Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBR*** P2 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin11y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the P2 December 2014 Exam.

*** P2 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P2 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P2 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Please note, the ACCA have asked us to allow posting comments only after 5pm UK time.
Former userFormer user11y ago#91
Since in the document it was saying that they were in a hurry to sell the Company (subsidiary) you should expect Forced sale = Negative Goodwill.
Ffaizan11y ago#92
Hey guys how u done q3(a)
Former userFormer user11y ago#93
I tink fr d contingent liabbilty,it shud be $6m wich is d fair value of contigent laibilty on. D date of acqn...bcos contingent liabilty ws later adjusted to $5m after acqn...so I tink $6m shud b used
HHong11y ago#94
Is that contingent liabilities recognised in SOFP?
Ggad11y ago#95
which question needed application or was about IAS 41 Agriculture?
Sseagoat11y ago#96
I think there wasnt any question about IAS41? Surprinsingly... Consolidation was tricky. If examiner intention was to fool me with thegoodwill well he managed to do that :) and I don't think i was good enough in written part so I don't expect anything positive.
Ttallaghthoop11y ago#97
Whats dissapointing in this exam is that no matter how much work you do to prepare you spend more time trying to understand the question than trying to answer the question in a reasonable way...some of the questions are so vague you dont know where to start...the ias questions were extremely difficult.
Ssonria11y ago#98
I got 10M goodwill for Hulty also but I was so stressed over my time management I didn't realize that it should be negative figure so I put it as positive... OH NOOOOOO :(
HHong11y ago#99
Strongly agreed with you! I was burned midnight oil everyday(11am-3am), since 3months before exam(September) and I covered all the syallbus althought there was some tips available on websites. But when I opening the question paper, it just seem like I am failed by P2. I even feel that do not want to finished answer the paper... Past year is more easiest compare to dec sitting...
Rrinku11y ago#100
can anyone remember the breakdown of question 2 please ?
AAdemola11y ago#101
I got a purchase bargain of 10 for hultby. That was pretty straight forward. The other dude was d problem.quit tricky. I got a goodwill of 51 Because I adjusted for the reduction in the liability. Wasn't sure
Sskantha11y ago#102
The total GW - 80
Ddragon7611y ago#103
I got both two bargain purchase GW, Any one have Margie GW (111)
CCraig11y ago#104
@tallaghthoop said: Whats dissapointing in this exam is that no matter how much work you do to prepare you spend more time trying to understand the question than trying to answer the question in a reasonable way...some of the questions are so vague you dont know where to start...the ias questions were extremely difficult.
that's how I feel completely! felt there was little chance to demonstrate my knowledge, now im wondering that I should have tried to explain the obvious a bit more - eg what a provision is .. but the questions seemed to beat you to it all the time stating this already qualifies for this treatment etc...
Ccristina8511y ago#105
hi guys I got a negative goodwill too! I thought I made a mistake maybe that was the examiner's plan to panic us.... I hope was correct... but I got confused on the buildings part and the valuation so I added the buildings again to net assets... I thought that might be the reason for negative goodwill....fingers crossed. Q3 was a disaster -andi attempted q2 and q4... hope good enough for a 50. Best of luck to all
Rrolake11y ago#106
Q1 was very cheap just two adjustment on Revenue recognition of a joint venture (If you read SA on revenue this is a bonus) and IFRS 5 very simple as well. The question states that the asset met the recognition criteria and to crown it all, it was within the twelve months limit. Measurements lower of CV and RA while RA is higher of Fv less cost to sell and value in use. I think RA was higher. And CV was lower. Just compare the difference between CV and the selling price. Again, the asset was said to be depreciated by $300k pa. Just porate I think the asset was sold 4months after meeting the held for sale recognition criteria. Adjustment (a) was on step acquisition from associate to control (gain on disposal was required), then goodwill. Adjustment to goodwill can only take place within the 12months limit and the contingent liability adjustment and Fair value of asset was within this limit so goodwill should be adjusted (again SA is sufficient on this). Hugh (subsidiary II) was very simple basic consolidation (F7). 1b. Share based payment (share appreciation) is vested immediately and should recognised and provided for. 1c. Ethics the entity needed finance and was considering doctoring it financial statements plus the new Financial Controller was eager to do that because he doesn't want to lose his job (F8) Knowledge was applied here. Part B was quite simple but I concentrated more on 1 for my preparation. Q4 relates to a question on my revision kit KEY. Q1 relates to GRANGE. Q3 IFRS 3, IAS 36 (economic life(30) or the life of the asset when it is due for disposal (10years)) ten was chosen by the entity INSTEAD of 30years. Then the asset has different components with different useful life which are 7, 10, and 30 I think. But the entity chose 30 for all. Which not in correct according to IAS 36. All in all, the exam was ok at least, for those who were ready. I wasn't well prepared but I won't lie. It was easy.
Former userFormer user11y ago#107
Yes, me too....I'm hoping that it's correct
OOLUWATOSIN11y ago#108
Got GW 50 and in H negative 10. Lord have mercy.
CCraig11y ago#109
does anyone know how to read the replies on here? - cant seem to - also can anyone tell me what qu4 a) meant about the significance and importance or the factors of impairment - i found that one really annoying - I think I made it far more complcated then it was meant to be - also what did everyone put about the appropriateness of the discount rate?
CCraig11y ago#110
@niknak said: does anyone know how to read the replies on here? - cant seem to - also can anyone tell me what qu4 a) meant about the significance and importance or the factors of impairment - i found that one really annoying - I think I made it far more complcated then it was meant to be - also what did everyone put about the appropriateness of the discount rate?
still cant see replies...
Kkcez11y ago#111
I got GW 50 and negative GW 10. I attempted q2 n q3. Treated guarantee on q2 as a fin asset, calculated gain on disposal of asset held for sale. Fingers crossed.
Former userFormer user11y ago#112
Craig...there are no replies to individual comments. The number of replies refer's to how many times an individual has replied to other people's comments.
CCraig11y ago#113
Thanks Kevin! what a fool I have been! - hope exam went well for you
BBaron11y ago#114
Goodwill was 89 for Margy and bargain purchase of 10 for Hulty
Mmywife11y ago#115
I got both two bargain purchase GW for M and H.
Ffrahmani911y ago#116
Goodwill Margy 110 & bargain purchase 10 for Hulty. Anyone attempt Q4 in relation to impairment - I related this to incurred loss & expected loss model
Yyeesh11y ago#117
it was HARD,,,
Former userFormer user11y ago#118
Would anyone know when ACCA will publish the answers?
Kkenny11y ago#119
Quite frankly, you'd have to be out of your mind to go looking at the answers now.... agonising over what you wrote (or remember writing), trying to do mental tots of marks you might or might not have gotten.... stomach in a knot for the next two weeks. I'll wait for the result.... if i fail then I'll have a look see where I went wrong, if I pass then I will keep on walking and never look back Don't do it to yourselves!
Sseagoat11y ago#120
Kenny very well said.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.