Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

General ACCA*** P1 June 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin12y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls and share your comments about the P1 Exam.

Please note, the ACCA have asked us not to allow posting comments before 5pm UK time. However you can vote in our instant poll immediately (Reload this page and post comments after 5pm) *** P1 June 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P1 June 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P1 June 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results
Oopentuition_teamAdmin12y ago#1
Sorry for the delay. topic is now opened :)
Aadman5012y ago#2
Wasn't too happy to be honest with Q1 nothing like I have seen in the Kaplan exam kit where there is a meaty question on the internal control system or goverance failures for a good 20-25 marks as opposed to 5 x 8-12 marks. Totally ballsed up the question on the internal/external risk audit question- 8 marks dropped. Q2 was ok though I think my definitions of business/finance risk were sketchy at best, hope my reasons made up for it though. Q4 seemed ok on the Kohlberg and ethical decision making, had to blag the rules based principles bit though... Overall I am very disappointed- no real work on reviewing internal control systems, stakeholders, sub committees or decision making models like AAA/Tucker and lack of Gray Adams Owen which was tipped by majority of providers. I thought this was a much more technical paper on defining terms than the usual application of models/theory. Interested to hear thoughts of others, but feeling downhearted after all the effort put in.
Eemmamc12y ago#3
Q1 was not too dissimilar to a mock exam provided by Kaplan with different questions. I used the AAA model in q1 for the decision on their choice of strategy and also mentioned truckers model. I commented that they were acting in a pristine capitalist manner. Found q2 and q4 ok also struggled to come up with the part you mentioned above but tried to write what I thought was relevant. Found it ok but I did have to stop and think about a few parts but hopefully enough done to pass
Ttonymc12y ago#4
Struggled for time took nearly 1 hr 45 for question 1. Dont think my questions had enough depth for all the marks. Here is hoping for a pass! Did anyone mention nestle in question 1 answer??
Aadman5012y ago#5
@emmamc which part did you use that on mate, if I can recall correctly a) was defining transparency, judgement and reputation bi) was why do institutional SH get involved in governance issues bii) should they get involved in the question c) why they should adopt a code of ethics and how it would effect decision di) risk audit process dii) interval v external with benefits of external I saw potential use in part c) but had the feeling it didn't fit the question well enough, as usually they would ask you to use a model don't they? I talked about responsibility to their stakeholders and CSR stuff etc. Could be well wide of the money though....
Ddani8812y ago#6
I totally agree with you. I didn't see the need to mention any models. I did mention CSR and responsibility to stakeholder like you did. The rest was to apply theory to the case given but no models.
Llunip12y ago#7
I think AAA model could of been used in Q4 for 'constructing an ethical case for Mahmood'. This only occurred to me after the exam though
Ppenboy12y ago#8
The paper didn't look anything like any of the past papers. I messed up on the internal/external risk audit question as well. The examiner has been trying to make P1 tougher since the last paper coming up with questions that off the beaten bush. Look at Q2 from the Dec 2013 paper on audit of a highly regulated industry. It's getting tough to prepare for the P1 exam.
AAMINU12y ago#9
I was a bit time pressed, may be I over shot on those topics I was prepared for, Lets hope and for the best I wish every1 all the best
BBenjamin12y ago#10
I didnt use AAA model for Q1 as well. It just used a conflict resolution method provided in kaplan text. Its like gathering the facts of the ethical issues, then highlighting the issues to the lower level, then middle level, then the board etc. Hopefully i get it correct. Overall this paper was tough to me
Sseagoat12y ago#11
I used AAA in Q4 although Im not sure if this correct approach. Im afraid i havent provided required depth in discussion in overall.... If this was F level i would say rather pass... but it can be a marginal fail since this is P.
Ddani8812y ago#12
I used tuckers in question 4. for Mahmood to see if he should report the case to external sources by asking himself is it fair, profitable, legal and ethical.. does this makes sense ?
Former userFormer user12y ago#13
i dont think AAA was relevant to q1 cos AAA is used when u have several option to choose from. anyway goodluck
Aadman5012y ago#14
I think for 4 I mentioned the reasons why he should report it because he is level 3.2 on Kohlberg, he tried escalating but got told to keep quiet, there was no mention of a industry regulator, the public has a duty to know etc. but then I said he needed to consider people may lose their jobs including his own and the SH may lose value....I don't know it's so subjective I could have got 80 marks could have got 20 haha...
Sseagoat12y ago#15
@dani88 i was struggling whether to use TUCKER or AAA. I started to writing Tucker but then crossed and stated AAA :)
Former userFormer user12y ago#16
i disagree with you. for q4 regarding mammod u could have refered to mamood as an employee and a professional and you need to bring the ethical issues involved such being obedient and loyal to be your employee but u need to observe the professional codes such as integrity or being honest
Sseagoat12y ago#17
Was he a proffesional ? I think it was only stated "junior employee"
Eemmamc12y ago#18
I used it in q1 for the ethical decision bit to be honest if I hadn't of used it think I would have struggled to structure an answer for it, just thought it's an ethical decision making model so can't go to far wrong.
Ddani8812y ago#19
he is not a professional to follow the professional rules. it's all about ethics and his dilemma whether to report or not considering that he loses his job if he reports it. It's very subjective true!!! I hope our reasoning is all good :)
Uumerkhayam12y ago#20
I found the exam easy, i didnt know anything about risk audit but totally nailed it with a bit of common sense :D and overall it was easy. Q4 a) Conventional-should not disclose, unclear if strict laws were in place. Q4 b) Effect on customers, Guilty of deceiving and effect on employees.
Former userFormer user12y ago#21
for me, this diet is better than dec diet. This is my second attempt to this paper. q1 was not that bad even though i struggled with id on internal and external risk audit, q2 was ok and q4 was not bad as well. i used tucker 5 question to justify why mahmood should go public in q4. goodluck guys, see u all smile come august 8.
VVipin12y ago#22
p1 is tough for me. q1 i did something good. i attemted q2 and q4. but i might fail.
Ddani8812y ago#23
do you still get marks if you use a different model and give good reasoning? i'm upset now :/
YYuchen12y ago#24
At first i think the AAA model should be used for Q4 However I changed my mind and used the Tuker's model as the question says "construct an ethical case for Mahmood whether tell an external source" so I think the question is asking for assessing THIS solution rather than listing alternative solutions and choosing the best one from them. So I used the five questions to assess the given solution.
Uumerkhayam12y ago#25
@dani88 you will get marks as long as your arguments were right like not some nonsense stuff, models shouldn't matter that much in P1.
Uumerkhayam12y ago#26
@dani88 i did not use any model in 4 b) either. I wrote about unclear regulations and whether company was in any breach of laws, effect on employees and main theme was customers being deceived by being sold a mix of high and inferior meat and being charged for High quality meat.
Eemmamc12y ago#27
As long as points are structured and relevant you will get marks :-) I only used some models to help me construct an answer otherwise I would have struggled but they were not necessary
Jjoevassallo12y ago#28
I think overall the paper was not that difficult but had a lot to answer/write about. It also concentrated a lot on risks, such as risk audit, financial risk, business risk, risk awareness, risk attitude and appetite, all terms which you need to know. There were no questions on internal controls as such and also very limited questions on Board of Directors etc (if there were any??) Re Q4 on construct the case for Mahmood I used the reasoning for as being the correct thing to acting as a whistlebower although he could face the consequences for that. The Company was trading unethically by declaring high quality meat when in fact it wasn't.... so on Re Q1 on Corporate Code of ethics and Institutional Intervention I answered this okish but would have preferred if I had more time to reword my answers better. Good luck to everyone!
Ddani8812y ago#29
ok that makes me feel better thanks. let's hope that we all passed.. good luck to all.. let's enjoy summer now :)
Former userFormer user12y ago#30
I attempted q2, I was wondering did anyone of you guys explained risk apeptite of BOB in the way I did. I firstly explained risk appetite and tried to analyse BOB risk appetite in terms of risk capacity and risk attitude. I said its like that BOB will only take medium risk because: a) Risk attitude: as he is wants to have return which will be high enough so that he can live his life comfortably after his retirement, this suggest he would not very risk seeking as he wants a comfortable living after retirement but not as much risk which might have high chance he loose all his fortune. b) RIsk capacity: it is likely he has a risk capacity as he might have inherited huge fortune, which will increase his risk capacity. So i said probably he will take modertate risk. Did anyone else wrote in similar lines?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.