Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

General ACCA*** P1 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share here with community your comments about June 2011 P1 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll

*** P1 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user15y ago#61
@drebels4 said:
yes, this was my answer too


My answer also.
Former userFormer user15y ago#62
I must be the only person who actually tackled Question 3!
ALACCA LOVER!!!15y ago#63
I did question 3 too.. hopefully we will get a additional minority answer mark or something!!! I read the recent article on non corportae governance but ended up not remembering much of the article except the Value for money audit and the 3 e's.

TOTAL Disaster for me, I found the whole thing to be a bit confusing to be honest, i felt in some cases i quite wasn't sure what the questions were getting at but i did not do as much prep as i intended and maybe wasn't used to the question style- my own fault though will have to prepare better for December. The controls for Q1... my mind went totally blank, i am so disappointed in myself at the moment. :(
Former userFormer user15y ago#64
I got the wrong end of the stick for Q4. I listed the 5 fundamental principles instead of the 5 ethical threats. I then went on to talk about how each of the principles could be threatened by the facts.

It has been a long time since I sat an exam (I am returning to it now after a gap of many years). So - the question I have is, should I expect zero marks for this entire part? Or in the experience of people who have taken exams more recently, it is possible that I might be penalised with zero marks for one area, in identifying the fundamental principles instead of the ethical threats, but might gain something for applying the facts of the case as threats to the 5 areas I mistakenly listed?

Just wondering.

Thanks.
Former userFormer user15y ago#65
I did Q1, 2 & 4 as well~ But sadly, I dun think I can score~ T_T
Seems like have to re-sit again~
Former userFormer user15y ago#66
it was an easy paper i say...i am not sure if i have done it correctly or not but i found myself comfortable with it. i did q1,2,3 and took 4 extra sheets...:)
there were too many things in q1 to contemplate...i tried to highlight as many as i cud...don no if i waz at a right track...in q1 i mentioned (NEDS) role as there part waz missin when the directors/board were takin decisions and than again audit committee role waz missin too...kohlberg waz grand...i put tsavos at pre con level, kathy con and fin director at post...
kathy @ conventional stage 3 : good interpersonal relationships bcuz she iz the only one having soft corner about the society and people...though she waz i guess loving her job more than anything else...
Former userFormer user15y ago#67
@squalk2008 said:
I got the wrong end of the stick for Q4. I listed the 5 fundamental principles instead of the 5 ethical threats. I then went on to talk about how each of the principles could be threatened by the facts.

It has been a long time since I sat an exam (I am returning to it now after a gap of many years). So - the question I have is, should I expect zero marks for this entire part? Or in the experience of people who have taken exams more recently, it is possible that I might be penalised with zero marks for one area, in identifying the fundamental principles instead of the ethical threats, but might gain something for applying the facts of the case as threats to the 5 areas I mistakenly listed?

Just wondering.

Thanks.



I did the same thing also. I am hoping that the examiner goes easy on me as well as yourself
Ssherlynlum15y ago#68
@tzxsean said:
q1) internal control measure + explanation
Kohlberg 3 levels
AGM vs EGM
usefulness of EGM on whistleblower issue
CEO statement on EGM
roles of CEO
argue decision based on pristine capitalist perspective

q2) criticise about beliefs on risk assessment
TARA on risks
what are related risks? prove risks E&F as positive correlated

q3) did not attempt
a) difference between charities and public listed companies. and how these differences influence the governance structure (9marks)
b) define 'transparency'. case for 'transparency' in HHO (8marks)
c) how AC could assist to mitigate the internal control deficiencies in HHO (8marks)

q4) IFAC 5 ethical threats
explain some they arises due to excessive gifts and hospitality in the case
critics behaviour
explain how it conflict with duty of uphold public interest
what is insider trading?
why unethical/illegal


Hi u have a good memory~ haha~
Former userFormer user15y ago#69
I think this sitting was better compared to the last, this was my first attempt though.
Hoping for a pass. should be alright.
Qqueenie15y ago#70
explain how it conflict with duty of uphold public interest..is it this Q we should write about the fiduciary duty and conflict of interest..all is about the duty of agent right?
Former userFormer user15y ago#71
I think it was easy, but not sure I've passed
out of time as usual...
I wonder how some people could attempt all questions, and have 10-15 minutes at the end to review the answers...
Former userFormer user15y ago#72
Hi there, the paper was OK.
The problem was only time. It wasn't as tough as I thought it will be considering the trend from 2007 to 2010. The trap is spending too much time answering q1. I totally got caught up with q1, running over time.... leaving 1 question (question2) completely blank! i didn't attempt it at all but had scribbled the answers in the question paper during the reading and noting time. It is extremely disappointing. now i just couldn't focus for p3.
nway.... good luck to all!
Former userFormer user15y ago#73
This exam I've started with Q 2,3
Q1 - at the end.
Aaccaman15y ago#74
@queenie said:
explain how it conflict with duty of uphold public interest..is it this Q we should write about the fiduciary duty and conflict of interest..all is about the duty of agent right?


I wrote about the public expectations of professional behaviour and gave a shortened version of IFAC's definition of 'the public interest'.
Former userFormer user15y ago#75
Dear Sirs/Madams



Would you like to tell me what application of three Kohlberg levels. What are the difference between level 1, level 2 and level 3?

Do all directors have social contract which show their responsibilities and their election period (usually 3 years) with company? If yes, is directors as social contract position?



Besides, does deep ecologist promote environmental issue in their position?


Your guidance is greatly appreciated. My e-mail address is honmeikc@yahoo.com.hk

Best Regards



Hon Mei Kuen
Former userFormer user15y ago#76
it was easiest in last 7 diets.
Former userFormer user15y ago#77
... not sure about the paper. It didn't seem 2 b too difficult, not straightforward either though. As per my previous experience you never kow what the eximiner wants to hear. I chose questions 1,3,4. 1a seemed to me the most confusing - "explore the problems surrounding fuel tank produce and internal control measures. I read the q a few times, it wasn't clear 2 me...
...re: Kohlberg, I don't think there was any post-conventional moral reasoning. Kathy only sugested what was expected by a society and considered both options. If she was post-conventional, she would go for an ethical option and didn't agree with the manufacturing of the cars that could kill...
2 months we have to wait, than we'll see - good luck everyone...
Aaccaman15y ago#78
I put Kathy at Stage 4 because of her comment about what society expect of them.

The CEO I put at stage 3 because he only cared what the shareholders thought

The other guy I put at stage 2 because he was only concerned for his own best interests (his bonus)
Kkzzrd15y ago#79
The paper was easy but i did so poorly due to time management issues. Q1 i overshot by 15 minutes and the rest they say its history.....did Q3 and Q4 but did a very huge stupid mistake of misinterpreting "Public listed company" as Public sector and wrote the answers around this....only after i came back home and saw the article "Non corporate governance..issue Oct 2010" that it struck me what dimbat i have been to make such a grave error and losing marks!!! and just didnt have time to finish questions worth almost 12 marks....i doubt whether i will get thru.......I need to pray really hard for a pass... :(
Former userFormer user15y ago#80
What I have noticed in Acca Exams is that the Difficult/Surprising area within the paper is mostly in Q1 -Reason to Shoot the B.P up to 200 to create initial exam hype :) however it usually is not worth more than 15 marks........Many might disagree however I attempted the paper upside down............
Q4- First
Q3- Second
Q2 - Did not even read it apart from the requirements
Q1 went as - D- First
C- Second
B- Third
A- Missed,it was better to miss Questions which create tumult as I
was always going to miss some other question worth those
marks but the one I would have answered better than Part A....
Just tried to collect 50 marks scattered through the paper......Hope Inshallah will Pass..............But Guarantee <<
Former userFormer user15y ago#81
The exam was OK, u know how it is with ACCA u think u pass and then. But (dear I say) I feel I pass it was a good paper. Expecially Q4.
Former userFormer user15y ago#82
I think the questions are not so much difficult, but I just still couldn't complete it. In q1, point d, I haven't attempted it. For AGM and EGM, I didn't prepared to learn this part.
Former userFormer user15y ago#83
@tzxsean said:
James Tsakos - pre conventional stage 2 : clearly bcos of self interest
bonus based on profit partly

Kathy Yao - when she follow orders of Tsakos, she is in stage 1 of pre conven
scared of punishment from Tsakos

when she suggest universal recall...it's post conven stage6 driven by self ethical principle

Finance director- I argue either stage 2 bcos he oso benefit from bonus or stage 6 as his own ethical principle is tat shareholder's wealth is most important


I think that James might on stage1 because he is afraid of financial loss as "punishiment". if there wasn't that financial director who focus on directors pay, i would say James is on stage2, but the fact is that financial directors is more like on stage2.

kathy is obivously stage3, for that her decision is to satisify public's claim in order to survive, rather than driven by ethical value.


and for Q(a) I would say the first part of question is more like a P3 question about project management, and the following part I write about features of a sound internal control system. but after exam i realised there might be something about agency relationship and problem i could write about.....any way feel much better that everyone think that is more about internal control.;p
Nnashwayo15y ago#84
zer was tarabhai in acca examination?
Former userFormer user15y ago#85
CEO & FD ==> Pre - Convential
Kathy ==> Convential

The only tricky part is if you assume that CEO is acting on what third parties(shareholders) want him to do, thus you may say that he is Convential. However this is just an assumption
Former userFormer user15y ago#86
@aelnakis said:
CEO & FD ==> Pre - Convential
Kathy ==> Convential

The only tricky part is if you assume that CEO is acting on what third parties(shareholders) want him to do, thus you may say that he is Convential. However this is just an assumption


This is my answer too~ ^^
Aahoatran15y ago#87
I thought I had done enough to pass but as soon as they collected the papers, I realised I screwed up by stating the 5 COPIC ethics rather than the threats, self review, advocacy etc.
Am kicking myself for that and am resigned to having to take a retake.
Former userFormer user15y ago#88
June 2011 ExamFor the post-mortem enthusiasts out there:
Mmikejosef15y ago#89
Any answer for question4 part b (10points). How you criticize a behavior?
Sssherazz15y ago#90
@mikejosef
was unethical not professional
againist the pubic intrest becoz other people were not invited to tenter they had right to tender for contract