Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

(Archive) Mentors and Mentoring

AWavian will15y ago
Hello comrades! Hope all's doing well. I want to ask a quick question about mentor meetings. It might sound silly but please note I am only trying to get everything as right as possible to pass The thing is although my mentor and I are in the same city, due to some practical restraints I am unable to meet her right now in person at a place. I'm running out of time so I do not wish to delay the meeting any further. So am I allowed to hold at least the first meeting with her on Skype? I will do my level best to arrange the next meetings face-to-face. Is that a problem if one meeting is through Skype and the other 2 meetings are face-to-face in person? Would appreciate any knowledge you share regarding the mode of mentor meetings Thanks a bunch!
Nnhung11y ago#61
Hi trephena, I'd like to ask about the new requirement for the mentor from P31 (ie to be listed). I failed to pass on P30, and intended to resubmit my RAP in this Nov period. If my previous mentor wasnt listed, would it be compulsory for me to change my mentor? I read in the Re-submission guide that as a student passed SLS, he/she does not even need to meet the mentor again if unnecessary. So I think that having to work with a complete new mentor in this case is quite time-consuming :( Thank you for your help
Ttrephena11y ago#62
@rong219 - you will still need a mentor to certify that the work you are submitting is your own, so unfortunately you will need to get somebody of the register. There would be both advantages and disadvantages of a new mentor. Some mentors offer a resubmission service which as you have posted a query on the 'Marker-speak' forum could be useful to you. A new mentor would be looking at your work with a fresh pair of eyes and may be able to be more constructively critical of what went wrong and what needs to be done to pass. A specialist service such as this is not offered by all mentors but may be worth considering. I know The Learning Luminarium do take on resubmission students - I mention this merely as a suggestion but ideally you need a mentor with the experience to help you focus on the weaknesses and what needs improving so that your resubmission is successful. By the way what topic did you do - was it T8 or T15 as you haven't posted this element on the other forum and might help me to give a better reply :-)
OMOBU Mentor | The Learning Luminarium11y ago#63
@rong219 - Trephena's answer hits the nail on the head. (And thanks, Trephena, for mentioning that we do have the resubmission specialization) To join in the discussion, the new mentor you get need not go through the 3 meetings with you since you passed the SLS. So it will not be as time consuming as before. However, she/he needs to be confident that the work is done by yourself. One way to do that is by keeping the mentor constantly updated of your progress. Also, we highly encourage you to find a mentor (it doesn't have to be TLL, just make sure its an experienced one) to review your report and point out/reaffirm how you can apply the examiner's comments. We have had students who approached us after failing twice because they misunderstood/misapplied what the examiner said. The anxiety inherent in a third and final submission is very unpleasant.
Nnhung11y ago#64
Thank you for your reply. It's T15, sorry I forgot to mentioned my obu topic.
Pphillipnjazi11y ago#65
What are the fee structure and in what currency
MMichael11y ago#66
Hi Team, I know that mentors for the BSc Applied Accounting - Research Analysis Project (RAP) now have to be registered with Oxford Brookes University and ACCA. If not a student cannot submit. Do you have a section within this forum where such registered mentors can enter their details for all students to see and make their assessment. I know you recommend TLL as mentor, but do you give students the chance to evaluate from a list of mentors who have entered their own details on this forum? Regards, Michael
Ttrephena11y ago#67
@michaelg - You need to register on the OBU Mentoring website and you will find a complete list of CURRENTLY registered mentors. You will then be able to select a mentor from there. ALL MENTORS ARE REMINDED THAT YOU MUST NOT USE OUR FORUMS TO SOLICT STUDENTS DIRECTLY.....AND STUDENTS ARE REMINDED THAT NO REPUTABLE MENTOR WILL TRY TO SOLICIT YOU VIA OUR WEBSITE. It is also actually against our forum rules so anyone who does contact you offering to mentor - or worse still - just sign off your work when they have not been through the full 3 mentor meetings with you instantly shows they lack any morals and is merely trying to profit from your situation and line their own pocket in the process. (We recommend The Learning Luminarium because of quality assurance and because OBU is cracking down on unscrupulous mentors. It is highly likely that mentors whose students are or have been involved in ACO cases will be removed by OBU from the registered list going forward. Some other mentors though on the list for now are regarded as 'suspicious' and if you allow such mentors to interfere with your work or unduly influence it your submission will come under greater scrutiny. OBU is keen to promote the need for integrity and honesty of mentors and as a reputable organisation Open Tuition endorses this policy.) CHOOSE YOUR MENTOR WITH CARE!!!!
MMichael11y ago#68
@trephena, Thank you for your advice. However, I also feel that your explicit recommendation of The Learning Luminarium as the sole mentor of acceptable quality out of a global universe of registered mentors, falls a little short of true professionalism. At the minimum, all readers of your forum deserve more detailed objective disclosure of the criteria adopted in your selection of this particular one over all else. As a matter of fact, more discerning readers are likely to think that you are in a beneficial arrangement with The Learning Luminarium (TLL), where it is in your best interest to refer students to them. My simple point is that your endorsement of TLL appears to lack full independence and objectivity despite futile attempts to make it so on your part. However, I agree that care needs to be taken in choosing any mentors (including LTT). Regards, Michael
Ttrephena11y ago#69
If you read the initial forum Advancing the OBU - Open Tuition Experience and my posts on some of the forums thoroughly you will see that it is a recommendation based on quality assurance but I inform students it is always their choice. In P27 one of TLL's mentees was awarded the prize for best RAP submitted worldwide - fact. TLL tutors are well qualified and experienced - fact. By contrast as I have contacts with some senior moderators at OBU (so have checked out TLL), I also know that certain mentors are definitely 'dodgy' - fact. My role is to safeguard the interests of students - for your information I am not an employee of Open Tuition (nor an employee/tutor of TLL for that matter) - I give of my time freely on the forums unpaid by Open Tuition. Open Tuition did however commission me to write the articles on our homepage to help those who are not given good guidance by mentors and most students have found my articles and checklists extremely useful. Having a 'direct 'line' as it were to some of the senior OBU markers allows me to dispense reliable and up to date information and help everyone produce a higher standard of work TOTALLY FREE OF CHARGE to the students on here. Due to my other commitments I do not offer mentoring myself but am keen to ensure that students do get this. Open Tuition and I have discussed the feasibility of recommending other mentors in addition to TLL but it must be based on experience (at least 5 years), integrity, consistently high pass rates (which staff at OBU will verify) and good value for money. I have checked some of the pass rates some mentors claim and those I have checked are false - so this in itself shows dishonesty and lack of integrity. Your personal attack on me seems to be based on a personal grievance that we refuse to allow mentors to directly solicit for students (and begs the question as to whether your real motive behind your posting was because you are a mentor trying to do so). Open Tuition itself like any business has overheads and staff costs in running and maintaining this site - so why should it permit random mentors some of whom are charging students several hundred dollars for a very average 'service' to use our forum as a free platform to 'recruit' their mentees??? Bona fide students are free to post their genuine comments about mentors but this is normally done when they receive their results on the relevant period results forum. (Those students who have posted positive feedback for TLL have done so voluntarily and as far as I am aware are fully authentic students who have used their services and in no way have been induced into posting their comments by neither me nor Opentuition). Contacting mentors should always be done via the OBU mentoring website if a student has no personal recommendation. As for my personal endorsement of TLL as you see it -this is in all students' interests as it sets a high standard of mentoring - and I hope it will inspire other good mentors to become greater mentors and to put their students' interests first. If that raises resentment then that quite frankly is not my problem but seems to be yours! ( By the way - Mutual respect is built into our rules and the OT ethos - so please read our forum rules! and also please refer to the section 'What we expect of you' on our homepage - your behaviour and the tone of your post above concerning me michaelg is NOT acceptable )
Aahmadriaz11y ago#70
How much you charge for mentoring?
MOM.Iqbal OBU Registered Mentor10y ago#71
Please read the Opentution rules regarding soliciting services on the forum. No rule and regulation abiding member of Opentution will answer this question.
HHafsa10y ago#72
Hi everyone..So I just completed f9...I want to start working on the project now..If you understand how to do it well..is it still necessary to have a mentor??Thanx in advance!
Ttrephena10y ago#73
Yes you need a mentor to certify your work and you have to do a Presentation to them. You cannot submit unless you use a mentor from the OBU list
AFAli farooq - ACCA member USA Chapter, CPA USA & BSc Registered Mentor10y ago#74
Dear Hafsa, You must have a registered mentor while preparing your project and hold three meetings (including presentation) with him/her. Your hard work and His/Her professional guidelines will be helpful for you to secure your good grade. Your bsc class has been decided by your average ACCA Marks. So As per my suggestion to focus on your grade now. If you need any further assistance, feel free to discuss here. Regards, ALI FAROOQ – ACCA Member USA Chapter, CPA USA & OBU Registered Mentor
AFAli farooq - ACCA member USA Chapter, CPA USA & BSc Registered Mentor10y ago#75
MENTOR QUALIFICATION CHANGES: We regret that due to continuing problems identified with some Mentors over recent submission periods, the original mentor categories are now required to be enforced. Oxford Brookes University has identified three categories of individuals from which students should choose their Registered Project Mentor. A new Project Mentor must be one of the following: • A current qualified Chartered Certified Accountant – Full Member (ACCA) – [not part qualified or Affiliate Members] • The student’s “Senior Colleague” at work e.g. line manager • A lecturer or tutor at an Approved Learning Provider IMPORTANT NOTES: • A prospective mentor applying for registration who is none of these may not automatically act as a Mentor for BSc (Hons) in Applied Accounting students. • Full members of other professional bodies may be permitted to Register at the discretion of the Programme Lead. • Oxford Brookes University may permit existing Registered Mentors to continue to offer Mentoring, subject to review. • if you select the category “Senior Colleague” we expect you to register a company email and that your mentees will be your colleagues only. You may have a maximum of 3 students per submission period. Mentors who defy this restriction and mentor other students will be suspended permanently. MAXIMUM NUMBER OF MENTEES: It is proposed that the maximum number of mentees that a Mentor may supervise will be 50 per submission period. [This will be confirmed.] It is expected that all Mentors have permanent employment that keeps then grounded in current Accountancy practice. Therefore it is considered by OBU that Mentors cannot professionally supervise very large numbers. It is stated again that Mentors claiming to be Line Managers/Seniors may only have a maximum of three students per submission period. If you need any assistance, feel free to discuss. Ali Farooq ACCA USA Chapter, CPA USA & OBU Registered Mentor.
Nnzeadall10y ago#76
Hello OT family, I have logged in the OBU site as a mentee since 04 Jan 2016 and contacted two mentors via the list provided and even got a confirmation email in my inbox saying the mentors have eventually received my request, however we are now on the 16 Jan and I still haven't got any reply from any of them yet. That's very discouraging as a first contact on the OBU site. Also, I would like to know why are we being compelled to contact listed members on the site while OBU clearly says that they do NOT approve these mentors, they are only listed mentors who have passed the mentor test online. I'm not discrediting any mentors, I'm sure they are very competent to have reached that level, my point is on TWO issues. a) familiarity / trust and b) Financial. Previously we could find ANY mentor ( in our local area whom we know and are acquainted with, they could have been our managers, seniors or a professional whom we know). Being familiar with these mentors not only allowed us being more comfortable with them in terms of communication and interaction but also in terms of proximity. We are in the same country and a face-face would be very easy ( though I'm aware this is not a compulsory requirement). My second issue is about the mentor fees. My goodness ! OBU is forcing us to find a listed mentor who charges at least £300. This represents more than a whole month salary for me. I could have arranged for half that amount under the previous conditions. I started ACCA as a self study student in 2012 and when I referred to the then OBU info pack, I immediately made up my mind to go for the OBU to achieve the degree. This was my main motive which has now been completely jeopardized by the new requirements. My concern is today even if we comply by these harsh requirements, tomorrow with a re-sit it can even be worse and we'll continue struggling and paying without achieving the degree. Your comments and views on this would be most welcome.
Ttrephena10y ago#77
@nzeadall - I can understand your frustrations. Regarding the lack of a response - I am surprised at this. I suppose it may depend on what their other commitments are at this time of year as many mentors are employed full-time elsewhere and if in a responsible accounting role could be involved in company year end matters or sorting out tax returns. Most students do not begin their RAPS till February /March so in that respect January is a month when possibly they lie low and catch up with personal affairs - who knows, but I agree it is disappointing for you A principal concern for OBU is plagiarised work or students copying from each other - something which has now reached epidemic proportions in the UK university system according to the Times Educational Supplement. Unfortunately in some parts of the world mentors are part of this scourge so by insisting on registered mentors, OBU hopes to control one element of the problem as unscrupulous mentors can now be delisted. All of these things tend to penalise the innocent as well as the guilty as you now find that you have to pay what you consider is an extortionate amount to someone to act as your mentor. Again I agree and cannot see how anyone can justify charging GBP 300 + for the 3 basic meetings - which is why currently we do not endorse any UK mentors. In fact the concept of paid mentors is relatively new - OBU originally envisaged mentors would be colleagues, supervisors/ line managers or a student's college lecturer I.e. someone performing the role for free. Unfortunately though others saw it as a money-making opportunity. I have always stressed that students need to feel comfortable with their mentor. You can still use a person known to you but they would normally have to be ACCA qualified and complete the online mentoring course (cost about GBP 85). However I understand that OBU is always willing to listen to student views so why not write the ACCA OBU Programme Diirector Jane Towers-Clarke about your dissatisfaction? Who knows, if you live in the UK you may even be invited to become a student representative and attend some of their programme development meetings. Personally I think to absolutely guarantee integrity and standards OBU staff should do the mentoring as they do on normal university courses but I suspect (a) OBU doesn't have sufficient staff hours and (b) would have to levy a charge of at least GBP 300 to pay staff if they had them to do it anyway.
HAHammad Ahmed Qureshi - OBU Registered Mentor10y ago#78
Hi, @nzeadall, Hope you are well! With regards to mentoring request that you have sent, there can be many issues why those mentors did not reply. May be mentors are busy, or they have not yet started taking mentees as you know its January and submission is in May. There can be several other issues, but i agree they should reply in reasonable time stating whether they want to become your mentor. This will help you in saving your time and finding other mentors. OBU website database contain number of mentors who are based worldwide, database maintained is of mentors who pass OBU mentoring course. This course is designed so all mentors know basics of mentoring i.e. what mentee require from them. OBU always recommend mentors to guide & direct students without actually doing their work. You may realise, since last few session there has been several changes to RAP guidelines which is more focused on mentors providing good service to students. One example you gave is of this mentoring course which resulted in mentors chosen are only in the database who meets specified criteria that they are ACCA Member, Your Senior Colleague (restricted to 3 mentees a session), lecturer at an Approved learning institution and have done mentoring course. Narrowing criteria and course helped in removing those mentors who have no knowledge of BSc RAP and OBU but they are acting as mentors because student wants them to be. Further, you can still select a mentor who you know, if he is ACCA Member, your senior colleague/manager or lecturer of approved learning institution. This may be helping OBU in segregating quality mentors and shrinking this list further in future. Previous rule was really open and led many problems, such as plagiarism, mentors selling projects or doing work of mentees in exchange for huge fee. OBU is catering worldwide students so there range of different issues, and i believe this rule of selecting mentors from their database help in reducing complaints of poor service and unethical mentoring which i told works like students were being offered whole RAP in exchange for money by freelance writers acting as mentors. I don't know from which country you belong but you may find any good mentor who provide face-to-face mentoring and as you know current world is of technology so you can develop most skills via online services too. Remember OBU's aim is to develop your skills, technical, interpersonal and academic. Hence, if you select an unfamiliar mentor there may be risk of poor service but if you research and look for good-one, it will benefit you more, in-terms of communication and learning. With regards to fee, it is on mentors discretion, currently there is no restriction as in case of ACCA Exams Lectures, some charge high, some low. I know GBP 300 is huge but you can find lower charging good mentors who charge between GBP 100 to 150. They do exist as GBP 300 is also equivalent to salary of many other students who are about to do their RAPs. Please also note that higher fee will give guaranteed service too and lower fee may have service problems. In the end, you can find good mentors in both fee ranges. Don't be hopeless, these requirements are for your benefit and i know you can achieve RAP within your desired goals with desired requirements. So, just search for the best mentor, contact more mentors who you believe can provide good service and work hard. In case of any question(s), please do ask. Regards, Hammad Ahmed Qureshi - OBU Registered Mentor.
Eewanyonyi10y ago#79
hello guys, am looking for the cheapest mentor anyone who can recommend one ;-) i have done academic projects and papers before so all i need is a guy to sign off my project.
HAHammad Ahmed Qureshi - OBU Registered Mentor10y ago#80
@ewanyonyi Hello, There is no cheapest or expensive one. There are good and normal mentors who follow BSc Info pack and they must be having 3 meetings with you for ensuring your project is upto mark. You can't find mentor who will just sign off your project as it is breaching requirements of OBU. Please don't ignore value of mentor as RAP require new skills which you may not have acquired previously. Regards, Hammad Ahmed Qureshi.
AAmy10y ago#81
Hey! @ewanyonyi & @nzeadall I read your post and I felt u are facing the same issue I had it. I would like to help you in this regard because I know what u are in to. I got recommendation from friends and talked with them about mentoring “honestly I like them all”. Their way of teaching are awesome as my friends told me about them. I found first mentor was Anna Lishman UK based Mentor. Her way of teaching was great, the only thing I had trouble with the payment. She charges GBP 395 me more than I thought. Second Mentor was Luminarium on OT Singapore based Mentor. I found them very helpful but again if I talk about the fee it was little more or less $500 which was beyond my budget. After going through all these I decided to search more Mentor way ahead that way I can shop around. I spend a lot of time to search different Mentor. As a student my concern was to find a best Mentor with best rate. My classmate recommended Mr. Ali Farooq like others. He is US based Mentor and charge reasonable rate. I found him the best in my first meeting. All of them are best and recommended. I recommend you to select the best Mentor with the best rate from the best countries it will be helpful for you to learn more than their mentoring. I spend my time to reply your post because I don’t want you to waste your time and money. Good Luck! I hope it will be helpful. Best regard, Amy
Nnzeadall10y ago#82
Thank you Trephena, Mr Hammad and amy2, I'm really grateful to all three of you for taking the time to reply to my query. I'm considering the precious advices you provided and will surely get back to you whenever needed I understand it's January, however I was not expecting a mentorship immediately, all I was expecting was a reply whether or not they are interested to become my mentor in the near future. However, as you advised I shall contact other mentors as well. @ Mr Hammad, will it be possible for you to provide me a few mentors within the range of £100 to £150? @amy2, how much Mr. Ali Farooq charge for the mentorship fee? Once again thank u very much.
HAHammad Ahmed Qureshi - OBU Registered Mentor10y ago#83
@nzeadall As any advertisement is not allowed by OT, so i am messaging you mentors. Regards, Hammad Ahmed Qureshi.
Ttrephena10y ago#84
I have always implied that when selecting a mentor it is 'horses for courses' in other words different people have different needs and some mentors are definitely more experienced than others. Whilst I maintain that it should not cost more than GBP 300 for a basic service it might be worth doing that for a really good mentorwho has an excellent track record (high pass rate, few if any ACO student cases) who is likely to help you pass first time. Remember a resubmission is nearly another GBP 200 for the resubmission fee and also means a delay in getting the degree (and you can only ever get a C grade) so using the services of a cheap but inefficient mentor is sometimes not the wisest choice. Students should contact mentors from the list to discuss prices not do so on our forum. (I suggest too that they ensure there is a clause in the contract that if the mentor is removed from OBU's list prior to submission they can get their money back because where mentors have assisted in plagiarism -and apparently OBU considers several have - they will be banned from operating as mentors)
Ttrephena10y ago#85
And if of course you are submitting for the 3rd time and obviosly need to pass you might need a more specialist service relating to a critical review. This is where an experienced mentor would mark and comment on the RAP like the actual marker and requires a mentor who has mentored for at least about 5 years and has a pass rate of at least 80%. Such personal service because it involves very advanced mentoring skills and a great deal of time is never going to come cheap.
AAmy10y ago#86
Hi Trephena, I have read your post after my answer, my sincere apologies for the inconvenience caused. I was not supposed to discuss prices on this forum. Hi @Nzeadall, You should personally inquire them and shop. Please visit the link below to search for the following Mentor by name: Adrian Tan (Singapore) https://learningluminarium.com/ Anna Lishman (United Kingdom) Ali Farooq (United State of America) https://www.oxfordbrookesmentoring.co.uk/mentors/view/list Don't forget to request a free career counseling class If you plan to go abroad. They can really advise you. Good luck!!!. Warm Regards, Amy
Nnzeadall10y ago#87
Thank you again Trephena, Mr Hammad and amy2 for your responses and advices. I'm really grateful for that. @ Mr Hammad thank you also for the mail I've received though I cannot reply directly on it. I went through the link you provided and found it very useful. Thank you very much
AAmy10y ago#88
@nzeadall you welcome :)
Ffirozahmmad10y ago#89
hi there , i am looking for mentor ,could anyone give me information plz.thanks
AFAli farooq - ACCA member USA Chapter, CPA USA & BSc Registered Mentor10y ago#90
@firozahmmad Kindly visit the below mentioned website and get full detail about registered Mentor and read pg 18 https://www.accaglobal.com/content/dam/ACCA_Global/Students/bsc/IP2015-16.pdf or register here as a mentee and contact with mentor https://www.oxfordbrookesmentoring.co.uk/ Before attending first meeting with your project Mentor, Kindly read an important areas of BSc info pack 2015/2016, make a list of questions and try to develop research skills. I am pretty sure He/she guides you well. Regards, Ali Farooq OBU Registered Mentor
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.