How was your March 2024 ACCA FM exam?
Vote in the Instant Poll
(Comments will be opened after 5PM UK)
FM*** March 2024 ACCA FM exam – Instant Poll and comments ***
Hi
Did anyone have question C about divisible projects ! In part B you had to do an NPV for Investment Z, the NPV was negative though as there were no cash flows coming in just a reduction in electricity consumption ! Not sure if I quote got this question ?
Hi,
I did get the same section C, from my understanding the ‘cash flow’ was the 27% saving from electrical cost.
I could be completely wrong
Yup - cash flow was the 27% electrical cost saving, less the 25% taxation. Think I got somewhere around $0.65m as the NPV.
That was such a hard exam I thought, even section A and B I found tricky! I think it’s definitely going to be a resit for me.
Just finished the FM exam got ratio question and Replacement NPV Question in section C
For the ratio question do you add the new Operating profit of 64.8 to the existing profit of 177 for the calculations? Same for the 360m investment?
Yes, had the same. Npv divisible projects, 27% are cash flow savings minus tax. There was a question about risk & uncertainty, sensitivity analysis.
Hi Usamaarshad1
I added them for option one , wasn't sure for option 2
Such a hard exam! The difficult ratios with different investments, sharia law financing theory, the divisible projects, part B had some tricky questions as well ??
I got that at first and then realised in the scenario it said that investment was required at the start of second year (so end of year one not in year 0 as it usually ihappens). That changed npv to 2 something for me.
I did
Arrr yes I understand it was a saving but it was not cash coming in as such, it was still cash that we had to pay for electric but it was at a reduced rate !! Arrrr I think I will be doing this exam again . I found section C very tricky
Thank you, yeh I'm not sure if I did that last ratio question right or not as the information given was for current year however the new project was for next year but the options were for expansion so surely the expansion projects are on top of current figures
Can someone recommend other forums as well where there's discussion about the march FM exam?
I agree with you Lisa, don't think examiner was very clear there as of what they have expected us to do. It didn't however state that electricity was only for this project alone and in what form savings would be received. I therefore assumed electricity was a cost that was incurred by entire company not attributable to this project alone. It did stated within scenario that npv was predicted to be zero based on assumptions that investment would be offset by the savings in electricity. Perhaps received in form of cash grant on which you pay tax? Doesn't charge fact the exam was very difficult and scenarios had a lot of distractions and some things weren't just obvious. I found section a and b very difficult and who knows maybe you nailed the multiple-choice questions and still grant yourself a pass, fingers crossed! : )
I had the same NPV question, it was quite tricky, I had a positive NOV of 4m, I just included the 27% as an inflow and the tax as an outflow. But I think I did the inflation wrong and the asset timing(placed it in year 0 when it should have been t1.
Also had the divisible projects, all I remeber is we needed 13m apportioned but one of the projects had 14m initial investment and NPV of 2.8M and this was a minus 200k on that specific project,so portioned against it. It should have had a total npv of 18.2m or 17.2m for divisible.
Did anyone else get this?
Did anyone has questions for replacement and EOQ in part C?
I actually have gone mind blank.
The question I got had the 4 years of cashflow for NPV, no tax, IRR, Payback, Roce and Talk about the investment appraisal.
Did anyone get this?
Junaid98 I had this question with divisible and none divisible projects and had similar answers but I've changed my answers on this last minute when I realised it said in scenario that project Z was mandatory due to government requirements to reduce co2 and 25m must have been used from the total 70m capital available so although the estimated npv by the company given in the scenario was zero I still included this in my calculation of maximum npv that could be achieved, basically this reduced my available capital by 25m. I made my assumption to clarify why I did that but not sure if that's correct. And yes you right one project must have been apportioned the spent was 14 but only fraction was available.
Hi NhungTruong yes I had those 2 questions - can I ask what you did for them?
I got around NPV 668K if i recall.
Hello, which part do you replace in question 1? Is it benefit from obtaining discount in question 2?
I got this question. How did you find it?
Hi Bella, I had the same question with various investment appraisals, and talk about usefulness of these investments used by the company. I q31 I had horrible factoring and settlement discount.
Hi, I had EAQ, Right issue or loan note to be issue(financing) question in Section C!
Had hedging one in section b £-$ and material purchases in Euro so much confusion, I just guessed most of the section B question.
I was absolutely lost with that the other question too for settlement and factoring.
I only went through it the day before
Section C
Task 1
Calculating:
Divisible and not divisible projects
NPV for unknown project Z
Writing:
Risk, uncertainty and sensitivity analysis,
Task 2
Calculating:
Ratios: Interest cover, EPS, Gearing
Debt or equity financing.
Writing:
Problems with high gearing levels,
Islamic alternatives for given financing options.
Hi FensiDziubdzius can I ask what you did for the ratios question?
I added the profit from the new project 64m to the current profit of 177 for the ratios
May I know other than the mandatory $25M invest for project Z , for the remain $45M can divided to project X,A &C to maximum the NPV?
How about the non divided project, $70M can only invest for project Z? I got confused for this situation
Tsuyoshi10 yes, from my understanding for divisible projects you can allocate as per ranking to maximise npv then if you have a leftover capital you can apportioned to most profitable project, where none divisible projects must only be accepted fully and cannot be split so you allocate by highest ranking at first then you look what you have left and if you can use on any other project even if the ranking isn't the highes, so you maximise npv. I first used the capital for project z as a must then as per ranking and I was left with 8m capital that I fully used on first project that cost 8m.
Namah1, I just remeber with this question, there was 14 million available and we had 13 million to apportion which gave 0.2mill off the NPV that needed to be deducted from one of the ranked projects. I didn’t include project Z but thinking about it maybe I should have but I’m sure In the question it said not to be included or deducted from the 70M
What was your answers on projects Z npv? I got around 4mill I think. I used the 27% of electric as an inflow and tax as an outflow.
Just need to ask you guys, for the gearing calculations I was blank because I didn’t revise this at all and plotted random numbers, would I get any marks for the recommendations?
Overall this was my resit, I scored 49 in my last one which was a bummer and really don’t want to do a resit again or I’m going to lose it lol.
Hope you guys smashed it!!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

