How was your March 2022 ACCA SBL exam?
Vote in the Instant Poll
SBL*** March 2022 ACCA SBL exam – Instant Poll and comments ***
Did anyone sit today?
Can’t find a thread on it?
How did everyone find it?
Q3 the investment one was tough
Yes I didn’t feel they gave us much information.
I had
Chairman and ceo roles
Merger
Letter to employees
Investment proposal - customisation vs sport fishing
Risks
E-Marketing
Yeah pretty much the same Q’s, the risk and emarketing ones seemed straight forward, the letter to the employees and the briefing note to CEO about organisational change not sure how we were supposed to approach that Q.
Tony
Was there any task with 2 parts except for the one where we had to (a)explain employees impact on organisational change and (b)write a letter to the employees addressing their concerns?
Hi. Yes I sat it as well been looking for the poll on here but it's not been set up. I found it a lot better than what I expected, literally was expecting a paper that I wouldn't understand at all. I just hope I answered enough to gain marks. I feel I went on a bit. Fingers crossed goodluck everyone.
Was there any task with 2 parts except for the one where we had to (a)explain employees impact on organisational change and (b)write a letter to the employees addressing their concerns ?
Thank you very much! :)
Also, I had no slide questions.
I think we were supposed to calm their concerns.
I put things like a consultation would take place
Employee participation
Training would be given
Resouces managed as they were worried about unpaid over time to move
Structure wouldn’t be biased on employees from different companies… no favouritism
I didn’t feel i used many models tbh mostly topic knowledge.
What did everyone write for the investment proposal?
For the investment proposal I said to go for the fishing yachts…I guess no wrong answers really if you gave reasons why
Fishing yachts had npv of 9mill and custom yachts had 3mill
But payback for fishing yachts was much longer
But after sale of land they 10mill to invest so couldnt do both. But first one meant they still had 7mill left not invested.
I said fishing yachts as had bigger npv but should see if longer payback acceptable to shareholders.
Got a bit stuck on the financial, non-financial benefits & drawbacks. Not sure i wrote enough on non financial.
Used a bit of porters diamond stuff for fishing one as was sales in other countries.
I got the case of Yexmarine
Q1 was related to a strategy committee
Q2
A) Change management Q how to manage the survey issues or something for each stage of change( I was stumped in this question)
B) how to address the concerns of the employees
Q3
Evaluate two projects and recommend what to choose.
Financial, non financial benefits and drawbacks
Recommendation with the reason why it was chosen
Q4
Evaluate the risi assessment, impact and the mitigating actions done by operation director as well as recommend further if needed
Q5
What are the benefits the company will get from acquiring the services of a marketing agency seeyatch co
It was quite a tough paper, mentally and physically draining because of the long hours. I didnt think I'll feel it cause it's just 45mins longer than the other papers but little did I know those 45 mins felt like I played a very demanding first half of a champions league final. Wow!?
Anyone else got this and how did you approach to answer these questions?
my exam froze when there was 15 min left and i couldn't do anything than clicking on the chat button. She called me via phone in the end but was frustrating not to know if everything got submitted and saved accordingly. Did anyone else have that issue?
Not sure If I di the risk assessments questions right (Data and Reputation risk). Data risk assessment as serious in the proposal but I said I disagree with it as it not very IT based so the risk is not that serious.
For sceptisitm skill I said there should be more mitigation activities mentioned
For Q with the impact of employees on the change process I said potential delays as they are too resistent and more time must be spend for encouraging them
for the Q how to address their concerns
Satisfactionary pay
Development opportunities
Extra pay for overtime
Communication
The investments options
Sport fishing higher NPV higher gross profit margin but high investment cost which means big financial risk
I got the question about Yexmarine. I ran out of time as I had only 10 mins going into the final 16 mins question. I am hoping that i can scrape a pass because I just can't with studying for this paper again. :(
It said that to pick one / recommend one IF any should be taken as a new investment so really could've said no to both because it was forecast for within 10 years and those margins weren't good and the shareholders or whoever wanted specific margins anticipated for 5 year mark at 45% or something so within 10 years those projects had ones still low for the target.
overall okay paper hopefully pass! but its hard as you never know if you'll get marks for what you actually wrote.
I chose dinghie and gave the following justification:
Having a higher return on investment of 135% compared to 70% of the premium yatch.
Also even the Npv was only 1.5M higher for Premium yatch however cost wise it was 6M more. They could make a saving here and invest in other lucrative projects.
Also I challenged the disadvantage of benchmarking targets using gross profit margins instead of npv.
I discuss around revenue coming in early for dinghi and this allows us to match it up with our working capital whereas in premiuk yatch we would need to borrow if there are cost overruns that was not estimated.
Payback period sooner than dinghie - less risky.
I mentioned discounted Payback should have been calculated to incorporate risk.
Also as Dinghi required simpler designs this could be something that we can leverage our core competencies with. The premium is what our competitors are offering but they have been doing this for a whole and they are likely to be better than yexmarine. Investment in this could be highly risky.
Yes. Same here. Answering in last question, the system is frozen and no responses from anyone of chat.
How was it?
What was the marking scheme for the questions? Anybody remembers?
I had the Yexmarine case study
Q1 - on the strategy committee suggested benefits and issues with proposal such as no FD or no independence on the committee
Q2a - To do with organisation change, was a bit confused (feel this question was not well written?) Discussed how rapid change can affect moral and uncertainty, employees feel they are not being heard
Q2b - In the letter tried to be reassurance, stated taking risk analysis on flooding, will provide training and employee representation on the board
Q3 - Evaluation of the two projects, I discussed each element and concluded with the Dinghies as they payback quicker, less risky and allow contingency funds to support other important strategic decisions
Q4 - On the risks of the move to Lympool discussed using the risk map and couple of other suggestions such as ensuring insurance cover loss of income in case of flooding and more proactive approach to the obsolescence products
Q5 On benefits of the e-marketing company, discussed benefits of outsourcing and the 6I's
I generally felt the paper was okay apart from question 2 which was a bit confusing and didn't really fit into anything i studied. It seems that there was a lot to study and only a couple of areas came up.
Best of luck to everyone, this is a mammoth paper in terms of things to know.
I could not understand task 1 hence no marks there for me. What was this about?
It depends on which question you got. There were two exams. One was about strategy committee. and another exam asked us to evaluate the Ceo's opinion of the roles between Chairman and CEO. That's question 1
The proposal to acquire and emarketing questions also had some differences.
I believe the only questions that were the same for all variants were question 2 (employee issues) and question 4 (risk question)
mohsintariq wrote:I could not understand task 1 hence no marks there for me. What was this about?It depends on which question you got. There were two exams. One was about strategy committee. and another exam asked us to evaluate the Ceo’s opinion of the roles between Chairman and CEO. I got the latter. which i find it was very easy, all I had to do was assess all his opinions and comment if its wrong or not and give recommendations
I could not finish the paper, left about 15 marks, and also had to really rush in the last few questions that i managed to finish.
No one seems to have time pressure by looking at the thread comments. no hope of passing then, i guess : (
Question 1 I had roles one. He seemed to have jumbled the roles of CEO & Chair. He had bits in wrong section. So had to put them back in right places. Was like a puzzle.
What did everyone put for the omissions bit of this question?
Only thing i could think of that was missing was in the Chair side & was protecting shareholders best interests. Mind went blank.
I agree Q2 A was very odd.
I put planning, design, implementation & monitoring stages as headings. Then wrote what i could. No idea if this is right or wrong.
I found Q2B ok.
What was the recommendation you guys gave for Q3 when selecting between the two projects dinghies and the luxury yatchs?
What did everybody say about risks? There were data and reputation risks and scepticism
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

