Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBLJune 10 Exams - Paper P3 was..... Post your comments here

Oopentuition16y ago
Please share here with community your comments about P3 exam!

[url=?https://opentuition.com/articles/surveys/acca-paper-p3-june-2010-exam-survey/]?Take our P3 exam survey
[/url]

Vote in our instant poll!
June 10 Exams  – Paper P3 was….. Post your comments here poll results
Former userFormer user16y ago#31
I did PESTEL for the envoirnmental analysis of Q1 (a) and also did a bit of r+c=C for the strategic capabilities part but didn't have time to answer the rest of the part a. I thought it was a lot to ask to add in stakeholders and (can't remember other part of Q1a).
Overall though I thought the exam was fair in terms of topics asked but very long. My lecturer had predicted Q1 to involve PESTEL, SWOT or value chain and that Porter's diamond and CMMI to appear somewhere.
Former userFormer user16y ago#32
Did anyone use the 6 I's (Integration, interactivity, intelligence, etc) for Q1 (c) when asked about using the web and email? I set out my answer with those 6 I's as headings and wrote 1 or 2 points on each e.g. can integrate renewal system with website for online renewals. I was quite happy with that answer but doesn't seem like anyone else here mentioned they did that.
Jjay1416y ago#33
Fergie yeah..u could use that but note that they asked for just acqurring new customers and retention..not membership renewal..
Jjay1416y ago#34
In my opinion,stage 3 exams should be more like what happens in real life..a business analyst wont be given 1 hr for that lengthy case....probably like 1 week!!..there shd be no ambiguities at this stage..
Jjay1416y ago#35
the c- part i attempted....but because was rushing so much didnt really apply it to the wet organisation..pity!!!. after so much hardwork and practice...
Former userFormer user16y ago#36
Q1 (a) environment (pestel), capabilities (9 m's) , stakeholder (mendelowe ) and msiion
Q1 (b) Use swim-lanes to find faults and solutions#
Q1 (c) ^i's of e-marketing

Q2 (a) ratio's (financial), synergy , fit , culture (non-financial)
Q2 (b) Porters Diamond

Q3 (a) Benefits of outsourcing
Q3 (b) Competencies of BA's - project mmgt ?
Q3 (c) CMMI and level 5 discussion

Had 20 mins to complete Q3 and thus rushed.handwriting suffered all the way through.
A crazy paper with long-winded scenerio's written by an examiner who is a stickler for models/rules.
This paper should not be such a nightmare to pass - it is made so by the examiner.

Third attempt after two 48's .
I feel I did well enough to pass but Mr Skidmore what's it to be...?
Ppaul1234516y ago#37
Nightmare, an absolute disaster.
1) Q1 was way too long. Had to rush other questions as a result.
2) i used PESTEL and stakeholder analysis but it was hard to find relevent info in case study for these.
3) That workflow diagram in part b was difficult.

Q2 was tough as well. Used factor, demand, related industry conditions but again there was no obvious info to use for these.

Q3 i had to rush so i cant even remember what i wrote.

Definately going to have to repeat. Depressing.
Former userFormer user16y ago#38
Hi Fergie

I used some of the 6I's = independence of loaction so can reach much wider audience an also inteligence.
Former userFormer user16y ago#39
Did anyone use SFA for Q2 A?
Mmakramm16y ago#40
Questions paper were too long, reading & planning time 15 minutes are not enough as compare with big scenarios and big big storeis in paper for 3hrs paper. i have writing speed problem and poor hand writing so, i could write enough where will be discursive question.
Ssuejune798116y ago#41
strongly agree with you. it was my fifth attempt on this paper, all the other 13 papers were one time pass. i got 3 times 48 and two times 47. i just donot understand this examiner. hate this examiner all it stuff.
@roseville36 said:
Q1 (a) environment (pestel), capabilities (9 m's) , stakeholder (mendelowe ) and msiion
Q1 (b) Use swim-lanes to find faults and solutions#
Q1 (c) ^i's of e-marketing
Q2 (a) ratio's (financial), synergy , fit , culture (non-financial)
Q2 (b) Porters Diamond
Q3 (a) Benefits of outsourcing
Q3 (b) Competencies of BA's - project mmgt ?
Q3 (c) CMMI and level 5 discussion
Had 20 mins to complete Q3 and thus rushed.handwriting suffered all the way through.
A crazy paper with long-winded scenerio's written by an examiner who is a stickler for models/rules.
This paper should not be such a nightmare to pass - it is made so by the examiner.
Third attempt after two 48's .
I feel I did well enough to pass but Mr Skidmore what's it to be...?
Former userFormer user16y ago#42
Qn 1a: I used PESTEL but got both the E mixed up (used environmental and emision. I totally remembered the wrong E). Mendelow matrix for stakeholders expectation. I listed members (Key Players), volunteers (keep informed), WWTFT (do nothing) and the government of Arcadia (Keep satisfied). Capabilities i used Finance, HR, equipment and intangibles (FHEI). Organisation mission: General
1b: General answering.
1c: Reach, richness and affliation. Wanted to include the 6 I but not enought time to do so.
2a: Ratio analysis. Financial measures.Only the GP margin and gearing is better than Swift. Non financial: Talk about Ashridge Portfolio (Heartland), BCG (Star), Ansoff (existing product but new market because of new country) and some general reasoning.
2b: Porter Diamond.
3a: Harmon Process Matrix (Outsource, therefore low strategic importance and high/low complexity) 6 general benefits listed.
3b: New/enhanced competence from Business Analyst (gave up due to lack of time)
3c: CMMI. Added balaced scorecard too. Reached optimisation (CMMI level 5) will improve learning and growth stage, which improves biz internal process, customer satisfaction which leads to improved financial performance for Pro-tech.
That's how i answered my P3 for today. hope can score 50.
Jjay1416y ago#43
sorry i just have to write again..coupled with the soooooo many types/models/matixes/functionsroles one has to learn!!! gosh!!!..do we really need so much info on just one paper...this is a classic example of information overload..infact, thats what shd be written on the ACCA site against this paper..information overload...u are faced with so much info that it gets confusing...did you say examiner used to cover I.T?...WELL..Info overload...
Former userFormer user16y ago#44
Completely ran out of time.

Spent too much time on question 1a, for the strengths and weaknesses - did a M model, oppportunities and threats - Pestel analysis. did a little on stakeholder mapping using Menlow matrix, and paragraph on Mission statements, this took too much time- it would have been better to use SWOT anaylsis instead.

by the time i got to part Q1b - i didnt even bother reading the question, on what i was suppose to do. had just written about BPR.

Q1c - cant really remember the question but i talked about customer relationshipment management.

buy now i only had 45minutes to do rest of the paper, which a had not read the senarios for. Did Q2 and Q3 completely rushed. In only spent 15mins on last. did write anything for Q3b.

must ask did anyone bother with question 4??
Former userFormer user16y ago#45
I did Q1, 3 and 4.
Q1 b was about problems in the process flow
I found few faults in the lanes but not sure about perfection.
First problem: members were not responding to payment request.
Members were geting membership card and booklet before the clearance of payment. The process of payment clearance from finance department and process of membership card were not interacting with each other.
Second problem: some members were getting renewal notices even after payment.
I think it was due to combined effect of backlog and sending of renewal notices one week before the date of renewal.
Third problem: some members were not getting renewal notices at all. It was also due to the second renewal request where the member's status was marked "lapsed". But the first renewal request was only sending notices to current member and not to those who were marked lapsed in the previous cycle of renewal notices. So such members were in the system but not active and hence they were not getting renewal notices

Coulnt touch Q4b due to less time.
ahhh done, exams over and now world cup.
Ssuejune798116y ago#46
i did the survey and hopefully they will do something
Former userFormer user16y ago#47
Did 1, 2 & 4. Tough exam!! I hope for 50%. very rushed.

Question 1a: too many models came to mind, not enough time; just wrote common sense very loosely based on a mix of swot & pestel.
1b used harmans BPR, main suggestion was the software they use is likely the root cause of the problems, consider using bespoke system.
1c used 6I's for some ideas, but mostly common sense.

2a compared a few key ratios, common sense, commented on ashridge matrix and JSW parenting (parental developer)
2b Porters diamond; fairly straightforward.

4a mostly common sense; appraisal method seems very haphazard, not fair, teacher had little control over some performance measures etc.
4b know very little about competency frameworks, id be very happy if i got 5/10 for this part.
Former userFormer user16y ago#48
I did 1,2,3 and spent about 30 mins on reading only question 1....paper was ok..but it is so lenghty....just say finger crossed...

as far as Specific model is concerend...its reallly depends on the quality of answer..how relevant it is..if any body use SWOT..but it is relevant and make sense...will get mark...
all the best for result
Former userFormer user16y ago#49
@gagsingh said:
Yh i passed F7 and missed out the cashflow question (q3 i think)!

I agree that the exam was really long, the texts where far too lengthy too read in the first 15 minutes!

Lets hope they take this into consideration when they mark it!


They will not take anyting into consideration as they have to earn money!!! :D
Former userFormer user16y ago#50
@jodukwe said:
In my opinion,stage 3 exams should be more like what happens in real life..a business analyst wont be given 1 hr for that lengthy case....probably like 1 week!!..there shd be no ambiguities at this stage..

Exactly!... what do they expect? that a client comes to me with a business problem.. and I give him consultancy with strategy for the next 10 years? this is ridiculous.. how you can possibly attend all these questions in 3 hours? this is absolutely unfair to know all the topics and to fail... so.. is it ethical? :)
Former userFormer user16y ago#51
Did anyone think to use Porters 5 forces for 2a? Thinking about it now, it makes sense as the question made specific points related to barriers of entry / supplier power/ rivalry....?
What do you think?
Former userFormer user16y ago#52
paper had lots of information and when i saw the first question i felt like someone please pinch me.... he he... wrote PESTEL the a of question 1 and also mendelow's analysis, in question b i said that problems were substantial backlog not processed, only one week for renewal payment and than the customer would be lapsed and even the repayment cheque had to go through whole the process again even if it was wrong dated, question 2 used the same ratios which were given but non financial factors like hardworking, ethical people, no rivalry in 19 out of 20 region of Ecuria, good infrastructure, privatisation, low tax rate (out of 1200 pbt only 50 was deducted as tax, just 4%), unmatured market..... and in 2b i used porter's diamond same points but just differant grouping... then did que 4 perf. appraisal was horrible, manager went to pick up children, so funny, uncontroled mesures for appraisal and many other probs, didnt knew a lot about competecy framework but wrole general sense and how to use it in national college and IMF... long paper, i hope to get 50...
Former userFormer user16y ago#53
Question 1 was a mess. I did PESTEL and Stakeholder analysis (didn't finish) .. that senario was all over the place and I just couldn't figure out how to pull everything together.
Bbilgic16y ago#54
it was just too long. 4 pages for one question!!!!

Did PESTEL,Stakeholder Matrix and SWOT in Q1
Did Ansoff and Ashridge in Q2
Did CMMI model in Q3.

I really hated this exam.
Rrishid316y ago#55
I did 1,2,3... I took 25min to read the case in q1 used PESTEL, SWOT, Mendlow and just talk about mission. It was to much for part a. Q2 was ok but to much to do that time was running out as I only had an hour to do the option que. For the first time in all my acca exams I used a whole booklet but still feel i did not go into details as the time was running out....hoping for a 50 it all I need to finish. Dont want to see P3 again wrote it to many time..... Exams over to just have fun now ppl.
Former userFormer user16y ago#56
@accaite said:
***** GUYS, please read this for your own good!

I see alot of you thought that the exam was really lengthy and we couldnt possibly have applied all our knowledge given the length of scenarios and the time available. Kindly visit


https://www.webropol.com/P.aspx?id=448095&cid=92084973


and post your comments and concerns there. If alot of students say the same thing, our voice will be heard and the time factor will surely be taken into account giving us an edge.....

i did part, now its you guys turn!!!!


I have done this, i urge everyone to do this, as this was an impossible paper for time! It might make all the difference in the end!
Rrishid316y ago#57
I did 1,2,3... I took 25min to read the case in q1 used PESTEL, SWOT, Mendlow and just talk about mission. It was to much for part a. Q2 was ok but to much to do that time was running out as I only had an hour to do the option que. For the first time in all my acca exams I used a whole booklet but still feel i did not go into details as the time was running out....hoping for a 50 it all I need to finish. Dont want to see P3 again wrote it to many time..... Exams over to just have fun now ppl.
Former userFormer user16y ago#58
I am sooo disapointed with this examiner,this is the longest papert ever.Spent a lot of time doing question 1,really long and detailed questions.Can we say something to ACCA so they consider this when marking the paper.I'm so frustrated.Guys what do you think about saying something to ACCA?I spent a lot of time and all my energy on this paper
Former userFormer user16y ago#59
it was very short time.
i spent all my time on Q1 and only haves 1 hour for laast 2.
i didnt get 1b at all (15 marks membership renewal process)

otherwise difficulty level of question was not that high
Former userFormer user16y ago#60
p3 was my fourth attempts,in the past three sits,i can only finished half of the questions,(41,46,47)this time,it took me half an hour to read the question 1, hopely only Q3b 7( mark)left untouched. i am very poor at english, so p3 is really tough for me.:(( i am thinking maybe i should quit....