FM*** F9 September 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
I managed to do 12 of the mcq in reading time, still ran out of time on question 5. Think mcq were ok, Q1 and 2 were good then things went down hill......
I said lease rather than buy.
Wrote loads on gearing, dividend cover etc. Hopefully some marks there.
I said bank offering 3.5% to 4.5% was good as it eliminated some risk.
I guesstimated what marks i should get, came out as 55%, will be happy if thats right.
F6 up next in December. Start studying for it tomorrow and try and forget f9 exam.
I said number attending for school mcq, cost is efficiency not effectiveness was my thinking.
one of the mcq i kept getting 4.99% closest option was 5.1% so went with that, think it was mcq20
@saiga said: Which statement about effectiveness in msq was incorrect?I believe it was cost per student as this is efficiency rather than related to objective of learning.
Yes I was also getting 4.99% and spend a lot of time on that question because I kept thinking maybe i am missing something.
ROCE and ROE neither targets were met.
Think I got the translation, transaction risk wrong, because I chose all 3, but going by Bryan's explanation there wasn't any translation risk.
I hardly had any answers as C. Out of 20 MCQ's maybe 2 or 3 were answer C.
why why why..... there wasn' t a WACC question ( usually its 10-15 marks)
mcqs question were tricky
question on interest was a nightmere!!
Horrid exam I thought.
The investment question (Q4 I think), I re-drafted the financial statements based upon the info the did some ratios to pit against the market averages and worked out some shareholder wealth ratios to satisfy that requirement. Did anyone else re-draft F/S or have I gone off piste here as seemed to take too much time for marks available?
tough
lease n buy and forex was disaster
Third time attempting this stupid paper, a complete mess:-(
hi. I thought question on valuation companies was difficult and I found this acca article on valuations. I think this can be useful for next session.
https://www.accaglobal.com/content/dam/acca/global/PDF-students/2012s/sa_feb12_f9_valuationsv2.pdf
I used the net asset model the dividend model and for the income based approach I want sure and did profit after tax divided by the efficiency yeild I think it was? :/
F9 multiple choice was by interpolation.Whoever passes this Paper will better be able to P4 as for me its Performance i like it.
I thought this exam was proper time pressured.
Q1) This was a managing stock question which required to analyse the impact a proposed discount would have on the cost of ordering (CO), Cost of Holding (CH) and purchase price. I do not think it required to use the actual formula which had the square root involved, rather just calculate: CH = CH x Q/2 and CO = CO x D/Q and purchase price. The end result was that the discount was more prefered as you get a reduction in cost. This question was very similar to a pass exam question. I did not get part b when they asked about the tresury department? did anyone understand that? I just wrote about why it is important to hold cash?
Q2) This was a business valuation question. The way they worded the question was tricky, but I think they were asking for the Net asset valuation model after taking into account the reduction in recieveables etc so it was the liqidation basis. Then The earning yield method, as they gave this percetage in the question. Which is earning/earning yield. the last model was the DGM model. Part B required to say the disadvantages of using a cash basis model? was this just evaluating Dividend growth model?
Q3) was a complete write off. I did not understand any of it. I thought they were going ask a money market hedge question and compare it to a forward but did not expect a full on theory question. I just wrote that the ways to reduce risk were things such as matching concept, lagging and leading etc not sure if that was right?
Q4) Evaluating the use of debt finance. I calcuate stuff like the interest cover once taking into the account of the 8% interest of the 20M raised and made a revised income statement based on the increase in sales and stuff. Then calcuated new gearing, and EPS? thats all, am not sure if there was anything else? EPS Rose so it was an increase in shareholder wealth? there was no info on the share price so it could not be calcuated? or could it? there was no P.E either.
Q5) what a complete write off. They did not give any cost of capital!! I am assuming this question wanted us to do an NPV calcuation based on the five years. There was no corporate tax caculation as there was no operational flow (Sales less Fixed cost & V.C given) therefore, it was just the tax relief obtained from leasing and the lost scrap and lost W.D.A that was obtained from year 2 to 6 even though it was a five year life cycle, the tax was paid in arrears as stated in the question. The overall affect was lease was better. The discount factor to use was 10% subtract the tax of 25% which makes it 8%? But it was debateable if you was suppose to use the fisher equation as there was inflation involved? I am not fully sure about this because it would of been (1+8%) x (1+4.5%) = (1 +i) i being the nominal cost of capital. But in the equation the inflation part needs to be a general rate, but in the question it was specific to the buy option. so I do not know!!
Multiple choice question: It was defo the cost per student that was not efficient, this is because cost is relating to economy (i.e cheapest price objective)
R.O.C.E and the other one - it was neither.
Q1 - it was just transaction and economic risk because it was dealt in a foreign currency. Translation was not the answer because that would mean it would have an effect on the balance sheet, but the questions stated that this was netted of to nil at the end of the year. so it was no effect.
Really struggled on the question which asked to evaluate the % obtainable from the note to maturity? any one else choose 5.1%? the options were either 1%, 5.1% or 7.99% or 7.5% or something?
The multiple choice questions were to hard and worth to much of the paper. one slip up and it basically costs you. hate them!!
Hope that helped!!
It was a nightmare. I think I attempted about 60% of the paper and I have to be really really lucky if I get 50 marks...
@hassan1123 said: I thought this exam was proper time pressured. Q1) This was a managing stock question which required to analyse the impact a proposed discount would have on the cost of ordering (CO), Cost of Holding (CH) and purchase price. I do not think it required to use the actual formula which had the square root involved, rather just calculate: CH = CH x Q/2 and CO = CO x D/Q and purchase price. The end result was that the discount was more prefered as you get a reduction in cost. This question was very similar to a pass exam question. I did not get part b when they asked about the tresury department? did anyone understand that? I just wrote about why it is important to hold cash? Q2) This was a business valuation question. The way they worded the question was tricky, but I think they were asking for the Net asset valuation model after taking into account the reduction in recieveables etc so it was the liqidation basis. Then The earning yield method, as they gave this percetage in the question. Which is earning/earning yield. the last model was the DGM model. Part B required to say the disadvantages of using a cash basis model? was this just evaluating Dividend growth model? Q3) was a complete write off. I did not understand any of it. I thought they were going ask a money market hedge question and compare it to a forward but did not expect a full on theory question. I just wrote that the ways to reduce risk were things such as matching concept, lagging and leading etc not sure if that was right? Q4) Evaluating the use of debt finance. I calcuate stuff like the interest cover once taking into the account of the 8% interest of the 20M raised and made a revised income statement based on the increase in sales and stuff. Then calcuated new gearing, and EPS? thats all, am not sure if there was anything else? EPS Rose so it was an increase in shareholder wealth? there was no info on the share price so it could not be calcuated? or could it? there was no P.E either. Q5) what a complete write off. They did not give any cost of capital!! I am assuming this question wanted us to do an NPV calcuation based on the five years. There was no corporate tax caculation as there was no operational flow (Sales less Fixed cost & V.C given) therefore, it was just the tax relief obtained from leasing and the lost scrap and lost W.D.A that was obtained from year 2 to 6 even though it was a five year life cycle, the tax was paid in arrears as stated in the question. The overall affect was lease was better. The discount factor to use was 10% subtract the tax of 25% which makes it 8%? But it was debateable if you was suppose to use the fisher equation as there was inflation involved? I am not fully sure about this because it would of been (1+8%) x (1+4.5%) = (1 +i) i being the nominal cost of capital. But in the equation the inflation part needs to be a general rate, but in the question it was specific to the buy option. so I do not know!! Multiple choice question: It was defo the cost per student that was not efficient, this is because cost is relating to economy (i.e cheapest price objective) R.O.C.E and the other one - it was neither. Q1 - it was just transaction and economic risk because it was dealt in a foreign currency. Translation was not the answer because that would mean it would have an effect on the balance sheet, but the questions stated that this was netted of to nil at the end of the year. so it was no effect. Really struggled on the question which asked to evaluate the % obtainable from the note to maturity? any one else choose 5.1%? the options were either 1%, 5.1% or 7.99% or 7.5% or something? The multiple choice questions were to hard and worth to much of the paper. one slip up and it basically costs you. hate them!! Hope that helped!!Hi, Thanks for sharing your information and refreshing my memory, let me share my information as well. Q1. EOQ: Discount is preferred. Centralized treasury department is covered by BPP. Benefits include: centralized liquidity management, cheaper bulk borrowing, better investment opportunities, smaller pool of contingent fund, able to hire treasury expert, better foreign exchange risk management. Q2. Agree with your part A. Part B, disadvantages of DGM include constant dividend growth rate, constant cost of equity, cannot be used for companies not paying dividends. Q3. Part A: The FRA offered by bank is 4.5%. If interest in 3 months time is higher, bank pays the company, if lower, company pays bank Part B: Interest payment in 9 months time is subject to foreign exchange risk. If euro strengthens against dollar, the company lose out. If euro weakens, the company gains (it is likely that euro will strengthen as the forward rate is quoted at premium). This can be managed by forward contract, or money market hedge (then I briefly explained the forward rate that can be fixed now, or use spot rate, convert into euro and deposit for 9 months). Part C: Explain interest rate parity, purchasing power parity, and expectation theory. Q4: Redo balance sheet and income statement after the expansion, then calculate financial and operational gearing, interest cover, ROE, and EPS and compared with industry average. I concluded that the expansion by loan note is financially acceptable as it can increase shareholder wealth without increasing financial risk too much. Q5: I used 8% as discount rate, but I think the correct rate to use is 6% (8% X 0.75). Time was not enough so I overlooked it. Hope we can do well!
Was confident in lead up...was confident with the MCQ's which i thought were easier than June-15 but for some reason total mind block on some of the others....Agree that the examiner loves the business valuation and seems loathe to ask a WACC calculation....reckon could be 5% either way of 50
Oh dear, I studied so hard for this paper and yet found it very challenging. MCQ were so time consuming and somewhat difficult. Part B was also very demanding: almost impossible to complete within the stipulated time. Really pray I make the pass mark. Goodluck to the rest of you!
F9 was a very bloody paper I hardly wrote anything in section B
F9 was too too hard for me but now I think am gona read P4 books to come and do F9
I agree with Shad77
Disaster. I'll resit again on December.
I get "D" at most of the MCQ. Anyone similar?
Cost per student was the incorrect answer........on mcq about effectiveness
I think the paper was okay.........the only mistake we make as students is trying to establish a trend on what is likely to come in the exam. What is important for someone studying to become a professional is to know most if not all the basic knowledge before the exam
I think F9 this September was very tricky. I felt so overwhelmed and worried when reading the exam. I struggled a lot to try doing all exams. I need a lot of lucky to pass F9 in this attempt. Hope that there is a miracle somewhere.
Wow I wish I had this knowledge when I sat the exam.
I'm definitely reading the student articles from now on!
Thanks for the post =)
Tricky, tricky questions all over Sec B.
@louisedowling85 said: Will open tuition put up answers to the examThe ACCA will not be publishing the whole of the September exam - only part, and not until after the December exam anyway. "With the introduction of the four exam sessions, we will continue to publish the same number of exams, two per year, and at the same times, after the December and June exam sessions. These exams will be compiled from questions selected by the examining team from the two preceding sessions. That is, they will not reflect the entire September or December exam, for example, but will contain questions most appropriate for students to practice. "
@johnmoffat said: The ACCA will not be publishing the whole of the September exam - only part, and not until after the December exam anyway. "With the introduction of the four exam sessions, we will continue to publish the same number of exams, two per year, and at the same times, after the December and June exam sessions. These exams will be compiled from questions selected by the examining team from the two preceding sessions. That is, they will not reflect the entire September or December exam, for example, but will contain questions most appropriate for students to practice. "Really? Did acca say this? I cannot find this comment. I think regards to MCQ they should publish it all for practice for students. Will open tuition be putting any MCQ answers up atleast please? Also the above comment does that mean past paper won't be unavailable too or just the answers for sep exam? I would like a copy of the F9 past paper for sep 2015.
Of course the ACCA say it, otherwise I would not post it!! We don't invent things!! :-)
It is printed above all the indexes of past exam questions on the ACCA website (there is a heading that says 'Publishing past exams for F5 to F9' - try clicking on it.)
How on earth can we put up answers to the MCQ's when we are not able to see them?
As usual, when they do publish (after the December exams) then we will put up our suggested answers to whatever they make available.
Their statement is pretty clear. They are going to publish questions and answers every six months as they always have. They are not going to do it four times a year now that there are four sittings.
You might like a copy of the September 2015 F9 exam, but (as the statement says) you are not going to get one.
With regard to practicing MCQ's, we have an online MCQ test which selects 20 questions at random from a large bank of questions (so every time you try it you are likely to get different questions).
For more practice you need to buy a Revision/Exam Kit from one of the ACCA approved publishers, because they have lots of exam standard questions to practice on.
Hey John sorry I did not understand first time round that is very clearly explained :) Well as a start I hope I pass f9 this time and not need to think about looking at F9 again haha!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

