Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AA*** F8 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments***

Oopentuition13y ago
Post your comments about December 2012 F8 exam.

Please vote in our Instant Poll
*** F8 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments*** poll results


Please note:
Remember that you are studying for a professional qualification - do not make postings that are abusive or threatening.
Jjazibali13y ago#1
1st 2 questions are easy but 2nd last and 3rd 1 is difficult...:D
overall passable paper...I hope so i will be passed...
Jjazibali13y ago#2
Allah Pass kary ga...
Kkhizrak13y ago#3
Question 3 was a bummer. Rest was fine. Even had trouble with question 5. What were the answers to Fuschia and the other part of question of impact on audit report'. What were the impacts? Part a and b? PLEASE answer
Kkhizrak13y ago#4
When will the exam question paper and marking scheme be uploaded?
Kkhanasad13y ago#5
@khizrak said:
Question 3 was a bummer. Rest was fine. Even had trouble with question 5. What were the answers to Fuschia and the other part of question of impact on audit report'. What were the impacts? Part a and b? PLEASE answer



a) disclaimer of onion, it is unable to form an opinion.
b) the matter should b disclosed n the emphasis of matter paragraph.
Kkhanasad13y ago#6
@khizrak said:
When will the exam question paper and marking scheme be uploaded?

a month b4 result, i guess
Ppicolina197513y ago#7
To be honest I hate discussion exams, But this one was quite easy.
I don't think that it should be disclaimer in 5.
I think it should be modified for Daisy on "except for" basis. It was impact only on revenue and receivables and other was fine. Financial statement was also made before issues, so probably it was fine.
And for Fuchsia I think it should be adverse opinion if the issue wasn't resolved and management doesn't want to disclose cash outflow in FS. Who with me?

I answered to all. Probably not all will be correct, but I hope I've passed this boring one:)
Ppicolina197513y ago#8
...and it is time to repeat F9 for tomorrow now...
Former userFormer user13y ago#9
I put adverse for Fuchsia as well.

Though for Daisy, I have the disclaimer of opinion because of the materiality of the issue. (also, revenue wouldn't be affected right? I'm thinking only receivables are affected?)

Also yes, I'll have to repeat for tomorrow's F9. The paper I fear the most this semester ._.
Kkhanasad13y ago#10
i think if the auditor cant find sufficient and appropriate evidence based on which they give their opinion and the matter is material, then they should say that we r unable to form an opinion. and if u remember in the question it was clearly said that the virus destroyed all the sale record, the management only know the balances without any supporting documents. so nooooo evidence....
Former userFormer user13y ago#11
I put fuchsia should prepare F/S on a breaking up basis but that's probably wrong :(
VVipin13y ago#12
all questions were easy.
q.no.1 was to find deficiency.
adv and disadv of CAAts
q.no.2
as usual knowledge qns. it was easy
q.no.3
audit risk and auditor's corresponding response
q.no.4
it was toughest and trickest
audit procedures
q.no.5
audit reporting
it was easy.
VVipin13y ago#13
@khanasad said:
i think if the auditor cant find sufficient and appropriate evidence based on which they give their opinion and the matter is material, then they should say that we r unable to form an opinion. and if u remember in the question it was clearly said that the virus destroyed all the sale record, the management only know the balances without any supporting documents. so nooooo evidence....

disclamer of opinion is appropriate
sales revenue, receivables and profit could not be recoreded . not just one area.
for fuschita
it is adverse or qualified but i wrongly wrote it could be qualifeid or disclaimer. made mistake there
Former userFormer user13y ago#14
@brisi81 said:
I put fuchsia should prepare F/S on a breaking up basis but that's probably wrong :(

i think thats right. if the issue is not resolved it is an adverse opinion in that its not a going concern
Ssazmaz113y ago#15
For the first scenario in q5 I said that although it only related to sales and receivables, because they couldn't verify sales the profit itself is also in doubt. On this basis it should be a disclaimer as its material and pervasive. I did also say it could be argued that it should be "except for" as well.
For the second one I said adverse opinion as the whole of the accounts have been prepared on the going concern basis when it's clear that this is wrong from what we are told in the question.
Former userFormer user13y ago#16
for the first one i put modified due to limitation of scope - disclaimer. because it was pervasive
Cchris91113y ago#17
@vipin70 said:
disclamer of opinion is appropriate
sales revenue, receivables and profit could not be recoreded . not just one area.
for fuschita
it is adverse or qualified but i wrongly wrote it could be qualifeid or disclaimer. made mistake there


I am agree with this, dasiy has one opinion, but F got two. I answer all, and give opinion on audit prcedure about discuss with management about the funding, and cash flow problem.
Aanny78613y ago#18
Question 5
Daisy I wrote Qualified opinion on an except for basis, it is material but not pervasive, insufficient evidence could be obtained
Oh noo it seems like I'm the only one who wrote that

For frus I was in two minds about adverse or qualified an just wrote qualified
Q3 was an absolute disaster!!
Epic fail just not my day
Former userFormer user13y ago#19
Hi Admin...
I forgot to mention the question numbers on the cover page of the answer booklet... would my script be checked or would it effect my marking??? Kindly reply.... Cheers!!
Ttheglobe13y ago#20
cud someone remind me what q5 was. I was so bloody tired cant remember
Former userFormer user13y ago#21
Adverse for the second one due to the lack of disclosure in the financial statements?

I think as long as you have justified your opinion that's the main thing anyway?
MikeLittleMikeLittleTutor13y ago#22
farhan - don't worry about it. Pass / fail is NOT dependent upon you filling in the front sheet correctly
Ppannanikt13y ago#23
Daisy - auditors were able to estimate revenue from analysis of previous years, other ratios etc. If the figure from financial director was close to this estimate I would say qualified opinion as they have not audited this part but indirectly confirmed revenue. If director's figure is miles away from what they estimated it means something with revenue, receivables, profit may be completely wrong so material and pervasive - adverse opinion.
Ggolamrahim13y ago#24
I also put Disclaimer for Daisey as both sales affected profit & loss account and receivables affected BS and therefore pervasive. For the same question, what did u guys put down for 'other audit procedures the auditor should undertake?' (in relation to the virus)
Ggolamrahim13y ago#25
what did u guys put down for the question on audit risks and responses.. i think i really messed up on that one :(
HKHalar Khan Bijarani13y ago#26
I think it was quite lengthy.. or may be it was my bad.. that i took 1 hour in just 1st question .. :P cause it was for 30 marks! :D
VVipin13y ago#27
@golamrahim said:
what did u guys put down for the question on audit risks and responses.. i think i really messed up on that one :(

i wrote only inherent risk. no controls were given, so control risk. but for me, audit responses in regard to audit planning, what to write for responses is not known to me. i wrote something something. i could identify the risks.
VVipin13y ago#28
q.no.4 was trickiest.
heading was payayble, receivables
but they were not asking for audit procedures for receivables or payables.
auditor found some error due to said scenario we have to audit regarding the error found. so it was bit tricky.
first, i thought they were asking for generic receivable , payable audit procedures, but it was not.
Ggolamrahim13y ago#29
@vipin70 said:
i wrote only inherent risk. no controls were given, so control risk. but for me, audit responses in regard to audit planning, what to write for responses is not known to me. i wrote something something. i could identify the risks.

i tried to apply it to the scenario.. for responses i wrote things like 'the auditor will have to increase substantive tests in this area.."

I found this question to be the most difficult..
Jjodianww13y ago#30
This was an "ok" exam. Nothing that was too challenging, and for the first time I didn't feel like the exam was time pressured. Fair exam I hope to pass.
But question 5 asked about the audit report and not the audit opinion. I based the answer on the opinion.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.