Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AA*** F8 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about December 2011 F8 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** F8 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user14y ago#1
Q1 - Payroll / Law & Compliance / Internal Audit
Q2 - Internal Control / Audit Report
Q3 - Audit Risk
Q4 - Corporate Governance
Q5 - Events After Reporting Period / Provisions
Former userFormer user14y ago#2
running out of time...but still cover all the question...hopefully i can get a pass...preparing for tomorrow f9...T.T
Rreshi14y ago#3
toooooooooooo much lengthy paper..i thnk one who completely solve the paper will probably pass..
Former userFormer user14y ago#4
This F8 paper was ok to me. And I sort of predicted audit of payroll/wages would appear as this new examiner has not set any audit qn on this yet. So overall was abit lengthy but yet not too tricky for most parts.
Former userFormer user14y ago#5
quite easy..hoping for a pass..
YYsbq14y ago#6
a well balanced paper and do able in time hopefull for a past
Aansi14y ago#7
Quite a nice and easy paper! No unexpected and tricky bits , only substantive testing , no even test of controls! :) First time i felt that it's bad to know too much :D

Thanks alot to opentuition! :)
Aaesire14y ago#8
well....it was reasonable.
MAmuhammad asif14y ago#9
very lengthy for me, i missed 15 marks in last question
Ddaredevil8714y ago#10
Easy paper ... attempted all Q's ....... not tricky ........... hoping good marks :)
Sshashi00714y ago#11
A bit difficult............lost marks in Q 3....not enough time
SBSaad Bin Aziz14y ago#12
Paper was ok but very lenghty. Goodluck for f9 guys!
Former userFormer user14y ago#13
can any1 of u plz tell me the ans of ques no 2 (b)?
Former userFormer user14y ago#14
Indeed it was a hell lengthy paper, couldnt attempt last 15 marks, out of time, paper was ok,
Aayman8514y ago#15
Pami Bahl is a great examiner, i like her style of questions..very easy to understand with clear instructions!
Former userFormer user14y ago#16
ok ok ppr :(... last attempts i cud predict whether i wud fail/pass or expect a pass and then fail but now its all a big doubt ...no expectations at tall :(( Too lengthy... and yes she was in love with Substantive Procedures as it was all way through and i hope she is merciful towards F8 students .. Open Tuition tips did help a bit... Thanks .. Now F9 to struggle with ..

Q1:
a)
(i) Payroll - Possible implications of the already identified deficiencies and recommendations to overcome it
(ii) Payroll charge - Substantive procedure
b) Auditors & managements towards law and regulation compliance
c) Provision - Substantive procedure
d) Reliance on internal Audit by external Audit

Q2)
(i) Elements of Internal Control system
(ii) Elements of unmodified report

Q3)
(i) The components of audit risks with example
(ii) Identify audit risks in the scenario & Auditor's response towards them

Q4)
(i) Corporate Governance & importance
(ii) Weakness in scenario's corporate governance and recommendation

Q5)
(i) Subsequent events - Substantive procedures for: Year end date to auditor's report date & Auditor's report date to FS date
(ii) Receivables / Law suit / Warehouse - if FS to be amended, audit procedures to overcome the amendment, effect on report if no action taken..

It's all i could remember after 2 hrs after the paper ...
Former userFormer user14y ago#17
Very lenghty paper didnt answer 8 pc of the marks which is not so bad. Not a terribly difficult paper but not so easy either
Kkarmuks14y ago#18
paper was quite easy,but not enough time to finish all questions
Jjoevassallo14y ago#19
As with all the exams again a lengthy paper subdivided into a lot of small questions. Not very difficult but a lot to digest and write about.... Explain and describe in most of them. There wasn't any straightforward "List" questions????
Hope for the best.
Bbari14y ago#20
Hi, paper was lengthy but less tricky, just one thing in Q5 Contingent Liability, I managed to complete it though but it will depend on the quality of answers, my guess to score is 70 but lets see, I think pass rate will be lower from last time (40%)...
Jjoevassallo14y ago#21
@dalal.abdulla said:
ok ok ppr :(... last attempts i cud predict whether i wud fail/pass or expect a pass and then fail but now its all a big doubt ...no expectations at tall :(( Too lengthy... and yes she was in love with Substantive Procedures as it was all way through and i hope she is merciful towards F8 students .. Open Tuition tips did help a bit... Thanks .. Now F9 to struggle with ..

Q1:
a)
(i) Payroll - Possible implications of the already identified deficiencies and recommendations to overcome it
(ii) Payroll charge - Substantive procedure
b) Auditors & managements towards law and regulation compliance
c) Provision - Substantive procedure
d) Reliance on internal Audit by external Audit

Q2)
(i) Elements of Internal Control system
(ii) Elements of unmodified report

Q3)
(i) The components of audit risks with example
(ii) Identify audit risks in the scenario & Auditor's response towards them

Q4)
(i) Corporate Governance & importance
(ii) Weakness in scenario's corporate governance and recommendation

Q5)
(i) Subsequent events - Substantive procedures for: Year end date to auditor's report date & Auditor's report date to FS date
(ii) Receivables / Law suit / Warehouse - if FS to be amended, audit procedures to overcome the amendment, effect on report if no action taken..

It's all i could remember after 2 hrs after the paper ...


You have good memory.... spot on. Do you remember the marks by any chance?
Former userFormer user14y ago#22
did not mention a qestion when a auditors should disclose confidential information
Jjoevassallo14y ago#23
@petrochina said:
did not mention a qestion when a auditors should disclose confidential information

Yes you are correct - I think that was Q3 to explain Obligatory and Voluntary Disclosures of information.
Rrabab14y ago#24
not so easy .
Former userFormer user14y ago#25
it was quite ok for me, I managed to attempt all questions but believe my arm is still feeling not good. Thanks to Open tuition guy I wonder what would have happened if I dind' t read your summarized contents . Once agains congs and may God Bless your Good work
Former userFormer user14y ago#26
paper was ok, but some of them questions were confusing hope to get border line pass......
Former userFormer user14y ago#27
Paper was too lengthy...hoping for a pass but you never know with written papers!!
Ggriffith14y ago#28
Paper was very lengthy, but we will all have to wait how easy it was by the many responses-which mean all should pass.
Former userFormer user14y ago#29
@abbasravjani

Question 2, part B was regarding the elements of an UNMODIFIED Audit report.

Possible Examples;
Date
Auditors Signature
Auditors Address
Management Representation Letter
Kkarmuks14y ago#30
Even with easy questions is possible to fail, especially when lot of thinking is required like for substantive tests which were included in too many parts. One question I did not get time to attempt,thought I was writing on high speed.will see outcome in 3 months