Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

TX*** F6 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments***

Oopentuition13y ago
Post your comments about December 2012 F6 exam.

Please vote in our Instant Poll
*** F6 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments*** poll results



Please note: The ACCA has requested that no postings must be made in this forum before 15:00 GMT on the day of the exam - any postings before this time will be deleted.
Remember that you are studying for a professional qualification - do not make postings that are abusive or threatening. Anyone breaking this rule may be reported to the ACCA disciplinary committee.
Hhamsterham13y ago#31
@jassi said:
oo i started with the net profit deducted the allowable exp because it was added - didnt nothing with the usual items eg depreciation etc 0. reworked capital allowances because they were wrong in the question. fii, intrest income and tax was at marginal relief there was an associated company and had to divide 1500000/2


Sounds very similar to what I did just the way we worked out the adjusted profit was diff but should give same result :)
Ddiane13y ago#32
Also added dividend at gross to stand rate band and hrb and added tax 100/90 to gross up div and 100/80 to gross up bank interest - deducted bfwd relief - property income as was as it said allowable deductions which I wrote I presumed included wear and tear - car benefit co2 rate - 125 /5 added to petrol instead of diesel what a twat lol just remembered that now but done calc right no fuel allowance - canteen allowable no benefit - moving max benefit 8k only as it said included legal for buying which is not taxable benefit so wrote presumption again probably wrong - isa calc easy but only 2 points woohoo I got 2 lol - co calc I started at trading profit and added on not allowed put zero for allowables - dividends adjusted in tax band by gross but think I should have missed out subsidiary dividends but too late now - deducted page tax in div tax in int poa and left balancing payment due immediately with reduced poa for July and jan as business ceased and prop income too low to require poa due to hr relief through dividends and gift aids. Think that's it but can't remember head a mess and now got f7 tomorrow so got to go revise as its not good :( - hope u all get passes hope I scrape through but can't find my 50 marks :(
Ddiane13y ago#33
@dianemartin said:
Well I screwed up took salary at 15100 a mth as it said but didn’t notice the 8 mth date if it was 8 mth and done a year – anyhow income >100k so reduced pa to zero as 50% reduction of the 100k limit was in excess of the pa- the co tax add back 8000 max is allowable as moveable benefit ( taxable benefit) the balance disallowed – pension 50k per annul allowed c/fwd unused gave 150k allowable for year and life limit 1.8 mill – hit deducted ae and nrb taxed at 25% as was diner not donee and if he died an extra allowance for taper relief was allowed but taxable at 40% on balance which ended less payable with 5yr taper – ran out of time on q3 so wrote crap done tax and nic calls for employee and employer but rushed – cant remember what else but found it all too much for 3 hrs and wish I could use pencil what a mess with scoring out lol – don’t think I passed but tried my best
you will only lose a mark for salary – rest is what you do based on your figures.

i didnt reduce pa income was greater than 114950. so no pa even after gift aid.

i had unused pensions of 133k as th 07/08 was not allowed – only carry forward 3 year allowances.

IHT – did the question not say to work out IHT if paid by trust AND Donor?

part c – if he died iht at 40% on trust coz nrb would cover the PET less taper relief at 40% for 4-5 years.



Yep I done both for doner and donee same 40% taper relief - pension can cfwd for ever up to 1.8mill life allowance so cfwd all years plus 50k for last year was 150 (but could be wrong lol) know cfwd is allowed for as long as u want - I reduced pa to nil also - it wasn't a pet it was a CLT (trust) in IHT but ur calc ok as there was only the one so u won't loose marks for saying pet :) - nic question lost me number 4 I think or 3 - ran out of time done calls for all paye and nic variants commented on class 2 and 4 being gone and 1 and 1a being payable and - cant think what else lol
Ddiane13y ago#34
Trading losses bfwd 41 thousand and something gets deducted 2nd row from trading profits :) but again minimal point :)
SS4K1B13y ago#35
I was a tiny bit confident before i read all this here lol

Salary was 15100 x 8months

I forgot taper relief ! I allowed the expenses for removal. Car benefit was 18%+4% = 22% x list price 14400? no fuel benefit but i didnt write NO FUELBenefit! Will i get marked down for this?

I was unaware of new rules for FHL losses. Oops.

Got the share pool correct not sure about the land. And i think i got the investment property gain correct also. all 3 werr gains right?

Question 4 was indeed a difficult one. Re incorporation.

Hooefully ill scrape it this time. Try not to think about it now guys and girls.
Ccjw113y ago#36
re Q3 CGT: Think the insurance proceeds was a ZERO gain - as the gain on it is rolled-over into the base cost of the new replacement asset. And the land one was a £9k gain I think.

Re Q4 c IHT: £122,000 CLT - so £24,400 when 20% paid by donee trust and 25% £30,500 - when paid by donor.

What did everyone else get?
Ddiane13y ago#37
Car benefit was list price 14400 x (co2 -125)/5 +18% for diesel but I went and added the 15% for petrol aaarghhhh lol and no fuel benefit - done 12mth salary not 8 (blows) 12 mth loan int not 8 (blows) its all minus minus minus - but got 2 marks for Isas lol - ahhh well never mind but I really don't want to do that book again and looks like I may have too :(
Ddiane13y ago#38
Oooo I done roll over for the gain on the insurance woohoo maybe another point there :)
Ddiane13y ago#39
Got the same as u for IHT 20 and 25% :)
Ddannyw198413y ago#40
for questions 1 i used £15k salary per month for 8 months
but did anyone else use salary from her previous job as well, as one of the months fell within April? can't remember how much it was, but just divided the figure and used 1 amount of it as salary,
think my answer to question 1 was something like £11,000 tax payable after taking off tax at source

question 2 probably should have been easy, but it just threw me - i have never seen a question where you are given everything like that and then told to basically reverse off the bits that weren't part of the income (main example was that capital allowances should have been deducted from income, not added in like the question had done). i got an answer but no doubt it was wrong.

question 3 - had a stab at it, hated it

question 4 - seriously? wtf was that about? one of the questions said "discuss if it would be beneficial or not if the lady takes all the money as renumeration or as dividends"
i was running out of time so for each option i just said "yes, it would be beneficial" - even if i get 1 mark its more than if i hadn't guessed

question 5 - was mostly straight forward, the amount of pension remaining from previous 3 years was able to take forward, even though she didn't pay into a pension last year she was still in the scheme, so that £50k was allowed.

was it just me who thought the question asking about ISA's was stupidly easy? ok, it was only worth 2 marks, but it said "ben has invested £4000 in a cash isa, how much can he invest in a stocks and shares isa?"

the amounts were given to you in the formula sheets - simply take the yearly limit, less off the £4k he has paid as a cash isa and the remaining is what he can have as a stocks and share isa?
Former userFormer user13y ago#41
@cjw1 said:
re Q3 CGT: Think the insurance proceeds was a ZERO gain - as the gain on it is rolled-over into the base cost of the new replacement asset. And the land one was a £9k gain I think.

Re Q4 c IHT: £122,000 CLT - so £24,400 when 20% paid by donee trust and 25% £30,500 - when paid by donor.

What did everyone else get?

Hi - I thought as the insurance proceeds were for an investment property that rollover relief would not be available as its not used for business purposes? - I could be wrong, but thats what i did. Anyone else get a capital loss on the sale of shares ?
Former userFormer user13y ago#42
@cjw1 said:
re Q3 CGT: Think the insurance proceeds was a ZERO gain - as the gain on it is rolled-over into the base cost of the new replacement asset. And the land one was a £9k gain I think.

Re Q4 c IHT: £122,000 CLT - so £24,400 when 20% paid by donee trust and 25% £30,500 - when paid by donor.

What did everyone else get?


Hi
Insurance proceeds was NOT a zero gain: as NOT ALL insurance proceeds were re-invested into a new asset. So, there was a gain immediately taxable (the difference between the insurance proceeds (cash in) and the amount spent on replacement asset) and the balancing figure can then be rolled over.


Well, at least this is how I calculated.
Former userFormer user13y ago#43
I didn't allow any relief on the investment property as only properties for trade are eligible for this. So i took the insurance proceeds less cost as the chargeable gain.

Also for Q4. i stated that taking salary would result in a higher tax and NIC liability and taking dividends a lower liability.
Former userFormer user13y ago#44
@charlyze2 said:
I didn't allow any relief on the investment property as only properties for trade are eligible for this. So i took the insurance proceeds less cost as the chargeable gain.

Also for Q4. i stated that taking salary would result in a higher tax and NIC liability and taking dividends a lower liability.


I don't understand why you are referring to investment property - this is not a question on roll-over relief for eligible business assets.
This is a question which tests the partial disposal rules - whereas the insurance proceeds are deemed to be "sale proceeds", and then only the portion of insurance money which is re-invested can be rolled over, whereas any cash not invested is immediately chargeable. Well - this is just my opinion
Former userFormer user13y ago#45
I had a nil loss for FHL and stated that it could only be carried forward ans offset against future FHL profits only.

Salary was £15100 per month over 8 months, loan was 7 months and car benefit was 6 months. removal benefit was £11600 less £8000(exempt) giving £3600,
no PA as net income greater than 114950
i had a tax payable of around £3k ish
Uumerkhayam13y ago#46
Unsure about Q1 and 2 and left IHT too :D i hope things go well.
Former userFormer user13y ago#47
@kirinski said:
I don't understand why you are referring to investment property - this is not a question on roll-over relief for eligible business assets.
This is a question which tests the partial disposal rules - whereas the insurance proceeds are deemed to be "sale proceeds", and then only the portion of insurance money which is re-invested can be rolled over, whereas any cash not invested is immediately chargeable. Well - this is just my opinion


I got the same as you
Uumerkhayam13y ago#48
Q5 part b was (10600-4000), Was there any fuel benefit in question 1? Q2 Tax was at 26% and limits divided by 2 ( subsidiary). Q4 a- In both situations net incoming cash was less then actual cash received if she had continued self employment, Q1 Salary for 8 months and profit of 3 months in total (1month first year and whole second period profit). Basic limit was extended but no Personal allowance. Gain arising on goodwill was nil :) thats what i did.
Ddannyw198413y ago#49
im going to stop reading now.

just when i think i might have picked up a few marks (like with the subsidiary making the corp limit divide by 2) i read that i didn't time aportion the car benefit - fucking idiot lol
Ttbm1313y ago#50
Q1:

FHL made a loss: needs to be carried forward; cannot be offset against gain of Property Two.

Car benefit: I think CO2 was 147 or 148, so round down to 145, then (145-125)/5 = 4 + 15 (base figure) + 3 (diesel) = 22%

Building society interest had to be grossed up (*100/80), dividends as well (*100/90). Prize from premium bond is not taxable.

Self-employment: added together gain from both periods, subtract overlap profit and subtract capital allowance.

Employment: the figure given was per month, so multiply by 8.

Q2: I found this hard since I wasn't sure whether I should start with Trade Profit before Taxation or with Total Profit.

Q3: Set up 1985 share pool: bonus issue is not an indexation event; rights issue is; perform indexation again before they sell shares.

Land: use calculation for part disposal. I believe the work done counted as "extension".

Property destroyed by fire: I calculated roll over relief: I think I came up with a chargeable gain of 16,600 since this was the amount not rolled over. But someone earlier in this thread said that an investment property was bought, so roll over relief would not be available. I cannot remember the wording of the question. Does anyone remember if roll over relief was available or not?

Q4: you had to calculate corporate tax, NIC and income tax for both scenarios: Scenario 1 (director is paid): calculate NIC 1 primary, income tax, and add the NIC 1 secondary they subtracted already; no corporate tax. Scenario 2: corporate tax (80000 * 20% = 16000) and then tax on dividends. 10% on first 35000, then 32.5% on the rest. Then compare total tax with the figure they gave you for self-employment: if your figure is higher, there is no tax advantage. Scenario 1 is definitely worse than self-employment. Scenario 2 was slightly worse than self-employment for me but it seems I made a mistake somewhere since other people said there was a tax advantage.

Q4, b (or was this Q3, b?): there was something about incorporation relief. 150,000 good will (cost: nil). The first part was getting 150,000 in shares. This leads to no chargeable gain since everything is incorporated. The alternative was 100,000 as stocks and 50,00 as cash: the gain attracting incorporation relief was: 100,000 / (100,000 + 50,000) * 150,000 = 100,000. 150,000 - 100,000 = 50,000 becomes chargeable. But there were 39,400 losses: so 50,000 minus 39,400 = 10,600. Minus annual allowance of 10,600 means no taxable gain.

Q5, a: pension: 133,000 could be paid into the pension

Q5, b: Look up ISA limit, subtract what he paid already and this is the figure he can pay into the ISA. (It would be wrong to use half the ISA limit! This is what you would've had to calculate if he had paid into a stock ISA and wanted to pay into a cash ISA)

Q5, c: Gift 200,000 to daughter: minus 6000 (annual exemption for two years): 194,000 becomes a PET.

Donation to trust: 450000 minus 3000 (annual exemption): first 325000 nil since PET is not considered. This leaves us with 120,000. 120,000 * 20% = 24,400 GBP. Or if Tim pays: 120,000 * 20 / 80 = 30,500 GBP. Total consideration: 447,000 plus 30,500 = 477,500.

IHT: PET becomes chargeable. 194,000 within nil rate. 325,000 - 194,000 = 131,000 left in nil band. 477,500 - 131,000 = 316500 needs to be taxed. 316500 * 40% = 126,600 minus taper relief 4-5 years (40%) 50,640 and minus the 30,500 paid already.

Does anyone know when ACCA will make the December F6 paper available on their web site along with the correct answers?
Former userFormer user13y ago#51
So I'm 105% sure I made some silly mistakes, how much marks do I lose if my final answer is wrong but my methodology is correct? (for instance adding something even though its listed to be subtracted in my workings?)
Uumerkhayam13y ago#52
@tbm13 we have done quite same thing in exam :D but in Q4 there was corporation tax in both conditions 1 and 2. :) other than that i agree that there was no tax being saved as net cash incoming was less in both conditions as compared to Self-employment.
Ttbm1313y ago#53
@umerkhayam I thought there was no corporation tax in condition 1 since the company made zero profit: everything was spent on NIC 1 secondary and salary. Do you disagree?
Uumerkhayam13y ago#54
@angleo86 said:
So I'm 105% sure I made some silly mistakes, how much marks do I lose if my final answer is wrong but my methodology is correct? (for instance adding something even though its listed to be subtracted in my workings?)

Check marking scheme in exam kit or past papers but i think you'd get marks for correct percentages used as per taxation rules and limits on your calculated income. In case your income figure is wrong you wont loose that much marks.
Uumerkhayam13y ago#55
@tbm13 said:
@umerkhayam I thought there was no corporation tax in condition 1 since the company made zero profit: everything was spent on NIC 1 secondary and salary. Do you disagree?

I am unsure about it but my corporation tax liability was something like 3000
Former userFormer user13y ago#56
for q4 part a, we have to first calculate the revised summary regarding income tax, nic and corporate tax for 2 given scenarios and then compare them seperately with the above scenario in order to findout the savings which sophia gained by opting the given scenarios , and then discuss them seperately
Mmor11213y ago#57
Damn I forgot about the taper relief!!!!! Hw many marks do you think that cost me?
Former userFormer user13y ago#58
The comments are interesting!...I made some silly mistakes as well...hoping for the best.....its so much to do in so little time...u have to think on ur feet......and then u panic when u realise u r running outta time...hope i can put this paper behind me!....what was going on in question 4 though with the NIC?
Former userFormer user13y ago#59
For Q1: Income Tax Liability for 2011-12 came to 36,200 in my calculations.
Long period of trading accounts ("anything yet untaxed") 14M less capital allowances (no AIA no WDA in the last period of trading), less overlap profits.

Property income from property 2 (FHL loss not off-settable, so carry forward)
Exempt premium bond.
Employment income: salary * 8M, loan 7M, car benefir 6M (22% as diesel plus extra % for emissions), moving house - tax on extra benefit over 8K limit, free meals exempt, interest grossed up, dividend grossed up, premium bonds exempt.

No PA, basic and higher rate bands extended by 5,500 (4,400 gift aid grossed up).

The result: income tax liability 36,200
(balancing payments required: 36,200 - 34 something already paid = so payable tax was something like 3K or so, can't remember precisely)
Payments on acct needed: 31 Jan 13 - 18,100; 31 July 2013 - 18,100 (50% of tax payable)

Anyone else got 36,200 as tax liability for Q1?
Former userFormer user13y ago#60
Q2, Corporation tax: I struggled a bit with the Interest Income: there was a strange presentation of this. Anyone remembers what they got? - I did this way: amount actually received (which was used by Clueless in the calculations on the Computation) less accrual at 01 April 2011 plus accrual at 31 March 2012 - so it was in fact a slightly different number from the one Clueless used.

I got corporation tax payable at something like 95K, or may be 97K. Anyone remembers what they got as the final answer?

(marginal company, 26% less marginal relief, the TTP was after the deduction of 900 gift aid (but which was previously added back when calculating trading profit)
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.