Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

LW*** F4 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share here with community your comments about June 2011 F4 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll

*** F4 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Nneilsolaris15y ago#31
So you think the fact I spoke about probability of risk, seriousness of risk, res ipsa loquiter etc, will not mean that I will earn zero marks necessarily? Fingers crossed!
Sstasi15y ago#32
LAW ROCKED!!!!!! :D :D :D
Former userFormer user15y ago#33
Drurolog -

Re: question 10, the liquidation debt repayment question... For my answer I wrote that because the Overdraft was under personal guarantee, not a partnership guarantee, Matt was liable to pay it rather than the partnership.... I may have to google it to see if it's right though, it was a bit of an educated guess!!!
Pplatinumkp15y ago#34
@neilsolaris

I think you will earn more marks than you think.
Nneilsolaris15y ago#35
Thanks platinumkp. I should stop thinking about it now! Hope everyone does well with their results.
Former userFormer user15y ago#36
can somebody tell me precisely plz wht the question 7 part a
it was duty of care or standard of care?
Former userFormer user15y ago#37
@platinumkp yes it sure is helpful so u can't do professional papers before clearing all skills right. Thx a lot
Former userFormer user15y ago#38
The question on standard of care related to the breach of duty of care. See question and answer 3 of the June 2008 paper.Click here I got that completely wrong. as I talked about neighbourhood principle etc.. Really annoying as I knew the answer. Why do they have to make questions ambiguous. I should have looked at those past exam papers!! Hopefully did okay in other questions.
Former userFormer user15y ago#39
Answer to June 2008 Q3 Click here.
Aaau9811315y ago#40
I have a question re the Ari, Bi, Cas, Dex question on failure to pay outstanding debts in full but need to know if anyone else did the Scots variation of this paper?

The BPP Scots Supplement Notes said that for Chapter 5 we only needed to study sections 4 and 5. That means we were advised not to study the part payment or alternative consideration rules that I've seen other people discuss on here as being in their answer

I'm guessing that means it is not applicable in Scotland so does that mean we just had to say that Bi and Cas repudiated their contracts and that new contracts were formed with Bi and Cas's father? If Ari then chose to pursue Bi or Cas for the debts he would repudiate these 2 new contracts. i.e. he cant do anything
Aaau9811315y ago#41
The question on standard of care related to the breach of duty of care. See question and answer 3 of the June 2008 paper. I got that completely wrong. as I talked about neighbourhood principle etc.. Really annoying as I knew the answer. Why do they have to make questions ambiguous. I should have looked at those past exam papers!! Hopefully did okay in other questions[/quote]

I disagree actually, I think you are OK with what you did. At least I hope so because I did same thing

I'm sure the question was asking about duty of care and not about breach of that duty of care

The question and answer you have linked to is all about the breach which we werent asked this year. The 2008 model answer even starts with "Once a clainmant has established that the defendant owes them a duty of care they must then establish that the defendent has actually breached that duty.." and goes onto talk about the breach rather than the duty

Our question today was about establishing the duty of care in the first place i.e. neighbour principle
Former userFormer user15y ago#42
I think the paper is fair. The only problem is English is not my first language so I tried to use simple English to answer all the questions and I haven't quoted any cases. If I failed this paper, I really don't know how can I pass it next time round. I just don't believe I have to use calculator for the last question to calculate the final total asset of the company (the 75% of shares need to pay up). I think the bank (overdraft) and all other creditors entitled the final assets (pro rata) - I may be wrong but who care, at least I don't have to think about it for a couple of months, especially I still have exam next Monday. P1 is really the paper I worry about
Former userFormer user15y ago#43
No the overdraft must be first in sequence, remember it was secured with a fixed charge.

The law exam was good for me, I must say due to my last minute studying I did well, started studying 5 days ago :( I asked God for guidance and he directed me to the topics that came on this exam.........I say a PASS.
MAmuhammad asif15y ago#44
q7 was on waiver of existing rights???
Former userFormer user15y ago#45
i hated the scenarios..the theorotical questions were much better...the scenarios were a bit complicating
Former userFormer user15y ago#46
i hated the scenarios..the theorotical questions were much better...the scenarios were a bit complicating
Former userFormer user15y ago#47
i was so happy becaz paper so easy i prepared exam in 2days
PPlen15y ago#48
I see u guys like anxiety!!! y even bother askin whts right or wrong, noone of us are gona correct the paper:) lets leave tht work to the staff now:)
Besides, wht seems right to some1 might seem wrong to some1else n there my friends is a never ending discussion :D

Relax! let go! whts written in the paper cannot be undone now can it;)
Mmarky12315y ago#49
I studied really hard for law and knew my worst subject was Corporate Governance - so what comes up??? Aaarrgh!!
Apart from 2 questions, I think it was a fair exam. After leaving the exam I felt I had answered 6 questions really well, 1 fairly well, 1 I think I got half right (!) and there was 2 questions that I know Ive messed up on. Reading everyones comments it seems to confirm my own thoughts. We'll just have to wait and see! Best of luck peoples :)
PPlen15y ago#50
@marky
hey mee too :( lol i went happy with fraudulent n actually the first thing i did wen i opened the paper was i started tracing the word "corporate governance" i knw hw u must have felt
Former userFormer user15y ago#51
The paper was great but the only chapter i left was corporate governance and wohh when i saw that it was like what the crap.......... anyway overall went good. too easy that i believe alot of us concentrated on important topics and the question were almost all from minor topics. I mean there was no question on directors rights and stuff like that. Very basic and direct questions were asked.
Former userFormer user15y ago#52
i havent attempt the corporate governance q, what about ya guys?
Pplatinumkp15y ago#53
Corp gov

a) wrote about the OECD definition - simply how companies are managed and controlled. and then wrote a little about the backdrop

b) Extra legal
Listed entities tend to need to use it
Features - INSIDE A CRAB (just gave a few examples, internal control, audit commitee, balanced board, disclosure).

c) Just described what NEDs in a balanced board do (supervisory role over execs). and then gave a few examples of subcommitees they make up (audit commitee, etc). Independence and objective element to management.

Quite a simple question if u applied a sensible approach - I hope to come away with 8-10 marks.
Mmarky12315y ago#54
I attempted all questions. Im doing mainly home study, but one interesting thing I got told is that ACCA do not "negative mark", and so always write something for a question even if you know you are a million miles out, as you never know when you might pick up an "accidental" mark - that one mark may be the difference between getting 49/100 and 50/100 !! Thats the philosophy I went into the exam with anyway lol;)
Pplatinumkp15y ago#55
@marky123 - while they don't negative mark, its always best to set a good impression with knowledge at the beginning of every script and the beginning of every question so that you buy the markers goodwill. Remember that marking guides can be very subjective so brownie points definetely impact performance.
Former userFormer user15y ago#56
Kiillllleeddd it.... surprisingly pretty straight foreward, number 10 was the best case scenario question everr
Mmarky12315y ago#57
Well all we can all do is wait and see when we get our results in August. Ive already packed my law notes away, and I didnt check any of my answers, no point, nothing I can do now anyway!! lol. Im concentrating on my F5 revision for Monday now!! :)
Former userFormer user15y ago#58
The exam was not too bad, not too many surprises came up.

I really want to thank F4 tutor for the wonderful lectures he has supplied. I was doing the course via distance learning and struggled with the books as found it hard to absorb all the different cases. I came across Open Tuition by accident, the lectures helped so much and the way that the little stories stuck in my head helped tremendously in the exam. Many thanks for all your help.
Former userFormer user15y ago#59
Hi guys, I thought I had done ok until I realised I had the wrong end of the stick with the negligence question. It was 100% asking about the 'standard' of the duty of care and there is a model answer in June 08. I wrote about DvS, Hedley Byrne v Heller and nothing worthwhile on actual 'breach' which the model answer explains. Damn! I originally thought it was for 10 marks, was this the case???

(P.S. For what it's worth, in my opinion, for q10, land sorted the fixed charge primarily, unpaid share capital + current assets satisfied creditors, and Mat was liable to pay the overdraft that he personally guaranteed. After paying the unpaid amount of their shares the other shareholders had no further obligations as they moved from a partnership to limited company.)
Vvjsharksn15y ago#60
@psyurmh the question was NEGLIGENCE > DUTY OF CARE ..... it is the landmark case "DONOGHE V STEVENSON" in which High court stated that every person owes duty of care to another person whome he has no contractual relationship, court also refined some subsequent ruling on some principle.