I am in middle of preparing my project analysis. The company I am assessing prepares its accounts in pounds (£), and the comparator company prepares in euros (€). Do I have to translate the euro into £s or I can just leave it like that? Is there any problem with this? Please help
Comparator company
This question has been asked before on 'Topic 8 Problems with Financial Statements' and my answer is reproduced below. You will see that comparing Ryanair with Easy Jet is not a problem. (May I suggest Kelly Ann that if you need to open a new topic then you should be more specific as Topic 8 is too generalised as T8 already has hundreds of sub-headings - so either our search facility or going to pages 2 or 3 may reveal a similar generic topic title)
"This is not an issue as you should be working mainly in ratios. The only times you might use absolute figures is when discussing revenue and even then it is the year on year increases that are most significant, or share prices. With the latter it is the importance of the effect of performance on share price where you should be focussing. So don't feel you have to translate currencies as it is unnecessary - there are ways round this and arguably translation does not add anything and probably masks some factors. As I keep trying to tell students it is not the numbers and percentages themselves that matter but their significance".
Thank you Trephena, much appreciate your advice.I will for future be more specific when I start a new topic?I was concerned as I wanted to do a revenue analysis by geography and thought the graph may be distorted due to different currencies...With regards to the graphs, I would obviously need to bring in the competitor as well,would I need to also need to take into account 3 year revenue/profit/costs of the comparator to plot on a graph simultaneously with main company?I have not seen this question asked with regards to graphs.I also found the answer in the suggested models to use for T8.
Thank you for all your help!
Kelly Anna
@kellann - if the currency issue is a problem with graphs then yes you may have to create separate ones occasionally but market share and GP ratios can be shown together. However you should find that with most ratios you can do your 3year analysis and comparisons without worrying about currency translations
Thanks again Trephena:) with the graphs , I also need to bring in 3 years of competitor?
Many thanks,
Kelly Anna
@melanin - yes do three years of comparisons
Thank you very much for all the prompt responses?
Hi Trephena, I have some concern to ask about my comparator.
I choose a Snack and Confectionary business as main company to analysis. It is a dominant player in this segment. In later of 2014, it sold its core segment (snack+confectionary), restructured business to focus on Food and Flavor segment and has already launched first instant noodles products (it still operates in Food industry, just changes the field)
I choose one of the leaders in Food and Flavor segment for comparison. My main firm and this comparator both manufacture instant noodles and spices so I guess that I can use this point as common things for comparison. However this comparator also focuses on natural resources sector. Currently, it is developing the world-class polymetallic project.
I wonder whether i can use this firm for comparison or not since it has a non-overlapping business interest with my main firm. Both of them are group.
Thank you in advance :)
I wanna add some further information of my case.
1) The comparator group has 2 subsidiaries. The subsidiary which major in Food &Flavor segment has its own financial statement and annual report.
So may I use this subsidiary as a comparator to my main firm for more relevance instead of using the whole group information? (include Food and Natural resources industry)
2) The subsidiary unfortunately only has Annual Report of 2014 in English, previous years' AR + FS are in native language and also its official website. As I read @trephena comment before, it is acceptable to compare one year of main firm to comparator.
So I just wanna be sure that if I only use 2014 Annual Report together with some articles on internet, is it OK? May I be criticized as don't gather sufficient information?
I hope to receive your reply soon as I only have this comparison part to complete my RAP. Thank you in advance :)
Dear @liinda, I am about to go on vacation and so can only deal with basic questions that are straightforward or those that I can give a quick response to right now. Yours is more complex and would require the focus unfortunately I can't give it at the moment. Sorry :-(
However our colleagues @LearningLuminarium will be monitoring our Forums and dealing with queries during my absence so I am sure will assist you. :-)
However I think only 1 years comparisons mean you would not be providing the level of detail required to get more than a C grade
Thank you anyways @trephena Enjoy your vacation :)
@LearningLuminarium Can you give me some advice about my case? I am so confused right now...
Hi @liinda,
1) If you are able to extract a specific segment as a comparator (food and flavours) and if the operations are similar to a large extent, that should be fine. You would however need to examine if there are shared costs (in your comparator) and how that has been allocated between segments. That may limit the effectiveness of your comparison. I would suggest you first try to obtain any industry ratios or averages before using a segment as a comparator. This is also due to response 2 below.
2) I agree with Trephena about the 1-year comparison. I highly discourage that, as that would mean that for 2 years, there is NO benchmark to determine if the target company has performed well. Therefore, in answering your topic, you have not assessed if the performance for 2012 and 2013 were good (because you do not have a benchmark for those years). I am inclined to agree that the maximum grade you'd get is a C, and it's more than likely an examiner might fault you for your depth of analysis and fail you instead. Again, may I suggest you obtain some industry figures and averages if possible?
Hope this helps!
Thank you for your help @LearningLuminarium :)
I have found another company in the same Food and Beverage industry with my main firm. It is a dairy business. Its operation is similar to my main firm. It gains 90% income from manufacturing dairy products while my main firm also earns 90% its income from manufacturing snack and confectionary products.
Since then, may I use this dairy firm for comparison with my main firm as it is more simple than using the firm mentioned in previous posts ?
May the non-ovelapping in main products is the concern?
@liinda
It's generally a judgement call. I would say that a company that is 90% similar is usually a good fit, as it's virtually impossible to get a 100% similar company.
Do remember to note the limitations in your project. Do you expect the 10% to impact your analysis much? If so, how?
@LearningLuminarium Thank you for your help. You clear my mind :)
I attempted my degree under Topic 16 Risk management intially and did not receive a grade for my RAP
However, I have decided to resubmit my RAP.
I decided to to choose topic 8 and currenlty completed the initial chapters.
Inorder to continue with my Part 3 Analysis I am unable to find a competitor.
My organisation is in the mobiletelecommunication industry, it is a listed company hence financials of Sri Lanka are available publicly.Its head office being overseas, it has to publish the finanacials in srilanka since it listed in the stock xchange.
However, all other mobile service providers operating in srilanka are foreign entities which are all private companies registered in Sri Lanka, so only the consolidated financial statements are available fof their head office , for example 'etisalat' sevice provider head office is located at UAE so the financial statements are consolidated are published by head officce at UAE in there currency.I cannot obtain individual financials for Sri Lanka alone,besides dialog being a PLC and the rest being private companies, i doubt how i would proceed with it.
I am afraid that I cannot find a competitor in this case.And I am not that clear with, taking industry averages as i do not possess sample projects for this purpose.
Please be kind enough guide me in this regard.
@fathima
I can understand the predicament you are in. It is worth considering whether you can change the company you are studying. It is still not too late.
When you select a company, you should
1) look at how much information you can gather on it. Are there news reports, analyst reports, industry reports that cover it?
2) look at the financials. Do they follow IFRS and can u comprehend them?
3) last but definitely not least, are u able to find a comparator? The very essence of the word "comparator" means something that is similar. Students sometimes miss that point.
If you compare a Sri Lankan telco to a British telco, that would be difficult as the customer profile is different. Prices and margins would not be comparable.
A Sri Lankan telco would be better compared to a Pakistani or Indonesian telco. You may even find a better one.
All said, do weigh ploughing ahead with the current company or changing. All the best!
And yes, topic 17 is really easy as Trephena pointed out! Also worth thinking about :)
The Learning Luminarium
Hi
Thankyou!
Does topic 17 require primary information, is it possible to continue with secondary info alone? eg; annual reports
My organisation is a foreign entity mobile service provider who is registered in Sri Lanka as a public limited company and listed in stock exchange.
Therefore the organisation has acquired subsisdiaries in Sri Lanka and is audited by the external auditors of Sri Lanka.
Hence all the secondary information is available due its listed status.
Apart from what i mentinoed previously would the below work as i am feeling comfortable to work with local companies.
But, there is only one PLC in srilanka which is goverment owned whose financials are publicly available. It provides mobile services, fixed telecommunications and other services.
My orgainsation is privately owned company which is PLC listed in stock exchange, whereas the comparator is a PLC owned by the goverment.
My issue is whether the comparision is possible between PRIVATE and GOVERMENT owned companies as explained above.
@fathima - yes you can (and should) do T17 using secondary data only. Have a read through what is on the T17 forum topic. I have talked students through this topic who had minimal mentor help and they managed to pass. You might be able to use either the company that you were doing your T8 on or possibly the one you used for your first submission. You will need to read up though on Corporate Governance if you haven't already passed P1 but it may tie in quite well with the some of the theoretical aspects you looked at for T16 as risk assessment is part of the remit for good CG.
Thank you boss!
hello, My question is that i am doing horizontal analysis of my pharmaceutical company on their consolidated financial statements, they have used constant exchange rates in their annual reports to find differences in their % figures, so do i also have to use CER or can i find out the yearly differences in % using normal way?
My second question is that, my competitor has published their annual reports in different currency, so how can i compare my company sales with them?
They are probably using a constant exchange rate so that any changes that would be entirely due to fluctuations in exchange rates are eliminated I.e. the differences and trends shown are completely down to performance. This can often give a truer picture of the results when it comes to judging management performance as by introducing exchange rates a factor totally beyond management's control could mask the underlying trends especially if the rate has changed significantly. However if a significant part of the operations relies on foreign imports this might be a way of manipulating the figures to make them look better if the rate has changed adversely (e.g. it could make the costs look lower and thereby has made profit higher). It all rather depends on how they have chosen the constant rate, why they are using it and the overall effect on figures. Calculating your own figures, comparing the 2 sets and reading the management policies in relation to currencies might shed more light on the real motives.
For comparator purposes you must compare like with like and use the same basis for your calculations.
Regarding comparing revenues between companies using different currencies focus on the year on year growth and the real factors (strategic and those from the business environment) that have affected performance. Produce line graphs which will show the trend lines and place them close together to assist the marker and DON'T just throw numbers and percentages at them explain the factors!
can u give me some examples for the last paragraph you wrote?
Read my article on Evaluation and Analysis on our homepage where I set out the way to approach this.
www.opentuition.com/obu
Hello. I just want to ask a simple question. As we have to upload three years financial statements of our primary company, is it necessary to upload three years F/S for our competitor also or should i just upload the latest one year competitors F/S?
Another question is that what should we upload e.g. only Balance sheet and Profit and loss account or Is it necessary to upload statement of cash flows also?
If I want to analyse three years then how many year’s figures should I take? e.g. 2014, 2013, 2012 and 2011 or just 2014, 2013 and 2012?
Whether we should use comparative figures (restated) or should i take the figures from individual annual reports?
Dear Mentors,
I would need your help with the following:
I chose for topic 8 pharmaceutical company Novartis and as a benchmark Roche. They report in different currencies (USD&CHF) but as it was discussed already several times in this forum (thank you very much for that!) its not the issue as i will make ratio analysis. Both report under IFRS but auditors of Novartis indicated in the report that statements are prepared: “...in accordance with IFRS as issued by the International Accounting Standards Board and comply with Swiss law."
Auditors of Roche (different audit firm) indicated that statements are prepared "....in accordance with IFRS and comply with Swiss law."
I am confused as in Roche report there is no specification whether it is IFRS as issued by the IASB and auditors just didn't mention that.
While reading requirements for SEC filing for non-US companies (https://www.iasplus.com/en/resources/regional/sec) I noticed that it was specifically indicated that “a foreign registrant may submit FS that conforms to US GAAP or FS that conform to IFRS as adopted by the IASB (that is, not jurisdictional adaptations of IFRSs), without need to provide a reconciliation to US GAAP”. Now I have concerns whether both companies are using the same variant of IFRS and can be compared easily without need to adjust the FS.
Thank you in advance…!
You seem to be comparing like with like so I think you are worrying unnecessarily - stop looking for issues!
I can assure you thiis will be fine (anyway it is not as though you are producing a document that is to be examined in legal proceedings or your life depends on it) - so to use my usual turn of phrase in such situations: Chill baby, chill !... and good luck of course :-D Trephena
Trephena, thank you a lot!:)
Hi,
I am about to start preparing ratio calculation for my project. I am comparing ryanair vs easy jet. They have different year end, march and sept respectively. Mentor suggest me to compare annual accounts of ryanair to interim one of easy jet. is that correct approach?Thanks
This question has been asked and answered many times before. I suggest you go through 'Using an Airline for Topic 8' as you will not only find the answer but probably read lots of other useful information to help you

