SBR*** ACCA Paper SBR March 2020 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Terrible paper.
Awful
What I can remember :
Q1
Functional currency - Grommits due to economic forces.
Goodwill - calculate in dinars then report at rate on date of acquisition. Bit of a twist here as they had some assets in Grommits and Dinars. I converted all to Grommits then to usd.
Impairment - why was there no average rate given? I took a punt and use 7.5 as the average between start and end.
Bonds
Amortisation calc fine with credit risk. Didn’t know how to treat the calc for the recognition of 12 months losses so took another punt on taking the expected value of losses to Pnl and offsetting asset in sofp.
Q2
Provision - no legal or constructive so no.
Event after reporting period - does it impact going concern? Will it impact at depot date?
Can’t remember the other accounting question
Confidentiality ethics with insider trading
Q3
Intangibles - tough one!
Seemed like the entity was using amortisation cost measurement with amortisation over useful life and business standard was fair value with annual review. Thought both were fine but didn’t agree with how the originally recognised the fair value of intangibles - seemed to only look at production costs?
Stadium
Sale and lease back.
Thought it represented a sale with a portion being retained. Calc was tricky because future dates and depn and not sure it was fully required but went for it anyway and explained IFRS 15 and control principles
Stadium barriers - far fetched but argued to capitalise as they would increase revenue through extra safety and increased attendance levels ?
Contact intangibles - amortise over contract and amend when life of intangible changes. Indicators of impairment include damage to players and roll up to larger cgu.
Q4
Waffle about sustainability and investors being conscientious and reputation damage if not. Threw in a bit about integrated reporting
Don’t aggregate provision with income for new building. And don’t recognise either of them.
Lease - tough, derecognised asset as control passed to new lease holder. Kept lease liability as not cancelled yet.
12 months lease so short term and accrue p&l?
Pension
Interest to p&l
Service (current and previous) to p&l
Remeasure to OCI
calc - take out provision for losses and take int and service to p&l
Paper was better than December in my opinion more opportunity to pass. However again I feel you are tested on small niche aspects of the syllabus which is already far too broad for one exam. Overall Paper was passable if you brushed up on provisions and differences between FRS 102 and IFRS !
First attempt. Its not difficult per se. The issue is the timing. There is so much content to cover and write about that there is very very limited amount of time to think. The questions I know I answered wrong is clearly because I had to rush. First time in all ACCA papers I struggle with timing. Let's see !
Your answers are almost the same as mine..
However, I'm a tad confused as to how the functional currency was determined! Guess the trick was in the final sentence!
I agree it felt like there were more questions than specimen. I literally skipped 3 questions to make it and even then i didnt do 2 questions at q4. So 40 points blank. First try at sbr and i think im gonna have to repeat.
What was the final sentence? I cant remember
@mervewillard said: What was the final sentence? I cant rememberIf you did not sit for the INT paper kindly ignore my message. It was related to the fact that the company pays tax in Dinars.
This was my first paper based exam and I have to say, computer based is SO much easier in terms of you can structure your answer a lot better and delete/re write. In this paper one I wasn’t even given any draft paper to write notes so had to go straight into writing the answer, which made it look messy at times and not flow well.
In terms of the exam itself, this was my first time doing SBR, I thought the first half of the paper was a lot easier than the second half. Not sure if I answered correctly in terms of Dinars or Grommits but worked out goodwill and the impairment etc and translation reserve. The last question about pensions seemed very odd - I’ve learnt a lot about defined benefit scheme but I don’t feel like this question was worth a good 25 mark answer. The main issue was time keeping, mind went blank towards the end and felt very pressured to quickly write so much in the time given!
@adebattista said: If you did not sit for the INT paper kindly ignore my message. It was related to the fact that the company pays tax in Dinars.I did sit int. I just dont think paying taxes in dinars is good enough of a reason to choose that currency. I thought it wouls be grommits because half wages in dinars half in grommits but they raise most of their financial resources in grommits
I put Grommits too as most of their sales was in Grommits. Translated all figures to Grommits to work out foreign goodwill then translated the whole goodwill figure to dollars. Fingers crossed.
It’s my first acca and Sbr paper. For the first question they didn’t give average rate but in the bbp revision kit they said ias permits closing rate for impairment translation to $. Damn I put opening rate for the impairment. Looks like I’m not going to make it for this one. The one about the barrier addition in the stadium ? is hard I think it’s expense as it doesn’t really add economic benefits and it’s cost added after asset is ready for use. And I skipped 2 whole sections on the one on restructuring costs and anyhow wrote about the ethics question on confidentiality and familiarity threat.
I have the same thoughts as you but unfortunately couldn’t answer many questions due to lack of time and mental block. Some of my neighbours have already given up and were sleeping during the test.
Rossacca.... I agree with a lot of what you have written. I too also took the average for the impairment as a punt.
Always after the exam I realise simple things I feel I have missed because they seem so basic/automatic at the time. So I realised at no point have I defined an asset... I was just focussing on the standards around it all. Hope I haven’t thrown away too many marks like this.
I feel there were repeated sections in this exam such as provisions and held for sale. Which are areas I am happy with. So if what I done is right, really hoping I’ve done enough
Let myself down with some of the calculations. Bonds in Q1. Only answered half that questions. Sale and lease back. I couldn’t quite focus on the proportion I was after and mentioned nothing of control of the asset. And Q4! Wow. What a disaster. No idea how to calculate the pension ( weak area for me and praying it didn’t come up) and certainly didn’t write enough to justify the 9 marks (plus 2 for professional) for the impact on PBT
I do always find my concentration lapses towards the end, so Atleast I am relatively happy with the majority of Q1 and Q2
My last exam, really hoping I’ve done enough.... I managed to score 40 in December sitting and was really winging it due to a serous lack of knowledge of the standards, which this time I really feel I have a strong grasp of.
please be my last sitting!
@nieffee said: Rossacca.... I agree with a lot of what you have written. I too also took the average for the impairment as a punt. Always after the exam I realise simple things I feel I have missed because they seem so basic/automatic at the time. So I realised at no point have I defined an asset... I was just focussing on the standards around it all. Hope I haven’t thrown away too many marks like this. I feel there were repeated sections in this exam such as provisions and held for sale. Which are areas I am happy with. So if what I done is right, really hoping I’ve done enough Let myself down with some of the calculations. Bonds in Q1. Only answered half that questions. Sale and lease back. I couldn’t quite focus on the proportion I was after and mentioned nothing of control of the asset. And Q4! Wow. What a disaster. No idea how to calculate the pension ( weak area for me and praying it didn’t come up) and certainly didn’t write enough to justify the 9 marks (plus 2 for professional) for the impact on PBT I do always find my concentration lapses towards the end, so Atleast I am relatively happy with the majority of Q1 and Q2 My last exam, really hoping I’ve done enough.... I managed to score 40 in December sitting and was really winging it due to a serous lack of knowledge of the standards, which this time I really feel I have a strong grasp of. please be my last sitting!I feel exactly the same about everything you said here. I felt like I was repeating answers about provisions and held for sale but maybe that was correct! I wish I’d have had a bit more time just to think about what I needed to write and structure it better, could have picked up easy marks by referencing the conceptual framework maybe.
It sounds like we all had similar issues, and were caught off guard in the same areas.
It's incredibly important that this is fed back to the ACCA during your feedback so things like this get considered during the moderation of the results.
The bond question in section A really put a spanner in my exam approach as I was not expecting it would be for that many marks..
Question 4 was a bit of a horror show for me too!
Regardless, best of luck all!
yeah i thought their functional currency was grommits as all sales, purch and most of their finance was in grommits and also some wages too.
I didnt see the currency that they pax in as being of an influence in this q as it stated that they were legally required to pay tax in that currency so they had no choice in the matter - also argued that even if you did take into account the tax payment that their primary economic activity in the most seemed to be in grommits.
Does anyone remember any of the mark allocation .... trying to just go over how I did. I know I shouldn’t torture myself. I can’t change it now. But it does help me lol
Question 1
Functional currency (6)
Goodwill , impairment, exch loss etc (8?)
How to account for Quaver (5?)
Bonds! (11)
Total 30
Question 2
Provision for restructure (6)
Related party. Wife’s shares (3?)
Stewardship? (3?)
Ethics points (6?)
Professional marks (2)
Total 20
Question 3
Accounting for stadium barriers (?)
Sale and leaseback (?)
Intangible contracts, bonus, CGU (?)
Total 25
Question 4
Sustainability (8)
£16m (£2 mil saving, £10m loss in sales ) and accounting for old lease (6)
Pension calculation defined Benefit
And Effect of PBT of above 2 (9)
Professional (2)
Total 25
Also feel free to correct anything that’s wrong !
Does anyone remember any of the mark allocation .... trying to just go over how I did. I know I shouldn’t torture myself. I can’t change it now. But it does help me lol
Question 1
Functional currency (6)
Goodwill , impairment, exch loss etc (5?)
Accounting for Crotchets customer contracts (4?)
How to account for Quaver (4?)
Bonds! (11)
Total 30
Question 2
Provision for restructure (6)
Related party. Wife’s shares (3?)
Stewardship? (3?)
Ethics points (6?)
Professional marks (2)
Total 20
Question 3
Accounting for stadium barriers (?)
Sale and leaseback (?)
Intangible contracts, bonus, CGU (?)
Total 25
Question 4
Sustainability (8)
£16m (£2 mil saving, £10m loss in sales ) and accounting for old lease (6)
Pension calculation defined Benefit
And Effect of PBT of above 2 (9)
Professional (2)
Total 25
Also feel free to correct anything that’s wrong !
@katie8223 said: This was my first paper based exam and I have to say, computer based is SO much easier in terms of you can structure your answer a lot better and delete/re write. In this paper one I wasn’t even given any draft paper to write notes so had to go straight into writing the answer, which made it look messy at times and not flow well. In terms of the exam itself, this was my first time doing SBR, I thought the first half of the paper was a lot easier than the second half.Agree on CBE and 1st vs 2nd half. I sat the CBE variant in the UK and it was much easier to structure and digest information. The ability to select and read only relevant sections to the question being asked was great as was being able to change between word and excel. Reviewing all the previous exams I think the 1st half has always been easier as it has followed a similar format each time - groups and ethics. I don't think we can complain too much around the 2nd half because I think there is a very similar question around player registration intangibles in the past papers. I might change my mind when I get my result! :)
My exact experience! First time sitting, paper was not hard but ran out of time. hoping for the best
I know Q3 last part was 13 marks.
@nieffee said: Does anyone remember any of the mark allocation .... trying to just go over how I did. I know I shouldn’t torture myself. I can’t change it now. But it does help me lol Question 1 Functional currency (6) Goodwill , impairment, exch loss etc (5?) Accounting for Crotchets customer contracts (4?) How to account for Quaver (4?) Bonds! (11) Total 30 Question 2 Provision for restructure (6) Related party. Wife’s shares (3?) Stewardship? (3?) Ethics points (6?) Professional marks (2) Total 20 Question 3 Accounting for stadium barriers (?) Sale and leaseback (?) Intangible contracts, bonus, CGU (?) Total 25 Question 4 Sustainability (8) £16m (£2 mil saving, £10m loss in sales ) and accounting for old lease (6) Pension calculation defined Benefit And Effect of PBT of above 2 (9) Professional (2) Total 25 Also feel free to correct anything that’s wrong !Remind me again, what was Quaver in Q1? I thought Ethics was 5 marks this time but can't remember how the 20 marks added up. Maybe the related party was 4 instead of 3? Did anyone put the wife was a related party? I thought not as the accountant wasn't key management personnel.
Can you please tell me in question 3 ..head accountantant wife is considered as related party.
Exam was confusing due to time constraints it's couldn't think properly. So it was difficult. Hope I get pass marks as I wrote atleat some points related in general for questions which I had no idea about .
Who are the 6 people who said the exam was easy as per the poll??
My first attempt at SBR and I have taken the exemption route. Time management was the biggest challenge. Given 5 hours I’m sure everyone would have been able to manage writing a good paper. Hope to clear.
Key management personnel:
Those persons having authority and responsibility for planning, directing and controlling the activities of the entity, directly or indirectly, including any director of that entity.
The accountant wasn’t a director and to me it appeared he was a consumer of decisions rather than having any authority so wasn’t key management personnel.
@rossacca Quaver was the 100% sub acquired with the intention of selling. Think you could be right about the ethics being only 5 marks
Related party. I actually didn’t stop and think about it too much. I said that although he wasn’t a director, he was a member of key management personnel and as such his wife was a related party. I personally would be very surprised if a head accountant of a company with that responsibility was not considered key management personnel
This exam to my knowledge is a lot about justifying yourself also. If you make key valid points and can back these up in relation to the scenario specifically you will still score marks.
for example if you state that the wife of key management is a related party, you would get a mark for this, even if you got the fact about them being key management wrong
Whether legal expense are considered as restructuring costs.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

