How was your ACCA Paper SBL December 2020 exam?
Please vote in the Instant Poll
Comments are now opened
SBLACCA Paper SBL December 2020 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments
Not examinable yet . I think it will be tested next year
You think my answers above are correct ?
I think keeping the subsidiary will be a good strategic choice because margins were shrinking in the Audit business and the market is getting tighter. The company can spread their risk by continuing with the subsidiary profitably. Moreover, the nature of the management consultancy business is suitable to the Parent Company and will complement the audit business. The same competence is required to run the subsidiary. The management needs to reorganise, refocus the mgt consultancy and develop market share by creating a niche for it . This is could be achieved by targeting small and medium scale clients as that segment has the potential to grow
However, the price quoted for the mgt consultancy appears to be attractive given the significant reduction in profit. The undiscounted future profit from the projection is lower than the present valuation (25m). Also, from the projections, the revenue from yrs 2,3, and 4 will mostly be from new clients, this is quite ambitious and at variance, with the prevailing condition in the market because the big four with enormous resources have the market share and are investing in it. In light of this, achieving the projections is quite doubtful. Furthermore, the regulatory authorities according to the article are beginning to look at the ties of mgt consultancies and Audit firms, this could potentially be a significant business risk in future should new regulations bar Audit firm from holding an interest in Consultancy service Companies.
It is our opinion that the benefits listed above outweigh the drawbacks if the mgt consultancy can be reorganised and refocused market-wise. It is our view that it has the potential to develop a niche in the market by focusing on SMEs. It will be more profitable if that is achieved. The strategic choice and risk opportunities it offers are far greater than the immediate gains from its disposal.
No ANswer is right or wrong you just have to look at both sides and make a choice. You can read my suggested way of answering the question and still arrive at a different conclusion. It is just to show scepticism .So your answer can be right in its own way .
Thanks and what about this answer ?For the ethics and investigation I wrote 1)Hr issues- there has being communication problem between the senior and junior staff and work has not being assigned properly leading to work not being done effectively. This threat would be investigated by implementing adequate timetable in the planning process to ensure that the employees record the time in which the work has being completed and to ensure the supervision is in place so that there is proactive communication within the firm 2)familiarity threat: as Toby and tim use hang a lot golfing and going on vacation this has lead to Familarity threat. This threat would be investigated by having quality control procedures and voluntary disclosures to ensure the threat doesn’t occur in the engagement of the team.
3)Business threat: there was a mutual business threat between Tim and Toby regarding the property which has led to the opinion being judgemented. This has led to self interested threat. There has being allegations of the properties which are listed on Tim and his families name. If this is similarly natured then allegations of ethical principle has not being justified. 4)Lost documentation: there has being three large payments of which the documents has not being noted or verified. To investigates the risk it need to be ensured that an authorized person has being staffed to ensure he keeps proper record and accurate bookkeeping. -5)Self review threat: duby co managed Tim so audit client as these two are different firms this could lead to self review threat as it threaten the independence. I’m order to investigate this risk personal control needs to be in place to ensure that staff are supervised fully and there independence are not threatened Are these points correct as well please do reply and out of 20 marks how much would I get for these points ?
neris wrote:Not examinable yet . I think it will be tested next yearYou think my answers above are correct ?
So happy to see there were two variants as when I first read about office closures, I thought I had definitely failed.
For the sale of the sub, I went through the pros and cons of the financial and non financial reasons. Complex specialist company that targets large firms and gov sectors - not the norm for Glendon Farr - small/medium target market. But may open doors into a new market/sector. Staff costs were a high % of sales (can't remember the figure) and expected to increase. If sold, staff could be used to focus on other services/objectives. Revenue from new customers were not guaranteed - not reliable. Revenue from existing customers declining. I suggested that the company could keep the sub - obtain more accurate figures for Revenue and manage (try reduce) staff costs - bring in technology.
However, I utimately said they should accept the offer to sell the sub as the projected profits over the next four years were declining and lower than 25 m without even taking the time value of money into account. The profits may be lower again as the revenue estimated is not reliable. I suggested the company focus on small-medium firms as these firms are moving away from big 4 to firms that relate to them. Selling the sub and focusing on this market - by offering more personal experience and better communication.
I see most people suggested to reject the offer to sell the sub so hope my points weren't off the wall.
The rest of the exam was pretty general. I don't really remembering answering Internal Controls so feel I missed that one. I answered the pros/cons for automation but obviously missed the second part to that question.
I rushed through Q.5. - used cultural web for one of the slides. and again general for the other ones.
Best of luck to everyone. I honestly just can't gauge how I did. I wouldn't be too surprised if I failed (I'd be so disappointed though).
I didnt see anything regarding internal controls either! But there was the pros and cons of having an internal audit team.
i just mentioned how they could stop expense rising and possible point out ways to better processes with automation.
The more I think about this exam the more I don't think the remote format suits it as it was set up.
This exam is always time consuming but on this sitting there were 8 exhibits to read if I recall correctly. Previous exams have mainly had 5-6 exhibits I think so seemed there was a lot more information to digest.
I am thinking there was additional information to allow for differing variants of questions that were asked, does anyone know are there normally variants of questions in the written paper for SBL?
The idea of pushing more information into an already time limited exam seems quite harsh and not well thought through. I know myself I was looking at information in the exhibits and wondering where it fitted in in the questions I had but just couldn't see what relevance it had and only became clear after I learnt the alternative questions. Appreciate that it is an exam but providing additional information that is only going to confuse doesn't seem appropriate.
Any thoughts or am I just moaning!?
For the first question the benefits and drawbacks of corporate structures, the benefits that I wrote for 1)The board was able to take long term decisions and due to neds working in the board it would ensure that the independence won’t be threatened 2) it is used to ensure that fair remuneration is given to the staff 3) the members who hasn’t worked for this board gets staffed this would be beneficial as oversees knowledge would come within the firm leading to more ideas and skills. 1) it is used to ensure that internal controls and working effectively and ensure that quality control procedures are in place with voluntary disclosures to ensure everything is running smoothly2) it is used to implement risk management policies and identify risk and to mitigate it 3) the member of the board is elected due to voting this would be beneficial as fair and independent member would be elected with the Satisfaction of other board members etc.4) to ensure that constructive relationship with the clients and other stakeholders are built. This could be done by ensuring that proper social and environmental auditing is conducted which ensures that the company is working in a fair and environmental friendly way. This would allow investors and other stakeholders to invest in the company leading to increased market share. The drawbacks which I mentioned was that these two boards are working separately so there is no unity of one leader but rather separation of two leaders and if both combines them there would be more ideas and knowledge which isn’t happened. Hope this is correct as well ?
Guys I don’t remember about sale of subsidiary. Is there a second variant as well?
Yes, I think there was a second variant. Not everyone had the same questions.
Thank you. I started worrying that I might have omitted something.
When will Dec 2020 results be out pls??
Think it's 18th Jan.
Hello,
I'm looking for a Study buddy for the SBL exam if you are interested then reach out to me at [email protected]
Thanks pal. I'm preparing for the March exam was getting too into the models which seems like a bad idea. Did you use any of the models in your exam at all?
Results out at midnight!
I'm scared!
Good luck everyone.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

