AAA*** ACCA Paper AAA March 2020 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Not a chance on this earth have I passed this exam. CBE in Birmingham was a complete disaster. People were starting the exam in stages so had so many distractions in the room, the invigilators were on the phone throughout the exam chatting away to ACCA. Didn't start my exam until 10:05am and some students hadn't even started at 11:30am. When I left, the 1:00pm students were waiting outside, who knows what time they managed to get started?
It was so disruptive and when I finally managed to read the content and a question, a student would get up and move and I would see it out the corner of my eye and lose all trail of thought. My answers were diabolical. I'm so frustrated with how bad it went because I could have easily passed this exam. Cheers ACCA...
What did you write in 1b? And also tell I find some same ethical issues in 1b and 3b? Don't knw whether I was right or wrong in my judgement.
Well very few candidates discussing answers here. Hopefully the result does not become a disaster. I'm feeling very worried. I attempted only 70 marks.
@alex145 said: Question 1a Management basis creative accounting Operating segment for Daryl co as assets over 10% of total group assets Amortisation on licences should be separated out 3,4,5 years Related party disclosure failure to disclose sale of property to ceo Risk in that statements due to Daryl operating different regulations Risk in reconciliation of I tercompsny balances due to different year end Goodwill should be impairment Daryl actually operating at a loss Revenue recognition incorrect as performance obligation not yet satisfied therefore 1 months worth of revenue overstated possibility in prior year. Ifrs 5 sale of discontinued non current assets the property that is unused may not be recognised correctly I.e depreciation charged when should be. Does that sound near enough them all?Whar did u write in 1b. Also tell about 3b. As i felt same ethical issues in both questions. don't knw whether my judgement was right or wrong. Also discuss other answers too as very less candidates are discussing answers of AAA here as compared to other optional paper exams. Don't know why?
I wondered that too - not many people are discussing their answers. I can’t remember the questions anymore, honestly.
Q1a)
- Foreign sub so inherent risk certain treatments that use local framework won’t match the group’s. Also there may not be a solution to any mismatch.
- Business model also an inherent risk affecting revenue recognition and cut-off period on P&L re when trial versions are ceased/cancellations occur/new subscriptions happen.
- Goodwill impairment on Daryl Co - overstated
- Amortisation of licences treated incorrectly so risk IA over/understated and amortisation expense over/understated.
- Substantial cancellations with Daryl co may also mean assets should be impaired.
- New sub, so need to disclose how this will affect the group structure
- The forecast - risk that it could be overstated due to mgmt bias
- Risk that revenue for the subscriptions may be recognised before payment received from customers & therefore could be overstated in this regard.
I’m sure there was more I wrote on this - just can’t remember now. Was this the one that also had the fraud??? And they asked the audit implications & procedures or perhaps it was another question.
Birmingham cbe disaster-started after 12pm-complained on the website already.
@ahmadraza2 Q1B) Yes there was ethical issues I think it was the audtiors of daryl co neegan providing non audit services from what I remember I added safeguards for it aswell since daryl co was not listed I believe.
Q1a)
done a few analytical procedures-relating to case
provision not recognised since legal claim was not going to be won in the case.
foreign exchange-wrong exchange rates used.
intangibles assets-useful life not clear on amortization.
revenue recognition-revenue recognised too early.
related party disclosures-not disclosed in fs
management bias-revenue seemed overstated
goodwill needs to be impaired.
Hey guys, does anyone remember questions and marks they carried?
You can download the March 2020 Q paper from here https://www.accaglobal.com/an/en/student/exam-support-resources/professional-exams-study-resources/p7/past-exam-papers/international-stream.html
@lazyali you And me almost wrote same risks but there are other imp. Risks that we miss. Anyways these will also give us marks hopefully. But my question was does anyone realize the same ethical issues or threats in 1b and 3b as I wrote almost same so I wonder that I may have gone wrong somewhere that were self review and management reaponsibility
@alex145 said: Question 1a Management basis creative accounting Operating segment for Daryl co as assets over 10% of total group assets Amortisation on licences should be separated out 3,4,5 years Related party disclosure failure to disclose sale of property to ceo Risk in that statements due to Daryl operating different regulations Risk in reconciliation of I tercompsny balances due to different year end Goodwill should be impairment Daryl actually operating at a loss Revenue recognition incorrect as performance obligation not yet satisfied therefore 1 months worth of revenue overstated possibility in prior year. Ifrs 5 sale of discontinued non current assets the property that is unused may not be recognised correctly I.e depreciation charged when should be. Does that sound near enough them all?@alex145 kindly tell what did u write in 1b for ethical issues and audit strategy responses
Hi sorry had not been on this in a few days as not many where discussing answers.
3b I put
2 year fee dependency over 15% not listed yet so ok currently with safeguards in place if listed not allowed self interest threat
Familiarity threat long association with engagement partner ok at the minute if safeguards such as quality review takes place, when listed the firm will have to replace the engagement partner for a minimum of 2 year cooling period
Self review threat, taking on management responsibility providing accounting services should only provide payroll as mechanical in nature
Intimidation threat as the firm is going to put it out for tender may make the audit firm feel they have to make unrealistic promises in order to keep the contract a significant element of their income this also affects the professional standards of the audit firm
Advocacy threat if they carry out the share valuation etc this is not allowed as no safeguards can protect the firm they can only provide a summary of the business risks.
The firm should state its capabilities and if this does not meet the clients needs then it should be declined.
1b
Review board minutes and the relevant board minute for date of approval for sale of property
Sale agreement
External valuation of the property and a copy of the fixed asset register to help auditor reasonableness of sales price
Review bank statements post year end to vouch any payments in relation to outstanding payments
Then first part of 1b
Familiarly threat
Professional competence of audit firm
Lack of professional scepticism
Should not set a materiality for revuene so be a % of revenue 5-10%
In adequate testing think there was more but can’t remeber off the top of my head
2a
Limitation of scope
Fraud agreed upon procedures so audit only gets paid for this if management want procedures down, can’t bill this into the agreeded fee for example, however audit firm may have to carry out subscribe testing as this fraud may be the tip of the ice berg and with the ceo not wanting an invesgation could suggest conclusion and possible money laundering activities, if suspected the audit most report it to the MLRO, more actions include trace all payments to a particular bank account to see if 40000 is the full amount, extra professional scepticism needed as this could have an effect on the whole financial statements as it increases engagement risk if inappropriate report issued extra planning is needed
Does any of this sound right maybe I am off track don’t really know
@alex1425 In 1b I go completely wrong
I wrote risk and materiality are opposite so the amount should not increase as risk is increasing due to losses plus switching on assets not preferred. Also going concern issues F/S may be prepared on an inaccurate basis.
Self review anf management responsibility threats and safeguard due to payroll. Also sufficient appropriate evidence not obtained
Integrity of management sale may be on non-commercial or favorable terms.
By looking at your answer hoping to fail now as according to you payroll is mechanical and in 1b there was familiarty threat as I remember there was 8 year relation so you are right.
I have to start my preperation again for June attempt as I will be in 40's :((((
Payroll is mechanical in nature the issue was that they do the payroll which is fine however they use a estimate it should not be an estimate if they are providing the work it should be 100% correct, also I can’t remeber the exact detail but separate teams should be used as a self review threat is possible as a member that done the payroll might be in charge of reviewing their own work might be unable to detect errors
You will be fine
@alex145 still I will get only 1 mark for that. The rest of the issues that I wrote were irrelevant so If out of 70 marks paper which I attempted 10 marks go incorrect. I left only with 60 marks to obtain 50 marks. :( But your all answers are excellent. Since everyone knows knowledge wise but I wonder how you guys able to extract all information throughout the paper in alloted time. And yes last attempt was more easy as there were a lot of materiality marks unlike this paper but I failed last time too by attemptinglg only 62 and getting 44. Hoping to fail at 45 this time too. Pray for me
I failed it in September 2019 didn’t have time left out 20 Mark question so I have been working on my time management I got 48 that time which is annoying
@alex145 This time you are going to score 70+. And I wonder when people say that we fail at 48 or 49 because whether I fail at 45 or pass at 50. I never score above 45 when I fail. Though when I pass at 50 I always thought that they conpensated me I may have score 48 or 49
Not sure I have have got 48 in audit and 48 and 49 in sbl
@alex145 Thank God it didn't happen to me throughout my journey though it was long due to break. But what didn't happen can happen now as this is my last exam. Feeling scared
If I get this I have sbl and sbr left I’ll try to do them in june
@alex145 u still have doubt of passing. U have identifed all major audit risks and other answers are commendable too. Unlike me who has identified half risks through scenerio and half just assumed like foreign exchange transaction/translation risk, disclosures relating to legal case, revenue derived from each offer should be allocated seperately which may not be required
I am unable to attempt more than 75 marks. Could someone please advise me as to how can we attempt whole paper and yet earn 80%-90%. What should be the right length of an audit risk answer and how many points for a 24 marker?
There are two articles "sticky" posted ("starred") at the top of this forum:
- "How to tackle the AAA exam" https://opentuition.com/topic/new-article-for-aaa-students-how-to-tackle-the-acca-aaa-exam/
- "Looking for guidance on marking? Read the mind of an AAA marker" https://opentuition.com/topic/looking-for-guidance-on-marking-read-the-mind-of-an-aaa-marker/
The 1st has advice for time management and the 2nd provides invaluable insights in how much you (or rather, how little) you need to write to secure a pass.
@ankitwadhavan said: I am unable to attempt more than 75 marks. Could someone please advise me as to how can we attempt whole paper and yet earn 80%-90%. What should be the right length of an audit risk answer and how many points for a 24 marker?Watch Kashif Kamran videos on Youtube. I had only 4 weeks to revise and found his videos through suggestions from other students here with 1 week left of study. His videos helped in how to structure my answers and learn more about the mark allocations. I would also highly recommend reading through the technical articles on the ACCA website on Risks, Audit procedures, ethics, etc because that also helped me as well. I managed to attempt 90% of the paper but that was down to poor time management on my part. I'm just hoping I haven't done too much damage :(.
Thank you so much!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

