AAA*** ACCA P7 March 2018 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
How many points would be enough for the requirement professional skepticism
Didn’t think it was an evil paper so I’ve voted for ‘ok’. I could’ve done better but I don’t like group audits. Fingers crossed that I have written enough for a 50!
@silentman said: How many points would be enough for the requirement professional skepticismIt was 9 marks wasn’t it? I’d say 4 well explained points would’ve been enough. i think I wrote 5 just to be on the safe side.
So what were the other questions please?
I have also wrote 4 points but generic all
any1 do ques. 5? what was the $5million cost?
Hey! I did the Uk variant of the paper-unfortunately you don't get the mark scheme. Can anyone remember the breakdown for question 1 please? Thank you!!
Q3 is QC, implications on the audit and actions and communication with Mgt and TCWG.
Q4 is ethical questions
Q2 (a) etical question and importance of DD;
(b)PFI, procedures 9 marks
i did the UK variant as well. mark allocation would have made things a lot better.
i think Q1 requirement was;
- audit risk
- areas requiring more professional scepticism
- xxx don't remember, something else here i think
- using work of the component auditor
not easy with such limited time!
Q1 -
Part A : 14 marks Audit Risks
Part B: 9 marks
Part C : 8 marks
Thanks. What was the 'significant component' part worth for marks?
Wasn’t really disclosed, but they gave 8 marks for part C in total, therefore it’s likley it was worth 4 marks.
Did you calculate the currency to dollars and then say if it was above or below 15% threshold or not, ie significant component
@arvind111 said: Wasn’t really disclosed, but they gave 8 marks for part C in total, therefore it’s likley it was worth 4 marks. Did you calculate the currency to dollars and then say if it was above or below 15% threshold or not, ie significant componentAh ok, thank you! Nope, just remember converting it and then working out the percentage compared to total group assets. Didn't say a lot for it as I wasn't 100% what it was.
What kinds of points did people write for Q1, part B -
Explain what professional scepticism was?
Corporate governance issue
Lack of accounting knowledge from management?
So, what i did was calculated the percentage by converting it with 4 Oska rate and it was 68/4 which was 17 and 20% of Group Assets. I also did something different, i calculated the average rate because of the fluctuations and calculated the assets that way as well. It was still significant.
@arvind111 said: What kinds of points did people write for Q1, part B - Explain what professional scepticism was? Corporate governance issue Lack of accounting knowledge from management?What I wrote was management was relying on industry norms rather than calculations. Moreover, they were just not agreeing to impair the intangibles even though a huge part of their assets consisted of them. Talked about goodwill impairment as well, along with the foreign subsidiary and maybe hedging is used with complex derivatives and financial instruments, which are difficult to understand.
For professional scepticism, I wrote about the management judgement for the forecast information about the new systems- might be bias/ over optimisic and how the 10 years for the royalty part wasn't based on anything? Might be completely wrong???
Yeah that was a tricky part really - think you could have taken it many ways.
What did people write for audit risks
1. New client - detection risks
2. Opening balances - Rom
3. Translation risks
4. Use of other auditor for sub
5. Software amortisation or review for impairment at year end as nothing was said to be done for the purchased bits
6. Operating segments - separate disclosures
7. Transfer of assets between group - inter company eliminations so that balance not held in both companies???
Anything else
I believe this was a very fair paper. However, time pressures made it almost impossible to answer all questions in detail. Fingers crossed for a 50. P5 left.
@arvind111 said: Yeah that was a tricky part really - think you could have taken it many ways. What did people write for audit risks 1. New client - detection risks 2. Opening balances - Rom 3. Translation risks 4. Use of other auditor for sub 5. Software amortisation or review for impairment at year end as nothing was said to be done for the purchased bits 6. Operating segments - separate disclosures 7. Transfer of assets between group - inter company eliminations so that balance not held in both companies??? Anything elseI dont recall it being a new client, I didn't write any points related to that. Mine were 1- Intragroup Transactions - 20 subsidiaries and a lot of volume and about the software worth $1m transferred at $5.4m which was inappropriate. 2- Intangible Assets - A lot of intangible assets and not correct treatments 3- Goodwill Impairment 4- Revaluation by management rather than Expert. 5- Foreign Subsidiary - IAS 21 Closing Rate 6- Fluctuation - Derivates/Financial Instruments
In the top paragraph it said that the auditors were appointed in Sept 17, mid way through the year they were auditing, which just opened the flood gates for many easy detection risks.
Q1 (a)
(1) Audit risk 14 marks; (2) professional skepticism 9 marks.
(b) (1) significant component (2) risk assessment 8 marks
Hi everyone how was paper . I wrote professional sceptisim regarding Revaluation done by group memeber May be subjective , analytical procesure and one other thing.please comment
I voted for easy! It really was, but I run out of time. This was my first attempt and I don't think I will pass. Also, English is not my native language so I need more time to write :(
From part B I wrote for Q3 and Q5. Q5 was based on final review with 3 parts
Q1 - first I thought that it's new client too, but then I realised that probably it's not. According to the previous exam papers, the examiner always tell us if it is a new client so I didn't write about opening balances.
what is a significant component. i wrote that if that asset are more than 15% of group assets. Is it okay???
My first attempt of this paper and it was so time pressured!
I done Q4 first within the 36 minutes and then Q1. I didn’t spend time to plan Q1 which is why I think my answer was messy & I panicked and over run on time. I only wrote minimal points for 1a and then 1b as I had to move onto the other questions so I know I am no where near a 50% pass on this question.
I think it might be a retake in June :(
I wrote a similar thing, fingers crossed it’s right and we pick up a few marks!
with the component auditor part in question 1 what were they asking for?.and what were they asking for in question 2
what was the answer to the due diligence part on question 2?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

