APM*** ACCA P5 June 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
I ran out of time also, it was very wordy and you waste so much time trying to almost guess what the examiner is asking you. Surely if the questions were more specific, the markers would have clearer and better quality answers from students. When revising using past papers I was constantly having to look at the answers to start me off, otherwise I would not know where to begin.
@zahra1003 said: The paper was a complete disaster Acca is money minded How can a paper be like this Q1 i) was on revised budgeting for q1 by using incremental budegeting (6 m) ii) prepare rolling budget for a division (6m) iii) was on how the 4 division has been performinng and recommend (19m) IV) non executive directors comment (6m) V) cant remember the question was on 12m and i left this part out of q2 was on performance management calculation of roce and part was on balance scorecard q3 was on current performance issues and how to add (10m) Use of lean information for new proposed measures (6m) Use of lean 5s for the proposed measures (11m) Q4 a company was about to acquire another company and both compagnies info was given... benefits and consequences of use of employees bonus scheme to assess if can be used in both business(8m)... use of pest for employees bonus scheme in both business(6m) and last was on mckinsey 7s model by using structure strategy style and value base for both businesses and recommend kpi to be appropriate (11) Overall was not expecting budegeting and others questions was lengthy and very time consuming. Very disappointed with the paper settingV) cant remember the question was on 12m and i left this part out of - was about changing role of accountant.
Why didnt Q3? I did Q3 this was easy, it was very common with F8 the waste in MIS. Also comment on KPIs for 5S measures and lean principles. Q2, Q4 and part 1,2, and NEDs of Q1 was disaster:)
Yes changing role of the accountant, there are literally 2 pages devoted to this in the study book, and no meaningful reference to burns and scapel, talked about how accountants were purely financial due to taking longer to do reporting. How it and integrated systems have improved information choice allowing then to become operationally focused and business partners. Also access to big data allowing boards access to more information to judge performance. Seemed like waffle!
Q4, I have read the McKinsey stuff after and still think I would not have answered the q differently as the study text only states the obvious I.e. strategy is how should the company operate. Hopefully answered this correctly it was guess work!
This was my 4th attempt and pretty sure I'll be sitting it again. I felt confident on my third attempt and got 45% but don't feel as confident this time so god knows what score I'll get. I concur with all the comments here - Q1 was ok and the optional questions had too much information and were challenging. Who would ever in the real world use PEST to determine a bonus scheme? I think the requirements are so badly worded it's so easy for the examiner to say every time that students didn't answer the question being asked but why does he have to word them the way he does? I'm sure it could be worded in a way to make it clear what he is after. I've been over the syllabus many times, read the articles, watched the videos, practised many past papers and still not successful if I don't pass this one I seriously will consider choosing a different option paper. It's my last paper I just want to get it done!!!!
Was my last exam and the only one I never completed. Ridiculously time pressured - bad enough the scenarios being hard enough to digest but why not just ask a straight question?
I'm wondering what the examiner is really trying to test here. Can't see how being able to read at 100 miles an hour and digest ambiguous questions will set you apart in the real world.
Anyway, we shall put it to bed until results come.
I'm very disappointed with that paper it was my 3rd attempt and probably my worst. Q4 I spent over an hour on and got very confused had to keep rereading the question, went over time on section b and then hadn't a hope when got to Q1 as it was so time consuming. I think the examiner is just trying to catch you out instead of allowing you to use the knowledge you have learned studying for P5. I really don't know what I could do differently time to improve my chances of passing... Acca is a money racquet
Hi there - good luck for your results !!! - I found it a bit difficult and some question s were confusing. Q1 was very long with a lot of narrative and the budget calculation – I moved to Q3 after about 1 hour and 45 minutes. Q3 was ok – the 5s were listed but a lot of mental work to relate them to the scenario. Moved to Q2 30 minutes before the end of the exams and tried to answer as much as I could. This was my first attempt but I was already expecting something difficult after practicing with last exams papers.
Q1) Heading, introduction, conclusion and style 4 marks as usual.
i) I don't remember exactly, only a lot of narrative about incremental but honestly don't remember the requirements.
ii) I calculated a budget inflating the actual results Q: by 2% sales and cost of sales and reducing Distribution cost for 5% from Q3 - wrote assumptions that admin and fixed cost did not change because of the sales growth.
iii) If I remember correctly this part asked to evaluate the current budgetary systems in each of the 4 divisions and recommend an appropriate budgetary system to enable to meet the goals. I analysed the 4 divisions demands and cost patterns eg. Basic was in non growing market with a stable price > incremental ok - KIDS was a very volatile price due to popularity of the snacks > rolling budget and PD (product development) being shared between divisions I recommended ZBB
iv) What was the comment of the NED??? (getting confused with Q2 that NEDS comments on short termism)
V) If I remember correctly this part was about the study of Burns and Scapens (changes in the role of management accountant - hybrid accountant) and it was required an explanation of the results of their work AND to discuss how the hybrid accountant can contribute to achieve these 3 goals set in the strategy. If you want check it out: page 27 kaplan text book.
Kaplan in few words "new technologies and globalized markets - several employees can book financial information and do reports - accountant must be able to elaborate the information from the IS and able to give strategic advice to mngmt - accountant must have knowledge outside pure accounting e.g. IT, Sales, maybe production process - key role of the accountant providing information " (I liked these section and I discussed about 1 months ago with a friend and I could remember well at the exams)
Q2)
i) Calculation of ROCE – left Roce as a last because looked time consuming for only 5-6 points. Went directly to the pro and cons of ROCE, short termism and suggested better model to evaluate shareholders wealth growth (which was the mission)
ii) Discussed ROCE, NEDS comment on short-termism and managers not investing (training and material assets ) to keep capital employed low and therefore maintain ROCE and bonus
iii) – how the Balance score card can help to focus on the long term and assess the proposed CSF/KPI for Financial – customer - innovation (I listed BSC elements and gave example how setting KPI for customers perspective, innovation and learning helps adopting a long-term view . for the second part: EVA is good for shareholder wealth, KPI for customer was ok but only consider 1 fault of the mould not quality / cust. satisfaction – KPI for innovation I suggested patents and investment in training and R&D
Q3)
i ) don’t remember. Anyone remember this part ????
ii) probably “how lean production reduce the waste” (I think I forgot to refer to waste in each line..probably I went out of topic… damn!) – Anybody remember this one ???
iii) Something like: are the actions implemented by the CEO useful for a lean production according to the 5s (daily tidiness check > sanitize - sorting the goods in alphabetical order > ok for Structure but what about if the most demanded products start with Z: they are far from dispatch areas – don‘t remember the other measure suggested by the CEO )
Q4) I did not try these one - check the question and realized I could have got stuck but not sure if it was the right decision
I felt like I did OK. On Q1:
i. Struggled to understand the revision until I realized it needed to be flexed, as the variance analysis was otherwise useless.
ii. Rolled the budget and hoped for the best. I used Q1 actual's ratio of distribution to sales to calculate Q2's initial distribution, then dropped it by 5%.
iii. As the poster above -- I did ABC for Basic (it's a cost-conscious division -- they should analyze cost drivers and stop riding off management's ancient cost control attempts), rolling for Kids, and ZBB for PD. I kept rolling for Healthy.
iv. Tried to use the BPP flashcard on the evils of budgeting here (adds slack, all that good stuff), but also blamed corporate HQ for not enforcing more of a value culture and letting the divisions manage the numbers instead of manage the business.
v. Fortunately, I had a big flashcard on this topic and was able to elaborate a lot. It seems like the new CEO was right on board with this hybrid accountant stuff; easy references to the company.
On Q3:
a. I hope this was the easy mark question. It simply asked if the WIS is supporting reduction of waste/meeting their goals right now, and the answer is obviously, resoundingly, NO, with examples of how they're failing their basic mission to be responsive as a supplier.
b. I used the WITDOOM wastes (waiting, inspection, transfer, defects, overprocessing, overproduction, movement/NVAs) to structure this. As follows:
i. Close down additional warehouse -- yes, provided they're ready to implement the other suggestions
ii. Put high volume items near dispatch point -- hell yes, great idea
iii. Can't remember
c. As follows:
i. Manager's 1-10 tidiness rating -- I said it's an OK quantitative surrogate, but needs other measures, since it solely dependson the manager and his/her idea of tidiness may not actually correspond to performance improvement. Links to sanitization, but I referenced all the other Ses except self-discipline too.
ii. Alphabetization -- Referenced systemization but argued against this as it's stupid. Items should be grouped by demand or likeness (soccer vs. baseball etc.)
iii. Number of failures -- yes, but it does'nt really hit operational 5 Ses. I referenced self-discipline as, provided the other Ses are taken care of, they WILL see fewer failures and this is the point of the entire change.
Q4 messed with my mind because it was obvious that LORE had made a mistake in acquiring CF, which was radically different from LORE's culture and values. As follows:
i. Talked about performance measures and renumeration helping motivate and retain staff, especially in CF's low-wage economy. I then went on a diatribe about how CF was in danger of incentivizing short-termism and unethical behavior, using examples, as the huge bonuses provided too much incentive to flip properties without due care that LORE would otherwise provide.
ii. PEST for employees -- the contrast between cultures helped me here. Politically, CF poses a huge reputational risk to LORE, which could lead to an economic risk too. Socially, CF is much less a multiple-stakholder beast, as a further contrast. For technology, I completely forgot what I said, other than that the two might offer amenities to tenants or something like that.
iii. KPIs were:
Shared values -- assumed this meant LORE's social interaction -- "number of volunteer initiatives undertaken"
Strategy -- assumed this meant for CF to transition to LORE's way of doing things -- "% revenue from tenant leases over 1 year term", since CF is flipping properties and needs to hold
Structure -- wasn't completely sure; forgot the KPI.
Style -- really unsure here. Went with something like, CF's style is run and gun, managers close deals, while LORE's is very slow-burning with multiple levels of review. So I went with "% of acquisitions that have gone through one level of review", saying LORE must choose the reviewer for CF's acquisitions in the future.
Question 4 is really where I feel I may have lost marks. It was just so jarring -- why would LORE acquire CF in the first place? Seemed totally misguided, and I kept hammering that point.
I like everyone else it seems struggled with this paper. I was sure I passed last time, however got 48. This time I know it's a fail.
I can't believe ACCA approved the examiner to issue this exam paper. I am so angry with it all. Completely different to past papers and questions were huge marks for topics that were so brief in study material for both BBP and Kaplan ( the biggest providers).
What was question 1a) all about? Should the question have been prepare Q2 budget, typo maybe?, why would you re-create Q1 when actuals have already occurred.
Generally far too much reading in the time allocated with trick questions - for example I seen PEST and thought perform PEST analysis but no the question was why use a PEST and for something like 8 marks?
Very unfair paper and I hope someone from ACCA reads this forum. They just want our money (yet again)
The exam was just OK.
Question 1 - Was ok but 1a no idea.. revise a budget that is already revised and simple enough?? Even my grandma would understand it, did he just want us to copy and paste it onto the answer sheet
Question 2 - what has the examiner been drinking, what a shambolic question but I gave it ago. Probably got around 10 marks.
Question 3 - What on earth was this, only he knows the answers
Question 4 - waffled i think i wrote 4 pages
I was literally tearing my hair out in Q2 part A. I mean we are supposed to calculate ROCE for an entity, Why are you making us calculate contribution using another company (manufacturer's utilization) and not providing revenues of the company for which we are supposed to calculate ROCE.
@sa1pw said: I was literally tearing my hair out in Q2 part A. I mean we are supposed to calculate ROCE for an entity, Why are you making us calculate contribution using another company (manufacturer's utilization) and not providing revenues of the company for which we are supposed to calculate ROCE.That too for 11 mark or something. I just couldn't get that part. Very frustrating
@Minaa said: That too for 11 mark or something. I just couldn't get that part. Very frustratingThis is shambolic. Like seriously, Which company doesn't record it's revenues and calculates it's ROCE by it's customer's utilization figures.
Second attempt, but it was worse than the first one. Am I trying to break the theory of the learning curve? Didn't finish Q4 due to lack of time, needed to reread several times the questions in order to understand what they meant... I've chosen Q2 and Q4 because there was less to read, but I don't think I understood the details around the moulds at all. I am starting to question my English skills as well...Maybe I need to go to a speed-reading class instead of attempting P5 for the third time.
Glad I'm not the only one who thought this exam was a joke. Where was everything that is covered in class? Spent 18 hours last week doing past exam questions which didn't help me at all in this exam.
I encountered time pressure which was due to long scenarios and volume of information to process. In real life there will be similar situations relevant to those in the question however there will be adequate time to make decent assessments contrasting with the time management issues within questions. Questions 1 D was not clear as to what requirement was also. Overall I am hoping for pass given the many hours preparing for topics such as VBM, EVA, Prism, pyramid, ABM, Transfer Pricing, Building Blocks,TQM, EMA etc.
Prior to choosing which option question to proceed it meant having to read and understand the requirements first which in itself took time as this required second read to extract points. I found this problem in option #2 and therefore had to move unto option #3 then # 4 rather than simply committing without any rational planning .
haha speed reading.
This paper was so lenghty and the wording was so lame and misleading that is impossible to complete in 3 hours.
Not sure what the P5 examiner is trying to achieve but I'm 100% sure that the examiner himself on similar type questions, under exam conditions will not be able to score more than 60 marks with a push.
How does he expect than someone to score 50 and to pass the paper if the maximum achieveable target in my view in 3 hours is no more than 60 marks.
And yes to be even worse this is P5 Performance management where targets need to be achieveable and they are not on this paper.
I know one thing for sure and that is he is not testing our knowledge.
In the real world you have time to think about and answer.
I'm sure if the exam is face to face I will pass with no problem and this should in theory be more difficult than on the wrtten paper.
Obviously his intentions are to fail as many students as possible and ACCA are tolerating this which is ridiculous.
This was my second attempt and it was a disaster. I studied hard for this exam and I feel defeated. All my previous exams I passed the first time. Now I am down to the last two and I cant do it. The questions was long and detailed and there wasn't enough time to answer the questions. I wrote something for each question though. Really wasn't expecting so much on budgeting and that ROCE calculation was complicated, I got lost and I knew I calculated wrong but there was not enough time to figure what I did wrong and fix it. Some questions seem vague, I didn't know what the examiner expected us to write. aye, I hope I did enough for the 50%.
I have spent 10days ...10 hours per day, practising 82 problems,plus I have read the courses from an ACCA provider, plus ca notes from open tuition, plus some technical articles and still I didn't have any time to think and finish the problems...I think it is a fail, the first from all the P exams
I did ABC for healthy. There were problems in the cost for healthy one of the appendices. ZBB for basic, mentioned although it was a stable market but cost reduction was one of the main new strategic objectives, ZBB would support that. Rolling for kids. Can't remember what I did for PD. I think it was ZBB.
The examiner is should get understanding of the Building Block Model that targets should be achievable , motivating, fair,claear...here in exams nothing is achievable, motivating and fair bla bla...even didnt understand what some wording from scnario...
P5 is tough and frustrating. I did the 3rd attempt and hope it went well.
But I highly appreciated it toughness. For some paper like P3, I pass even without understanding topic. But for P5, i must understand the topic from inside out. It took me 2 times the time I spent for other papers
Some topic like Performance Prism, linking strategy to stakeholder, process, resources really widen my horizon, which is quite limited even after I passed some papers
what a disaster, a total flip in terms of the Q1. no past papers had such a question
I agree question 2 was was needlessly confusing, ROCE is so basic but this impressions business just wasted a lot of time.
That makes two of us :)
I truly think this exam is doomed, there is a sort of malediction. I sat at my desk at the ExCel centre,thought "oh new, comfy, chairs" and pinched a nerve. I fainted, it happened twice in the past, it is a fuse for my body when there is intense pain. Paramedic came and I started the exam 30 minutes later. It was complete chaos, I only read the questions, hardly the texts, only appendixes, and I attempted all of them. I am really curious about the result. It is unfortunate as I took and passed 10 exams in three sittings and this was the only one remaining. That is why, as many of you, I truly believe in some kind of malediction. I may even switch to P6, not trying a second attempt.
Q1 part (v) was about changing role of management accountant and linking to the scenario for introducing ERPS for 11 marks.
complete disaster. too much to read and think about in limited time.
first attempt. complete disaster. I completely agree with you, its a test of English and decision making skills to choose the right question rather than test of your knowledge and application of P5

