AFM*** ACCA P4 September 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Hi All
How did we all find it? This was my first professional exam and first sitting, found is very time pressured and tricky, especially Q1. I done two NPVs, one for P country and the other to show the effect in any CAPS country. 1 Positive and 1 Negative. Messed up on the exchange rates for P/$, found it very tricky so used OFR based on the current inflation. Also missed off the 60& contribution and apportionment back to the US company ! ! !
I chose Q2 and Q4 - thought they were okay considering.
Interested to know other thoughts.
Wow Investment appraisal in Q1...What a shocker! I have to say though a good one too. It's about time. My last few attempts at this paper have all had Business Valuation in Q1. Nice to see a change. Hoping for a pass this time.
Question 2 and Question 4 were just about as easy as this paper would ever get. I ran out of time doing Question 1 so I am still not definitely sure about passing it.
i thought q1 was ok.. better than last time, but very time consuming.. there was a lot of info...
did not get time to finish the whole paper
really annoyed as the last question was something i could easily answer and score but couldnt finish in time..
did q1, then q4, then q2 or 3 (sources of finance)
@kabangamc said: Wow Investment appraisal in Q1...What a shocker! I have to say though a good one too. It's about time. My last few attempts at this paper have all had Business Valuation in Q1. Nice to see a change. Hoping for a pass this time.true. there have been a lot of business valuation questions in recent sittings, its probably because this is the area of p4 where students have consistently failed to perform. although this appriassal question was not easy either, it was tricky and long.. but still better than the q1 we had last time..
its really annoying when the examiner deliberately makes these attempts to make the question longer and longer.. there was no need for few currencies to be adjusted for inflation.. either all or none.. but examiner deliberately made some adjusted from question itself so we keep going back to repeat the whole purchasing power parity formula applied on cashlow exchange rates.. very annoying indeed!! >.<
This exam is too time pressured. I did not finish it all.
Q1 was better than Jun-17. The only problem is I ran out of time! and got confused/time taken up by all the exchange rates.
P4 is a test of speed! reading fast , figuring out what needs to be done, calculating quickly.
I'm too slow. Would feel more confident if I finished.
Has anybody else noticed the section B scenarios (text to read) are becoming nearly as long as Section A!
Question 1 was tough with cross rates and two npvs.
I couldnt answer the q1 well.
To me, it was tough.
P4 Exam was tough and time pressured. I did q4, q2, and q1 in that order. I got confused on q4a after answering q4b, which is more of an essay or theory. Q2 went smoothly. Then l tried q1. The exchange rates and long information confused me. But I settled to do npv in NR after initially wasting some time. I di not complete NPV for Pusha. I converted the local cost into $ and NR. The local cost generally lower in Pusha than other countries. I then assumed that the NPV should be higher since that is main variable that changed. This then enabled to write the report to the board.
One good thing about this Exam is that the calculations are worth only about 35%. Judging by previous examiners reports and the mark allocation, the NPV calculation in Q1is not worth more than 20 marks. This leaves 30 marks for the theory, report, and professional marks. The hedging calculation in Q4 is 15 marks. The whole of Q2 is mainly theory for 25 marks. Thus for q1, 2, and q4, there is a total of 65 marks for theory, essay, report and professional marks.
@maxbillion said: Question 1 was tough with cross rates and two npvs. I couldnt answer the q1 well. To me, it was tough.agreed, it wasnt easy, like always with p4.. but it was considerably better than the June attempt.. although more lengthy imo.
Q4b was tricky. It was not simply advantages and disadvantages of centralised treasury function per se. It was to compare regional treasury function against country function; and then regional versus global.
Regional versus national treasury function will be centralised at the regional level; but when compared between regional and global the role is reversed. The clues are actually in the scenario as a new regional structure is in place and therefore needs treasury function that match the structure. It is more of an intermediate solution between the national and global treasury functions.
Q4b is worth 10 marks, while q4a is worth 15 marks.
This was my 3rd attempt at this paper. I've never had to resit 3 times and won't be surprised if I have to do a forth attempt. I struggle to read the whole question it's so long... I started my calculations for q1 to realise they had already been calculated for me on the second page. I wasted 20 minutes. Q4 was my favourite but couldn't think of 7 points for 4b. Nightmare paper, I seriously do not want to sit the damn thing again. I passed F9 with 80% and thought P4 would be a breeze, oh how mistaken I was!
This is my third attempt on this paper. For the past last two sitting I had been making the same mistake with this time thinking to correct it and pass but oooh no I have lost out words.
Idid q1 first which I got confused with the way the information was packed. Get lost in the process almost given up and try to pick up. Time overrun.
Then I had to go to q4 tried to calculate the hedging and get panicked as well. By the time I had to attempt the last question almost 30 minutes left. Chose 3 on expense of 2 and big mistake that had cost my sitting as well.
Reading the question and started it got stuck on the way and not knowing how to go about it.
And for the whole 25 mark quiz and I do not know how much I attempt. Tired of this paper resitting it the forth time It was not my wish and like but the way they are setting this exam I do note know if they want as to pass.
i got 2 negative npvs too in ques 1. Not sure if its correct because i translate the $ investment for land & buildings & working capital into PP & NR to get Net cash flow & translate it back to $ again. Hope I didnt screw up. I didnt managed to finish the report but finished calculating both Npvs.
By the way, did anyone attempt question 3 its kinda like a reconstruction sum where we have to draw a new SOFP. I was wondering how everyone calculate cost of equity there.
The question give us beta asset, so with that we can get ungeared ke (ie kei) then do we search for geared ke with M&M formula? Or do we use kei in WACC formula?
Thanks.
@elie1lwin said: i got 2 negative npvs too in ques 1. Not sure if its correct because i translate the $ investment for land & buildings & working capital into PP & NR to get Net cash flow & translate it back to $ again. Hope I didnt screw up. I didnt managed to finish the report but finished calculating both Npvs. By the way, did anyone attempt question 3 its kinda like a reconstruction sum where we have to draw a new SOFP. I was wondering how everyone calculate cost of equity there. The question give us beta asset, so with that we can get ungeared ke (ie kei) then do we search for geared ke with M&M formula? Or do we use kei in WACC formula? Thanks.I attempted Q3. Question provided Wacc, cost of debt and capital structure so all inputs to calculate cost of equity. Then you had to ungear equity beta and calculate asset beta of cinema business (asset beta of fitness clubs was given). Regarding Q1 I have also obtained two negative NPVs, which was little bit confusing. Assuming that maximum remittance was up to 60% of taxable profit (I also assumed that at the end of the project remaining cash flows will not be recoverable and are "included" in salvage value) the result couldn't ve positive. For me this question was unnecessarily complicated because calculations were not sophisticated. I wasted too much time on this question and wasn't able to finish 2 optionals..
Qn 01. I got two positive NPV's, I assumed remaining 40% will be remitted at the end of year 4 and the project will be disposed @Yr 4 by the amount given in the exam.
Did anyone else assume the same?
It was really time pressured and I couldn't complete the paper almost 15 marks left out.
Question 1 too long...full of meaninglesss details. Time pressure..
..i got 46 in june...i think i did worse in september :)) never give up
I agree, I felt that for question one we were being tested on how quickly we can read the question and jot down countless numbers. There's no time to sit and think. Thank goodness they've let you start writing during the reading time!
I also got 46 in June, I started on Q4 and completely run over on time. I stupidly started Q3, got completely stuck, spent far too much time and was left with an hour for Q1, didn't read the question properly and messed it up. I did pretty much the same in June, so I'm expecting a similar result. The problem for me is definitely the length of the question, I don't feel like I have time to read it properly. How many times has everyone else sat this exam? This is my 3rd time, it's becoming embarrassing.
@waseem225 said: Qn 01. I got two positive NPV's, I assumed remaining 40% will be remitted at the end of year 4 and the project will be disposed @Yr 4 by the amount given in the exam. Did anyone else assume the same? It was really time pressured and I couldn't complete the paper almost 15 marks left out.I did the same.. the amount in yr 4 i took as cash inflow.. as limited by time, I only imagined it being similar to land / building sold off end of the project. Another thing if u noticed the working cap. was not released end of the year, that is usually the case when the project continues, so i just went on with it. hopefully it was the right way to go about it..
I assumed the same for the scrap value and put it at the end but I didn't do anything for 40% unremitted to parent.
I got 2 negative npvs and got confused because i thought one of them must be positive.
Anyway the question is too confusing for me with the exchange rate adjustments and everything.
For question 3, I didn't notice the equity beta given and because asset beta for club was given, I used the beta asset in the CAPM formula to get cost of equity ungeared and use M&M formula to get Ke. (Not sure if i screwed up for this.)
I couldnt finish question 3 because i was running out of time
Futures price: 94.78
Exercise prices: 94.25 and 95.25
Yes I assumed the same, lets hope for the best, hopefully our approach is right (I mentioned this approach in assumptions as well)
@fightclubalum said: I did the same.. the amount in yr 4 i took as cash inflow.. as limited by time, I only imagined it being similar to land / building sold off end of the project. Another thing if u noticed the working cap. was not released end of the year, that is usually the case when the project continues, so i just went on with it. hopefully it was the right way to go about it..Yes I assumed the same, lets hope for the best, hopefully our approach is right (I mentioned this approach in assumptions as well)
@d019452 said: I also got 46 in June, I started on Q4 and completely run over on time. I stupidly started Q3, got completely stuck, spent far too much time and was left with an hour for Q1, didn't read the question properly and messed it up. I did pretty much the same in June, so I'm expecting a similar result. The problem for me is definitely the length of the question, I don't feel like I have time to read it properly. How many times has everyone else sat this exam? This is my 3rd time, it's becoming embarrassing.
@d019452 said: I also got 46 in June, I started on Q4 and completely run over on time. I stupidly started Q3, got completely stuck, spent far too much time and was left with an hour for Q1, didn't read the question properly and messed it up. I did pretty much the same in June, so I'm expecting a similar result. The problem for me is definitely the length of the question, I don't feel like I have time to read it properly. How many times has everyone else sat this exam? This is my 3rd time, it's becoming embarrassing.i have sat this exam more no. of times than any other exam in my life! F9 was too easy and i enjoyed it too.. never thought would hit this stop at P4 though.. it sure is embarassing, but we have only one choice dont we? just keep trying again and again and again..have invested far too much time & money in ACCA to quit now. >.<
Assuming that examining team expected solution based on bullet cash flow in Y4 with cash accumulated in years 1-4 is it a chance that I still gain at least half of available marks (9/18) for this point? I remitted only 60% and got 2 negative NPVs but described this in the report.
I initially got two negative NPV's due to the 60% remittance but once I added back the sale cost (which was in year 4, at PV), I got a positive figure for both. Did everyone add back the sale which was in PP?
This was a very tough paper.
The hedging on interest rates was a standard question which comes up a lot, so I felt OK with that, the other Section B question was a nightmare.
And there I was beating myself up for thinking I may have to do a retake.. thank you all I feel so much better now
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

