General ACCA*** ACCA P1 September 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
sorry for slight delay :) you can post your comments now, thank you :)
Thought it was an okay paper!
Did Q2 and 4.
4 was nice, insider trading, ethical principles and csr.
2 was about internal controls and impact of having poor internal controls and suggestions to improve.
Thought 1 was a okay scenario too. Plenty to pick at with lots of bribery corruption.
Basic things on remuneration. Did find it very application based
I wasn't sure if the last question in Q1 about corruption was about the company or the country itself. Any ideas?
@belze001 said: I wasn't sure if the last question in Q1 about corruption was about the company or the country itself. Any ideas?Country I believe. Didn't say Oil after it. Plus fair few points about how it was a corrupt country
I did Q2 and Q4 also and just completed about 92-94% of the paper due to time constraint even my hands kept writing in every single minute.
Not sure if it's enough for 50 marks though. You can't really predict your score in P level. What I wrote might be given marks or otherwise not relevant at all. Hope that luck is by my side this time.
I find that the most difficult thing in P1 is finding out what the examiners actually wanted from the requirements. The way they asked might not be so direct. Or just because English is not my native language.
@belze001 said: I wasn't sure if the last question in Q1 about corruption was about the company or the country itself. Any ideas?I answered it from the country perspective also. Just Xuland mentioned, not Xuland Oil
@hoangduchung1903 said: I answered it from the country perspective also. Just Xuland mentioned, not Xuland OilAgreed. I kind of mentioned how there's bribery top to bottom in the country. It's almost autocratic, media controlled by. All friends at the top. Then just to resolve to try add diversity etc. Thought it was ok mind
Hated it. Having done all of the past papers several times this seemed to be the most narrow exam yet which covered so little of the syllabus but it covered it in great detail. Question 1 was okay but I found myself repeating my answers a lot which was something I found through out the exam.
I don't know if my time management was poor or it was a longer exam than usual but I had to really rush at the end just to answer all of the questions. Due to time constraints I barely looked at question 4, I just saw the first question was about insider trading and looked at the marks and doubted I'd be able to write that much on it.
Having got 44 in June (which looking back on was a much easier paper than this one) I'm predicting between 30 and 40 this time and another resit in December.
@james1114563 said: Agreed. I kind of mentioned how there's bribery top to bottom in the country. It's almost autocratic, media controlled by. All friends at the top. Then just to resolve to try add diversity etc. Thought it was ok mindI suggested diversity in the government also since most of public officials were from one of the ethnic groups
@ddmoo said: Hated it. Having done all of the past papers several times this seemed to be the most narrow exam yet which covered so little of the syllabus but it covered it in great detail. Question 1 was okay but I found myself repeating my answers a lot which was something I found through out the exam. I don't know if my time management was poor or it was a longer exam than usual but I had to really rush at the end just to answer all of the questions. Due to time constraints I barely looked at question 4, I just saw the first question was about insider trading and looked at the marks and doubted I'd be able to write that much on it. Having got 44 in June (which looking back on was a much easier paper than this one) I'm predicting between 30 and 40 this time and another resit in December.I also find the questions were set narrowly but too deeply, especially the part on how internal control helps environment reporting and the importance of completeness in remuneration report. These have never been asked before in past papers. And I was hoping that AAA would come out so that I could grab easy 14 marks but sadly it did not.
Really? Am screwed. I written about the Xuland oil and how it was corrupt. What a fail.
Paper was ok. It was however very easy to run out of time and even after all my practice I still didn't use the correct headings in places. Answered all questions so nothing left in that respect but as we all know, that doesn't mean an awful lot with these papers, particularly when you have three requirements in one..... Roll on October when the lottery results are announced!
@hoangduchung1903 said: I did Q2 and Q4 also and just completed about 92-94% of the paper due to time constraint even my hands kept writing in every single minute. Not sure if it's enough for 50 marks though. You can't really predict your score in P level. What I wrote might be given marks or otherwise not relevant at all. Hope that luck is by my side this time. I find that the most difficult thing in P1 is finding out what the examiners actually wanted from the requirements. The way they asked might not be so direct. Or just because English is not my native language.I completely agree! Although I was thinking maybe the examiners ask more open questions to give space and flexibility to students.
@lolo822 said: So guys what do you do then study the next paper for December or wait for results before studying a new paper?Considering you wont get your results until mid October I think you'll struggle to be ready for the next paper if you don't start until then. I was halfway through studying for P3 when I found out I failed my P1 June exam. I'll likely go back and finish off P3 studying and sit it in December even if I fail P1. Might be better for me to come back to P1 next year with a fresh mind.
@belze001 said: I completely agree! Although I was thinking maybe the examiners ask more open questions to give space and flexibility to students.I think question were quite open ended for sure. But some bits like remuneration etc weren't so much. But corruption there was a lot of points to make
This sitting in Sep'16 is horrible compare to June. Most of the requirement don't really link to the case. And is more on a narrowly
Did everyone talk about Xuland rather then Xuland oil in part (I) of question Corruption question?
@suger890 said: Did everyone talk about Xuland rather then Xuland oil in part (I) of question Corruption question?I spoke about both but I think my suggestions for how to prevent corruption were pretty weak.
I missed out two questions overall. One was a 8 marker on part (ii) of the first question and I missed out a 5 marker on the second question as I ran out of time. I overan the first question by a lot. Not feeling very confident either. I didn't do very well in p1 June either. But I felt June exam was very hard. This one was ok. I hope I've scraped it.
Spent almost 2 hours on the first question but feel it might be worth it. Managed question 3 and 4 in the remaining time - just! I felt a lot of the syllabus I spent time memorizing was unfortunately a waste of time :( anyone else?
@gilmoregirl said: Spent almost 2 hours on the first question but feel it might be worth it. Managed question 3 and 4 in the remaining time - just! I felt a lot of the syllabus I spent time memorizing was unfortunately a waste of time :( anyone else?That's what I was told - essentially with 4 sittings a year we will start to see more random things and perhaps more of a focus on specific parts of the syallabus!
That's good to know, thank you. I suppose I can't complain though as nothing really threw me off!
Just a quick question. In the question about LIBOR about Internal Control compliance did it mean compliance in terms of CG codes or in terms of people bypassing and ignoring internal controls?
Had the feeling I was repeating myself half of the time. Strange exam.
Suggestions against corruption weak. I missed the point wit diversity, forgot about the ethnics. It's frustrating. My 3rd sitting of p1.
But I still have hope as I answered all points. Chose 3 and 4 as I did not want to repeat myself on internal controls... :)
Let's see. Good luck to everyone!
@hoangduchung1903 said: I also find the questions were set narrowly but too deeply, especially the part on how internal control helps environment reporting and the importance of completeness in remuneration report. These have never been asked before in past papers. And I was hoping that AAA would come out so that I could grab easy 14 marks but sadly it did not.I was hoping for any sort of question on Kohlberg, deontology and teleology, absolutism and relativism or CPD for easy marks. The only mnemonic or model I think I used in the end was OAPSPAMS for part C of question 2.
@lolo822 said: So guys what do you do then study the next paper for December or wait for results before studying a new paper?I was halfway through studying P3 for September when I found out I failed the June exam for P1. I'll probably go back and finish it. I might sit P3 in December and come back to P1 next year so I can approach it with a fresh mind.
Can anybody remember how many marks the prevention methods of corruption were worth on question 1? It was such a haze and I can't remember if it was the whole 8 or not? I was struggling to think of suitable ones! Thanks :)
Yes i agree. I done all past exams.Done 2 mocks but still felt that paper was tough even though i passed p3 first time which is mostly based on application and more tough than p1 but not so confidence with this. I hope i pass and good luck to everyone for your resuts.
English is my native language and I still struggle! My biggest concern is time management, q1 took me 2 hours but I don't think I waffled, just so much to comment on in each section.
The topic were ok but the questions were much confusing. still much struggling with professional writing in English and time management.
Question 1 case study a bit harder to understand. When i read it the third time i understand well. I found myself repeating my answers a lot in internal control chapter which was something I found through out the exam.
I know if my time management was poor. Due to time constraints I barely looked at question 4, I just saw the first question was about insider trading and looked at the marks and doubted I’d be able to write that much on it.
I didnt do well! But covered so many chapters during revision. I need more practice in next sitting. Missed a good chance to pass the exam as the paper was capable...
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

