General ACCA*** ACCA P1 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@christa316 said: My threats were self interest, intimidation and familiarityThat's the three I identified too.
90% of The requirements to the question were sooooooo....... CONFUSING..
I found it hard to interprete most of the question requirements.
How could the Examiner make the report iquestion even horrible yet it had the professional mks....??
To be honest, I was following ma instinct while answering coz the confusion was tooooo much.....
Keeping fingers crossed for the nest....
Hi
Do you thing the risk assessment in Q2 or 3 am not sure would be the risk mapping?
My first ACCA exam, I decided to do question 3 and 4 first, found them pretty straightforward and reckon I got some solid marks. Although I agree with those saying that there didn't seem to much differentiation between 4a and 4b. I pretty much repeated myself and I doubt will gain many marks for that.
Question 1 was brutal for me, I was tired by the time I got to it and the amount of reading threw me. Found it hard to extract what they wanted. I didn't practice any case study questions so I only have myself to blame. If I scraped 15 marks out of 50 I'd be grateful.
Feel drained and disappointed. I'm not expecting a pass. Fingers crossed the marker is drinking heavily when they get to my paper.
For the ethical decision part of question 4, I applied ethical decision making (4 steps) rather than AAA, which is 7 steps. Considering it was 5 marks I felt it was more appropriate, plus I was pressed for time. Hope I can be fully credited for it, as it felt appropriate to the scenario.
@montelik said: For the ethical decision part of question 4, I applied ethical decision making (4 steps) rather than AAA, which is 7 steps. Considering it was 5 marks I felt it was more appropriate, plus I was pressed for time. Hope I can be fully credited for it, as it felt appropriate to the scenario.Which part of question 4? I mentioned only PICCO, Self interest, familarity and intimidation. I dont see how people have used AAA or tucker? Im baffled. Someone remember the requirements.?
@vipulv said: Which part of question 4? I mentioned only PICCO, Self interest, familarity and intimidation. I dont see how people have used AAA or tucker? Im baffled. Someone remember the requirements.?4c) something about explaining the steps Andy should take in order to resolve the ethical dilemma. I don't see how tucker or AAA would fit. I mentioned consulting with ACCA, review legal requirements, look at internal policies. 4a and 4b were the annoying ones. Both very similar and 10 marks which implies 5 ethical threats. I got 3 threats and a dubious 4th.
I think I did ok overall. Good to know am not the only one who was really struggling with the letter, felt like I was regurgitating a lot already stated in that essay of a scenario we have to read. Might as well have written, "Hey shareholders, we love you and always will, yours truly, Sarah Moor"
Time keeping is so difficult, I actually tried being as strict as possible to dedicate 1.8 minutes per mark, sadly my hand has a mind of its own and just kept on writing when I needed to move on to the next bit. Only had half an hour to do Q4, really didn't write as much as I needed to :(
@strwbrrblonde said: Some questions, especially #4, were very confusing. It seemed to me that all the parts were requesting the same... Some strange mix of questions in Q#1. Strange purpose of the letter, strange everything :)Same to me..this question really confuse me..still hoping to pass
Question 3 risk management 8 marks I described the Tara framework. Anyone else? Wondering if I'm barking up the wrong tree!
Also to people who did question 3 what were the environmental concerns in the first part and what did you write about integrated reporting? Have no idea how to get the 8 marks for that part.
Question 2 people are saying they wrote what comprises good info but the question said explain how good info is useful.....so I didn't so much write about the qualities....maybe I've mistook the question....didn't have that much to write!
Similar thoughts on question 1....letter question terrible...had nothing much more to say ran short on time and who knows how well I've done.
Also only just realised that I did not tick the boxes on the front of the exam paper to say which questions I have attempted is this a problem?!
Fluffyduck, yea I did question 3, first part can't fully remember what I wrote, I used the TARA framework too for risk management bit, almost certain that was the correct approach.
The final bit on integrated reporting, I did a lot of standard bookwork on writing about the guiding principles of an integrated report, the benefits it can provide to different stakeholders. The question was actually very similar to a past paper. The sample answer of which essentially briefly described each type of the 6 capitals and then applied it to the case. The question mentioned an oil disaster previously, fairly sure it was hinted at the BP disaster, which was what I based my university dissertation on(winding back the years), so I didn't find too much trouble on apply the scenario to the answer.
I hope the marker will be ticking many of my points on question 3 to make up for some of my not so great answers for Q1 and Q4.
Good to hear you used the same framework!
I thought I got the 6 capitals correct until I came out and saw I got two wrong...don't know what happened to my brain in the exam!!
I'm hopeful that maybe I have scraped through but very uncertain. Ambiguous questions throughout and didn't like topic ranges too much either.
Good luck to you and everyone else
@dd92 said: 4c) something about explaining the steps Andy should take in order to resolve the ethical dilemma. I don't see how tucker or AAA would fit. I mentioned consulting with ACCA, review legal requirements, look at internal policies. 4a and 4b were the annoying ones. Both very similar and 10 marks which implies 5 ethical threats. I got 3 threats and a dubious 4th.I think it says the steps Andy should've taken. I also doubt either AAA or Tucker Models
Hi uzair52,
For the first part of question 3 a, what did you write regarding sources of environmental risk that they would discover during the risk assessment?
Regarding risk management framework, I used COSO framework but not sure if this is the correct one.
It was a bit funny for me. After completing Question 1 & 3, i was still to decide one amongst 2&4. I read Q2 first and then read Q4, made up my mind to go for Q2. But when I started answering, Q4 scenario was still on my mind because that was last read question. I started answering Q2 questions for Q4 scenarios for about 3 mins. I was like OMG!!
Hi sahir,
Regarding q 3 a what did you write regarding sources of environmental risk that they will discover during assessment? I was a bit confused regarding that part.
@fatimasaid123 said: Hi sahir, Regarding q 3 a what did you write regarding sources of environmental risk that they will discover during assessment? I was a bit confused regarding that part.I'm interested in this too. What points did you make Fatima?
I mainly describe how their activities pose environmental risk.
For example, I wrote extracting oil , a non-renewable resource, would contribute to it being depleted as it can not be replaced.
I also wrote that through processing of oil, environmental footprint and risk that arises include carbon being emitted.
Another point I wrote is that environmental risk also includes impact of the environment on the firm such as adverse weather conditions,earthquakes and so on damaging oil rigs leading to a possible explosion.
Regarding ways to mitigate impact, I mentioned developing more robust oil rigs so that it will be able to withstand strong waves and not explode as was the case with BP.
I also wrote that they should install carbon capture system and spill containment.
But I am not sure whether these were points that examiners were looking for.
Sounds good. The only two points I got were oil will run out and risk of spillage. Ran out of time for this whole question and moved onto the other parts
@nulais said: I think it says the steps Andy should've taken. I also doubt either AAA or Tucker ModelsI hope you are right as I knew both models inside out but it didn't even occur to me to apply them here. Question should have said using tucker model or AAA describe thought process. In reality someone doesn't need a model to make a decision.
@kevikraze said: I hope you are right as I knew both models inside out but it didn't even occur to me to apply them here. Question should have said using tucker model or AAA describe thought process. In reality someone doesn't need a model to make a decision.That's the key! (Question should've said using either model) In order to manage time, one doesn't do everything in an exam,especially if the examiner isn't specific.
@nulais said: That's the key! (Question should've said using either model) In order to manage time, one doesn't do everything in an exam,especially if the examiner isn't specific.Yeah, I pretty sure that question was about steps for ethical conflict resolution so the steps followed are about referring to facts, establishing ethical issues, refer to fundamental principles, establishing internal procedures, identity alternative actions, speak with appropriate person in firm, advice from Acca and then finally withdrawing from engagement.
I just feel the question ask the same things and i feel like i' writing the same answer...so requirements that i didn't know what the examiner want!
@fluffyduck279 said: I'm interested in this too. What points did you make Fatima?In respect to q3 part a i wrote about risks from damage to nature, animals, water, air etc which may arise during oil exploration.
@fluffyduck279 said: Question 3 risk management 8 marks I described the Tara framework. Anyone else? Wondering if I'm barking up the wrong tree! Also to people who did question 3 what were the environmental concerns in the first part and what did you write about integrated reporting? Have no idea how to get the 8 marks for that part. Question 2 people are saying they wrote what comprises good info but the question said explain how good info is useful.....so I didn't so much write about the qualities....maybe I've mistook the question....didn't have that much to write! Similar thoughts on question 1....letter question terrible...had nothing much more to say ran short on time and who knows how well I've done. Also only just realised that I did not tick the boxes on the front of the exam paper to say which questions I have attempted is this a problem?!Same for me, but i've mentioned also necessity to perform risk prioritization (same to Mendelow matrix) through matrix with two axes probability/impact.
I agreed with you. I attempted question 4 and also find it very confusing. It left me fixing the paper for minutes without knowing where to start. Sec (a) and (b) were asking for the same thing. The paper was a nightmare :(
Keep faith dear, forget about P1 and concentrate on F9. I also attempted P1 and absolutely agree with the points you mentioned. A complete disaster.
But it's over now. I attempted F6 today. Good luck for tomorrow.
OMG it was a nightmare. That letter in ques.1 was ridiculous. Not really sure how you would get 18 marks... definitely got my 4 marks for doing the right layout!
Ques 2 was also quite tricky - I started it and then realised I was blanking and didn't know enough but i wouldn't have had enough time to switch to ques. 3 so I had to try my best... I just blanked on internal controls and could kick myself!!
Ques 4 it did feel like I was saying the same things over and over. I used Tucker to help him decide on his ethical dilemma... and then I put down some other points too like reporting it to the compliance officer, contacting ACCA for assistance etc. The examiner might find a few marks.
I will be re-writing in March i am sure of it. Just too much expected of us in the limited time. It's ridiculous. Even if we could type it would be better than hand writing the answers.
I think it was on writing a letter to explain the shareholders the importance of Corporate Governance in the case of the pharmaceutical company, or something like that
Indeed it was a nightmare. I had no idea what to include in the letter to shareholders. I only drafted the format to get some professional marks.
I also felt like doing ques 4 but while writing, I could not find out what to write in part (B) as I already mentioned it all in part (a). That paper left me without words, literally.
I then tried ques 3. Now it was asking to describe a framework to decide upon a dilemma. Sec (c) I think was asking to describe the steps in the framework. I went in with COSO framework but found that not all steps were relevant to the question. I this went for Tucker, but could not figure out neither how to apply it to the question. And above all, such a demanding section in the question which required to develop a framework was worth only 5 marks. I was disgusted.
I am also pretty sure I will need to retry in March. I tried to complete the paper but in vain, left lots of blank spaces to fill before the bell rang, but had to submit like it was. Lack of time and confusing questions.
Let's wait for the results now.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

