AA*** ACCA F8 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
ok i remember now; there was one confusing question related to cut-off
I had chosen d for it which was about recording revenue in correct accounting year.
I also remembered, one tricky question asking for two sentences which are INCONSISTENT with the data provided. But i totally forgot what was the answers.
i chose d too that sales invoice should be matched with GDN and the line below that but can't the wording - again was something to do with invoices and price list maybe?
@kanchandhankar said: Options were something like sample of invoice to match with GDNs Sample of GDNs to match with invoice ???This was for completeness of revenue wasnt it? could be confused...
Yes it was about occurrence
one of course is get sample of invoice to match with GDNs
other option i was not sure.
@kicek7 said: I also remembered, one tricky question asking for two sentences which are INCONSISTENT with the data provided. But i totally forgot what was the answers.For cut off - i went d? It said something like wages and salaries have been correctly allocated in the right year.
@kicek7 said: I also remembered, one tricky question asking for two sentences which are INCONSISTENT with the data provided. But i totally forgot what was the answers.i remember one answer i chose for this was that sales revenue had gone up whilst costs stayed the same as 2015 - i thought this was wrong as gross profit margin had dropped
@ash182 said: For cut off - i went d? It said something like wages and salaries have been correctly allocated in the right year.I did the same. If you passed, I pass :)
@tayyabom said: I did the same. If you passed, I pass :)i did D also
@kanchandhankar said: Yes I guess I chose Slow down Inventory was better than last year Sales price increased with same maintaining of cost Both were inconsistent with the data given in q As gross profit margin was falling Inventory days were increasedOh is this about Ratio Analysis Section (B) question? One simple guess can be that Gross Profit is increasing but net profit is not because COS is booked under Operating Expenses as they were clearly up.
@kanchandhankar said: I remember choosing d as well it was about cutoff relating wages All wages were allocated in year xxxx something ...l..?thats the one :)
@kanchandhankar said: Yes I guess I chose Slow down Inventory was better than last year Sales price increased with same maintaining of cost Both were inconsistent with the data given in q As gross profit margin was falling Inventory days were increasedyep had these two aswell as they were both inconsistent :)
@tayyabom said: Oh is this about Ratio Analysis Section (B) question? One simple guess can be that Gross Profit is increasing but net profit is not because COS is booked under Operating Expenses as they were clearly up.This was just state and calculate 6 ratios - not too hard i thought!
this was an okay exam <as the mcqs wew little twisty.
@kanchandhankar said: Yes six ratios Still got one ratio wrong payable days I did payable /revenue :@not to worry :)
modified audit report with a qualified opinion- Except for paragraph
@kanchandhankar said: Thanks :) What was ur answer for q18 last q About implication on audit reportI did find this hard in approaching the answer. I cant remember the specifics, something around not disclosing the payment after year end? I discussed various scenarios that would lead to various opinions, qualified, adverse, disclaimer. you?
@ash182 said: I did find this hard in approaching the answer. I cant remember the specifics, something around not disclosing the payment after year end? I discussed various scenarios that would lead to various opinions, qualified, adverse, disclaimer. you?Question was, directors don't want to disclose anything related to payables although amount was material 490K. They were of the view that both Overdraft and Payables fall under current liabilities there is no issue. It was a material misstatement but was not pervasive as it was only one figure related to payables. I mentioned that it is a presentation issue as IFRS 1 states figures should be presented as per defined rules. I then mentioned that it is not about broader terms but about treatment of various figures e.g. payables make part of working capital but overdraft doesn't. I also one mentioned that there might be additional reason that some of the suppliers threatened the company of legal action and now to hide it they did this window dressing by taking overdraft from bank and by extending payables period etc etc :)
@rishi121211 said: I think there is a misunderstanding with the payroll question. It had specifically said "ignoring redundancy cost"redundancy cost means End of Service payments such as gratuity, indemnification due to contractual obligations etc.
I got ans D 1860000 is it ok?
@kanchandhankar said: I mentioned as well that info about profit or revenue is not given to calculate materialityCurrent liabilities figure was given.
I got answer D too
@tayyabom said: Question was, directors don't want to disclose anything related to payables although amount was material 490K. They were of the view that both Overdraft and Payables fall under current liabilities there is no issue. It was a material misstatement but was not pervasive as it was only one figure related to payables. I mentioned that it is a presentation issue as IFRS 1 states figures should be presented as per defined rules. I then mentioned that it is not about broader terms but about treatment of various figures e.g. payables make part of working capital but overdraft doesn't. I also one mentioned that there might be additional reason that some of the suppliers threatened the company of legal action and now to hide it they did this window dressing by taking overdraft from bank and by extending payables period etc etc :)yes material and not prevasive was the choice. i felt they were looking for an explanation around how other opinions would form, hence my discussion around other potential scenarios related. should have got a few marks regardless :)
@ash182 said: yes material and not prevasive was the choice. i felt they were looking for an explanation around how other opinions would form, hence my discussion around other potential scenarios related. should have got a few marks regardless :)of course you'll get marks; ACCA markers are very generous.
I think the most difficult bit in this exam was identifying THREE STRENGTHS in that dirty till control system :)
@tayyabom said: I think the most difficult bit in this exam was identifying THREE STRENGTHS in that dirty till control system :)haha tell me about it! :)
@rishi121211 said: Not sure how tough the marking is for ACCA but there is no way i could have wrote as much as the examiner has answered in the answers to past papers.In past paper answers, examiners write all possible answers e.g. if 4 risks are to be identified they'll write 8 just for teaching purpose. In my opinion, idea about ACCA F8 exam is that, if they have asked you 4 audit risks try to write 6 audit risks (permitted you have time), markers will mark your best 4 answers out of 6 since there is no negative marking. ACCA will get really tough if they started negative marking. it'll get very difficult to pass. E.g. 18 (d) I wrote 2,3 plausible answers as I was also not sure how to go about this; from my past experience with ACCA I know that they'll cross the invalid answers but give marks to valid reasoning.
@ash182 said: haha tell me about it! :)what was your answer :)
@tayyabom said: I think the most difficult bit in this exam was identifying THREE STRENGTHS in that dirty till control system :)What strengths were there? What did you identify?
Monthly reconciliation and finance director authorizing it was a strength.
Cash was sent out to bankvery day morning that was a strength
Sales were matched with receipts at the end of day, that's strength
all receipts and sales transactions are transferred to HO and a clerk matches them that's a strength.
Test of controls?
Cash being sent to bank (observe)
Monthly reconciliation being signed off by FD (get a copy of recon and inspect)
Daily recon performed by clerk (again get a copy and inspect)
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

