PM*** ACCA F5 September 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@louiseabigail said: I had a shortage of approx 11k of beta. Majority went on the 5k of shakes. Leaving only 4500 for the cookies and cakes. Getting a protit of around 22 or 23k and the deciding if they should honor the contract or not i got a profit of 41k Loved question 31 think i wrote about 4 pages and did about 8-10 calculations. Hopefully i get the full 20 marks for this. Hopefully done enough to passCan you elaborate a bit about the calculations in 31. And in 32, 5000 shakes for encompass health were apart from current demand and so 5000g had to be deducted from 12000g of beta first leaving us with 7000g of Betta for current demand of cookies cakes and shakes. The question specified that shakes for encompass health were not included in the table and what would our revised Opp be if we honored our contract to encompass. So it was 5000 shakes for encompass, followed by all cookies, some cakes and 0 shakes of current demand.
Hi,
The question was on Limiting Factor Analysis not throughput although it's similar. You have to further divide each contribution by the amount of Betta they needed per unit and then you rank them.
Cookies are first, Cakes second and Shakes last because of the contribution per unit of the limiting factor (Betta). Based on limited availability of Betta and the ranking, all of the Cookies and Cakes could be made. It was just Shakes that could not be completed to meet the demand.
That's what I did!
Hi can anyone one remember the ans for that question 26-30 pls
Lily ...I guess 15.9 answer is correct
because question says ..they sold net value of 40000 asset for 50000 and replaced another asset costing 250000
so I guess - 1000000- 40000 + 300000
IT SAYS REPLACED THE ASSET SO
50000 is exchanged for the asset ...they had to pay 250000 and replaced asset value of sold asset for the new one is 50000 .altogether 3000000
blockquote>@liliyasolo777 said:
ROI:
Profit = 190 000 + 10 000 (net profit from selling asset)
Net assets have been increased to 1 260 000$: 1mln + 250 000 + 10 000 (as increase in net asset from disposal old machine)
ROI = 15.87%
But now I can see that I wrong - It was necessary to deduct 40 000....I forgot((((( I believe that the answer would be ROI = 200/1220 = 16.39%
For those who take the CBE exam, will the result be released instantly?
can someone tell me the answer for ROI
Even I think it was basee on limiting factor because a question can be based on only one section and chapter and so 32 question was full on limiting factor throughput accpunting is a different chapter that too in section A so I dont think it was throughput. But after i found limiting factor i rankes according to what was demandee in the contract so i ranked shakes first because they had to fullfill the contract first and becausw of that none of cookiesand cakes could be produced.
My maximin and minimax were 450 and 960. Is that correct? And in question 32 i ranked shakes first because of contract but i found contr. Per LF and then ranked shakes first and then in the b part i wrote its affectinh profit of other produvts so contract shouldnt be continued. in the next part the optimum point was B right?
And in ques 31 what calculations were required? I just found % differences in everything from 2015-2016 while discussing. Is that correcr?
Frustrating I forgot to divide contribution by the limiting amount of beta, I ranked in cs ratio order.
For the second part of it though was the correct answer not to honour the contract as limited resource produces more contribution on other products so profit would be higher?
I got optimum point as C..
Minimin 450. Minimax regret I got confused with how to calc so think I just took a guess at 650!
Question 31 i mainly did percent differences too.
Also net and gross profit margins..
And Amount percent of late deliverys had increased
I have got difficulty to tackle Q.32.
Paper was OK compared to June which was tooo hard,
New style for Sec. B (30 marks) has some + and -
Before it was 10 marks each 2 question, so if we do some calculation then will get some marks even if the final answer is not correct, however, Sep-16 we do all calculation but if answer is not correct you lost full marks.
Mcq's were 60-40 ok-tricky, i did 60% and 40% were guess.
Long questions were also OK.
I sat the June one too nelvin,
awful!
Oh really? The normal optimum production plan would be with cookies first. I didn't realise with limiting factor that contracts takes priority?
I also got the same answers for the Maximin and Minimax. I guessed for the value of perfect information was C because I forgot how to work it out haha.
I also got optimal solution as B because the ISO contribution line if you imagine it pushing forward on the graph will not touch the other points. The object was to Maximise it.
Sarah, looks like you and I put similar answers. I also did the exact same for question 31 so I'm so relieved! I did the gross profit and net profit margins, explained why they probably increased or decreased and by how much. Then I talked about how revenue/sales increased for the electronic goods because of the increased market demand. Then just went on about how complaints also increased and by how much, and also delivery times fell. I balanced it out with a notable increase in customers though and just suggested they should be more efficient with their processes so as to retain the increase in market share (customers) they already have. The increase in customers meant their strategy was working so just they need to work at being efficient.
Hope that gets me at least half the marks! lol.
Section B. Anyone remeber what was the 3rd part
1) Risk Uncertainty - minimax/reget
2) Flexible Budgeting
3) ????
How was your paper Sarah ?
The 3 part was composed by a problem with maximin, a problem with linear programming and limiting factors (ISO contribution line, contract with Encompass for shakes) an a problem with flexible budget. This is what I remember.
Hey chi fingers crossed we've done enough on 31 for almost full marks! I also mentioned that they were performing well with revenues increasing but in order for it to continue they must work on lowering customer complaints most likely about slow deliveries and that changing from the international Courier to their own was a bad move. Just a lot of waffling really these performance measure ones aren't they! They're Easy marks I think so was quite happy to see that question poo up! :)
Nelvin I thought the paper was okay too much better feeling than June paper. First half of 32 with limiting factor think I messed but but found second part with optimum solution and iso lines, and slack, easy.
Mcqs probably definitely knew about 12. Ten probably half knew/half guessed. 8 really unsure and time pressured so guesses!
Never have time to check through my answers in an f5 paper!
@sarahb1985 said: Hey chi fingers crossed we've done enough on 31 for almost full marks! I also mentioned that they were performing well with revenues increasing but in order for it to continue they must work on lowering customer complaints most likely about slow deliveries and that changing from the international Courier to their own was a bad move. Just a lot of waffling really these performance measure ones aren't they! They're Easy marks I think so was quite happy to see that question poo up! :) Nelvin I thought the paper was okay too much better feeling than June paper. First half of 32 with limiting factor think I messed but but found second part with optimum solution and iso lines, and slack, easy. Mcqs probably definitely knew about 12. Ten probably half knew/half guessed. 8 really unsure and time pressured so guesses! Never have time to check through my answers in an f5 paper!I found my optimum to be B tell me yours
If you perform calculation, the optimal point should be C as at C the objective function is maximised.
@fatez said: I found my optimum to be B tell me yoursOmar I chose C as it was the last point my ruler hit when I ran it parallel away from the ISO contribution line!
Guys, what paper to go for after F5 ?
Any suggetions ?
@carsbru said: I did the session CBE version. ACCA needs to get a grip when they roll out this exam version. First, I could only start my exam with 35min delay because of technical problems of various kinds. Then, during the exam I got interrupted twice by staff. Then they wanted to add time to my exam (3. interruption), fair game, but did not manage. So they stopped my exam to call tech service etc. This happened roughly 8min before exam should have ended for me. I will file a complaint, hence I was interrupted so many times and lost my train of thoughts and unequal exam environment. Very poorly done on ACCA side!With the CBE examination, do you have instant result?
Hello,
Unfortunately the results are not instant. We get them at the same time as the paper ones as section C is hand marked.
Exactly! It was nothing to do with throughput accounting I think ...
Did we have to show calculations in the answer booklet? I was calculating on the question booklet and then just draw dots...:((( I know it is weird.
No, you didn't have to. You could write your calculation strait on the question paper to make it easier for you. I did ask that question!
@carsbru said: I ranked Shakes last, too. This product had the least contribution regarding the limiting factor. Answering the follow-up question was funny, hence only 4400 of the 5000 could be delivered, failing the contract already :) Another comment of mine was that one needs to look into the penalty for failing the contract and perhaps reevaluation the profit/contribution considering this circumstance. Sadly, time was short on the entire questionDid you add 5000 to the expected demand of Shakes for next month? 'Cause the extra 5000 were being sold at a discounted price. So i calculated the contribution for the 5000 shakes and the expected demand separately to show the difference and that they couldnt produce enough for the agreement. In the next one i said if the agreement is breached, the remaining grams of Betta could be used to produce any of the three products if theres a sudden increase in the demand
I loved Q31, much better than F7s ratios -_-
What was the optimal plan q32 Part c
does anyone knew about the ans for question 26/30???
@carsbru said: I ranked Shakes last, too. This product had the least contribution regarding the limiting factor. Answering the follow-up question was funny, hence only 4400 of the 5000 could be delivered, failing the contract already :) Another comment of mine was that one needs to look into the penalty for failing the contract and perhaps reevaluation the profit/contribution considering this circumstance. Sadly, time was short on the entire questionYup, time was short but I hope we've done enough. I didn't focus on the contract in part (a) because they couldn't even make enough shakes to meet the current Market demand in the first place. If they had done that, then yes they could talk about how to fulfil the contract. I got a shortfall of 2060 shakes because the market demand was 2500 from what I remember. So, they could only make 440 shakes from Betta. In part (b) Was asking whether they should breach their agreement. I said they should breach their agreement because as long as Betta is limited to 12000 grams, they would not be able to make any more shakes regardless of the demand and regardless of the contract. The contract also demanded they make vast amounts of shakes which again I said would not be possible because of Betta. My Optimal plan was to make all Cookies and Cakes. 440 units of Shakes could only be made based on the limiting factor.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

