PM*** ACCA F5 March 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
I got 260 for necklaces. Anyone else get that?
Horrific, if I have managed to pass it's a complete fluke! Written questions in Section C were the worst part for me, never have been a fan of written sections in exams.
I interpreted that to mean had he had a chance to adjust the standard cost card there would have been no revised (as the changes would be the standard if you get me) I think you guys are right though
Just seems a lot of marks for 2 variances but acca love a trick ;)
ACCA is just cruel. Where do they get these mean examiners......the question that had these figures 10%, 9025 ,5%, 9783 what was it about by the way and what was the answer
@passionate said: ACCA is just cruel. Where do they get these mean examiners......the question that had these figures 10%, 9025 ,5%, 9783 what was it about by the way and what was the answeri was so confused about this too... but guessed the answer to be B $3000 something as my answer was closer to that. anyone else who managed to get an answer here?
hope so))
@micksymooresy16 said: I interpreted that to mean had he had a chance to adjust the standard cost card there would have been no revised (as the changes would be the standard if you get me) I think you guys are right though Just seems a lot of marks for 2 variances but acca love a trick ;)if he would have had the chance to change the cost then that would have been the standard cost to compare with actual, that was the whole tricky part. thats why i saw no need of operational/planning variance. i calculated three variance and 'assessed' the production managers performance. i guess thats why the marks were more as you had to explain the variances too. dont know though? i might be wrong.
@2929107 said: if he would have had the chance to change the cost then that would have been the standard cost to compare with actual, that was the whole tricky part. thats why i saw no need of operational/planning variance. i calculated three variance and 'assessed' the production managers performance. i guess thats why the marks were more as you had to explain the variances too. dont know though? i might be wrong.That's why I chose to do the plan & op, because if he had signed off the changes the 'revised' would be the standard so there would be no revised to compare to. Because he didn't sign off changes, the 3 scenarios (standard, act & revised) existed. So that's why I chose comparison of 3. tough, tough, tough question - I think your right but I could be right too! :)
Why would they give 7 or 8 marks for 2 basic variances from f2?
@sunnydeol89 said: Why would they give 7 or 8 marks for 2 basic variances from f2?my thoughts exactly - then 8 marks to assess 4 standard variances? doesnt add up like. only way I could think is that they attributed marks for the logic
I had seen a similar question before in one of the practices I had done and the answer scheme needed both the operational and planning variances to be calculated and under discussion to evaluate production manager's performance, it was important to point out that the planning variances existed because the standard cost card was not updated and as such the production manager should not be held responsible for the adverse planning variances
thats what I thought. Then i was questioning myself in terms of was the manager resposible for the design changes as the question stated he/she was resposible for all production and purchasing issues.
horrible question
It was horrible. I thought of that too but I decided on this approach because I reread the question a few times and it seemed like the school had decided on the design change and the material and the production manager did a good job of securing the material without any adverse variance but the favourable variance can't be attributed to him either cause it was a planning variance based on the school's choice of material...at least that's what I wrote
Now I also found similar question about Truffle Co.. there is required to calculate op&planning variances, you're right..
I've failed)))
I said he was responsible for the material purchasing as the q said he was responsible for all purchasing issues. so many ways to go wrong like.
@anano said: Now I also found similar question about Truffle Co.. there is required to calculate op&planning variances, you're right.. I've failed)))no shame in it prob failed myself, was a horrible exam, how hard are the p's like?!
I know, was just trying not to get too worked up over the p's
For q31 operational labour efficiency variance, I working out the total hours available (160hours p/mth x24 (no. of employees) x60 (minutes in an hour) = 230,400 minutes. So on that basis, 24000 units actually took 9.6 minutes per unit, giving a favourable variance of $1,920. Any one else do the same here?
Ans for 2 ques: i think its profit
Anyone took the revised standard quantity as 2.2 in sec c 31st question
@jobinthomas said: Anyone took the revised standard quantity as 2.2 in sec c 31st questionyes, I took it
yes, same here
@anano said: I agree, I thought, accountant-related part was key part in question. I think revised budget means adjusted budget. Accountant was responsible to set new price and new quantity of material. Budget would be prepared with old standarts, because new standarts weren't updated. But everyone here has solved Q31 with planning and operational variances, so maybe I'm wrong.I saw this info as basically telling you, that you must use the original standard cost to calculate variances, and not the revised cost. I think this was put in, because with the recent examiner change since Sept16, they prefer you to use the original standard and not the revised standard when calculating variances. I could be wrong, but that's how I understood the final paragraph
@rohvj said: I had seen a similar question before in one of the practices I had done and the answer scheme needed both the operational and planning variances to be calculated and under discussion to evaluate production manager's performance, it was important to point out that the planning variances existed because the standard cost card was not updated and as such the production manager should not be held responsible for the adverse planning variancesthis makes alot of sense now. ur probably right. i hope i do get some markes for basic variance and assesment i did though.. every mark counts right? and i did 3 variances not jus two lol. hoping for the best.
how did you understand in the q32 actual incidence of fraud being below target? is that good or bad? they planned wrong, software is not good or what?
@jasv said: how did you understand in the q32 actual incidence of fraud being below target? is that good or bad? they planned wrong, software is not good or what?fraud being low than target is deffo a good thing for the company
@jammy109 said: I saw this info as basically telling you, that you must use the original standard cost to calculate variances, and not the revised cost. I think this was put in, because with the recent examiner change since Sept16, they prefer you to use the original standard and not the revised standard when calculating variances. I could be wrong, but that's how I understood the final paragraphThats exactly how i understood it
One more argument from my side))))
"the planning variances existed because the standard cost card was not updated and as such the production manager should not be held responsible for the adverse planning variances" - as i remember from theory, planning variances are depended on external changes.. Manager should not be held responsible for adverse variances even if standarts were updated... because change of uniform design was decided by school, if i remember correctly... But im not sure))))
Anyway))) i think i should break down into operational and planning variances)))
I agree with you 100%. I relied so much on the lecture notes and the videos to better help me understand the topics. Granted, they were understandable but I realized the actual practice questions from the revised kit were on a more difficult level.
This is my second attempt with F5 and I can only hope that I did better! Good luck to you :-)
@petraicon said: Q31 for material planning usage variances: I did actual production at standard quantity by standard price 24000*2m(2.2m/110*100) * €3 (2.85/95*100) = 144000 and actual production at new design quantity by standard price 24000*2.2m*€3 =158400 144000-158400= €14400 Adverse planning usage Is this really wrong?will I get any marks?Anyone remember the actual quantity used in production? I think it was 54,000 or close?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

