Skip to content

Ask the Tutor ACCA LW

Ratio Decidendi - Overruling

BBiseko4y ago
Why does a higher court consider decisions made by a lower court (in a different case), even though the higher court is not bound by those decisions.
MikeLittleMikeLittleTutor4y ago#1
You have to imagine the realities of the situation of a Court case. For each of the 2 sides, the plaintiff and the defendant, there will be a barrister (or even a team of barristers) representing the 2 litigants The task facing these 2 sets of legal representatives is to persuade the Court that their own client has the valid claim and, equally, that the opposition does not have a valid defence. In order to do that, the barristers will bring to the attention of the Court similar cases which the barristers claim will provide precedent. If these cited cases are from a lower Court, then the decisions will be persuasive only but if they're from a Court of same standing then the precedent will be binding So that's why the judges in the higher Court are looking at decisions from lower Court cases OK?
BBiseko3y ago#2
Understood. Thank you Mike
MikeLittleMikeLittleTutor3y ago#3
You're welcome
BBiseko3y ago#4
Just did my paper today. Got 73%. Thank you Mike and the team for this awesome platform, you guys are life savers.
MikeLittleMikeLittleTutor3y ago#5
That's a good score Biseko, well done. And thanks for letting me know Good luck with your future studies
Sign in to reply to this topic.