Skip to content

Ask the Tutor ACCA FM

Accounting Rate of Return

CChinny7y ago
If that is the case, the question gt disposal value, how should we treat it in accounting rate of return? which part will be affected? Thanks sir
John MoffatJohn MoffatTutor7y ago#1
If what is the case? The disposal value is relevant in calculating the annual depreciation charge (which affects the profit). In addition, the average investment is (initial cost + disposal value) / 2 This is revision from Paper MA (was F2) and is all explained in my free lectures :-)
CChinny7y ago#2
Is it same like scrap value, but disposal value is + to initial investment while scrap value is minus from initial investment? Average annual profit= Total est CF- total depreciation for the investment (initial investment-scrap value+disposal value)=total profit From total profit/investment life span= average annual profit Average investment =(Initial Investment-Scrap Value +Disposal Value)/2 Is that correct?
John MoffatJohn MoffatTutor7y ago#3
No it isn't correct. Scrap value and disposal value are the same thing! Total depreciation = (initial investment - scrap value) / life of investment Average investment = (initial investment + scrap value) / 2 Have you watched the free lectures?
CChinny7y ago#4
I think scrap value is the net realisable value, while disposal value is the cost to remove the asset. It should not be the same thing right????? Thanksss
John MoffatJohn MoffatTutor7y ago#5
The two are the same thing. Disposal value means sale value (or scrap value). You are thinking of disposal cost - that would be the cost of removing the asset.
CChinny7y ago#6
Orhh sorry I misunderstand it. I have watched the free lecture video As per u mention, average investment= initial investment + scrap value/2 However, I am wondering the example 8 sir u discussed in lecture video why from 80,000 (asset original amount) drop to 10,000 (scrap value). The difference not supposed like 80,000 drop to 10,000 which means difference is 70,000 and then divided by 2? why it will use 80,000+10,000/2 to find the average investment?? I a bit confused with this part. If there is disposal cost, where will it be?
John MoffatJohn MoffatTutor7y ago#7
If the value is 80,000 at the start and falls over the period to 10,000 at the end, then the average value is the average of the two in the normal way i.e. (80,000 + 10,000) / 2 = 45,000. A disposal cost is unlikely in the exam but is treated just as negative scrap proceeds.
Sign into reply to this topic.