Modigliani–Miller capital structure propositions
Without taxes and under idealised perfect-market assumptions, changing debt/equity mix does not change total firm value or WACC: cheaper debt is offset by a higher equity required return as gearing rises. With corporate tax and a usable interest tax shield, debt can add value in the simplified model. The familiar perpetual-debt relation VL = VU + T×D relies on its assumptions. Real financing decisions also involve distress costs, agency effects, taxes, information differences and flexibility. The propositions are a framework for analysing these effects, not a recommendation for unlimited debt.
Worked example
In a simplified perpetual-debt tax model, an ungeared firm is worth $10 million and adds $2 million debt at a 25% corporate tax rate. The modelled tax-shield value is $0.5 million, giving $10.5 million geared value before omitted real-world costs.
Common mistake
Applying the tax model without usable tax relief or treating its omission of distress costs as proof that maximum debt is optimal.
Where it appears in your exams
| Qualification | Exam | Relationship | Period |
|---|---|---|---|
| ACCA | AFM | Direct | September 2026–June 2027 |
| ACCA | FM | Direct | September 2026–June 2027 |
