Skip to contentSkip to search

CIMA Forums

Dispoals- Groups - BPP f2 question pack.

Ccam10y ago
Hi Chris. Another disposal question! On I July 20X1, SP acquired 75% of the 1 million ordinary shares in MN for $6 million. Goodwill of $1 million arose on the acquisition. SP measures non-controlling interests at acquisition at their proportionate share of the subsidiary's net assets. On 31 December 20X8, SP disposed of part of its shareholding in MN for $4 million, retaining a 40% interest. The net assets of MN on 1 July 20X8 were $8.5 million and MN made a profit of $800,000 in the year ended 30 June 20X9 (no dividends were paid or declared by MN in that year). As at 31 December 20X8 the fair value of a share in MN was $10.10. Non-controlling interests in MN at 31 December 20X8 amounted to $2.225 million. What is the profit or loss on disposal that will be included in the consolidated statement of profit or loss of SP for the year ended 30 June 20X9? A $3,675,000 loss B $365,000 profit C $615,000 profit D $1,365,000 profit Solution Ok- so we initially had 75%- subsidiary and we disposed of half.. retaining an interest of 40% so it is a subsidiary to associate change in control. the gain/ loss on dispoal: Sale proceeds: 4000 FV value of remaining consideration= 40%*1.10*1M= 4040 Total investment= 8040 Less: Net assets @ disposal= SC(8.5M)+ Profit(800k)= ????? Goddwill@ disposal= 1m NCI @ Disposal 2.225m in the solution the answers take 6/12th of profit= 6/12*800...whereas I have just taken the full 800...... the questions says "The net assets of MN on 1 July 20X8 were $8.5 million and MN made a profit of $800,000 in the year ended 30 June 20X9 (no dividends were paid or declared by MN in that year" which makes me think that the profit is in the month 1st July x8. and Month end is 30th June 20x9.. So from 1st July x8 to 30th June x9 is 12 months.. so why do we take 6/12th of the profit figure? Thanks Abi
P2-D2P2-D2Tutor10y ago#1
Wow! How tough was this question!?!?!? You've done it all correct apart from identifying that the disposal took place on 31 December 20X8 which is 6 months after the date the net assets figure was given on 1 July 20X8. To get the net assets at 31 December we need to add on 6 months of the profit for the year and so pro rate the profit to 30 June 20X9 by 6/12ths. If ever you are given dates in a questions always give them close attention as they usually play a big part in MCQs. Thanks
Ccam10y ago#2
oo wow. Such a small thing could have cost me that one mark! Lesson learnt- Triple watch out for dates in questions. Thanks Chris. I can see where I went wrong.. hopefully next time if I see a similar question I will spot it!
P2-D2P2-D2Tutor10y ago#3
Yes, it is that harsh sadly but at least you now know to give huge amounts of attention to the dates given in any question.
Sign into reply to this topic.