Skip to content

Ask the Tutor ACCA AA

Dec 2016 CBE Auditor's report How is TP not pervasive

Former userFormer user7y ago

[Content removed at user request]

KimKimTutor7y ago#1
Think of pervasive as the financial statements as a whole - yes understatement of liabilities means overstatement of profits and so both SoFP and SoPL are both affected (that is the nature of double entry) - but if in qualifying the audit opinion the auditor says "trade payables should be x and profit should be y" the reader can understand the impact that this misstatement has. It doesn't have non-current assets or current assets or revenue or the analysis/disclosure of any of these things in the notes - so it is not pervasive.
KimKimTutor7y ago#2
I am SO pleased!!! In the real world adverse opinions and disclaimers of opinions are extremely rare (who would invest in a company with such a "bad" opinion? surely the shareholders would remove the directors?) I would say they exist more in theory (in exam questions) than they do in the real world. You may be interested to know that in practice (you wouldn't get this in AA exam) you could have multiple matters on which to give an "except for" opinion and even combining them ("except for this and except for that and except for the other") the opinion is still only qualified - not adverse :-)
Sign into reply to this topic.