Skip to content

Ask the Tutor ACCA FR

cost painting

ASalawi sayed5y ago
Hello Mr chris, why in this case below we have to consider $20m repainting cost as expense even though it is a major expense ,isn't it a big amount that we have to capitalise. Thanks, ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Elite Leisure Co OTQ case 18 mins The following scenario relates to questions 57–61. Elite Leisure Co is a private limited liability company that operates a single cruise ship. The ship was acquired on 1 October 20W6 (ten years before 20X6). Details of the cost of the ship's components and the basis on which they are depreciated is as follows: Component Original cost Depreciation basis $m Ship's fabric (hull, decks etc) 300 25 years straight-line Cabins and entertainment area fittings 150 12 years straight-line Propulsion system 100 Useful life of 40,000 hours At 30 September 20X4 no further capital expenditure had been incurred on the ship. The propulsion system has been used for 30,000 hours at 30 September 20X4. Due to the unreliability of the engines, a decision was taken in early October 20X4 to replace the whole of the propulsion system at a cost of $140 million. The useful life of the new propulsion system was 50,000 hours and in the year ended 30 September 20X5 the ship had used the system for 5,000 hours. At the same time as the propulsion system replacement, Elite Leisure Co took the opportunity to do a limited upgrade to the facilities at a cost of $60 million and repaint the ship's fabric at a cost of $20 million. After the upgrade of the facilities it was estimated that their remaining useful life was five years (from the date of the upgrade). For the purpose of calculating depreciation, all the work on the ship can be assumed to have been completed on 1 October 20X4. All residual values can be taken as nil.
AAamna5y ago#1
Hi see you capitalise a cost only if it gives to economic benefit either by increasing the efficiency of the product ,reducing costs or increase revenue.in case of repainting it’s just like maintaining the asset ,it does not increase the economic benefit received from the asset that’s why it’s treated as a revenue expenditure
ASalawi sayed5y ago#2
Thanks.
P2-D2P2-D2Tutor5y ago#3
Yes, it does not matter how much is spent, even if it is large sum then it must enhance the economic benefit of the asset being painted. Painting an asset does not enhance the economic benefit of it. Thanks
Sign into reply to this topic.