Skip to content

Ask the Tutor ACCA FM

Straigh line method depreciation : Hawker co SD21 vs Telford co Mock March 2024

Aanisah2y ago
In Hawker co "SL tax allowable depreciation is available on the vehicle" The TAD is calculated using (cost-residual value)/4 Given cost= 34,000 Residual value=14000 (34000-14000)/4 =TAD of 5,000. Resulting tax benefit at tax rate 20% yr 1 to 4 = $1000 I find this approach simpler as it lead to equal TAD throughout the useful life. Whilst in Telford co (Pre March2024 mock in Test reach) "SLM over five years" Given cost =560,000 Residual value = 60000 The TAD is 112,000 for yr 1to 4 (tax benefit 22,400) Yr 5 BA is 52,000. (tax benefit 10400) The end result is the same I believe. Will both approach be accepted in the exams, Sir?
IAW3005IAW3005Tutor2y ago#1
Both approaches are correct and would be accepted in the exams, as they are consistent with the principles of calculating TAD using the straight-line method. The key is to apply the method consistently and correctly according to the tax rules specified in the exam question.
Aanisah2y ago#2
Thank you Sir.
Sign into reply to this topic.