Skip to content

Ask the Tutor ACCA AAA

September / december 2016

JLjihun lee7y ago
Sep / dec 2016, question name Raven&Co, part (b), in military research, shouldnt it be material & pervasive ? Because kaplan textbook says that If so confined, represent or could represent a substantial proportion of the financial statements is considered pervasive What does this substantial propotion mean ? Does it mean 50% of the materiality ? I do not understand when an item is considered as pervasive when materiality of militarity project already surpasses 10% Thank you.
KimKimTutor7y ago#1
I don't understand the explanation you have copied from the text (and I don't have a copy of the text), but please see here my explanation to a similar query https://opentuition.com/topic/poodle-june-13/
JLjihun lee7y ago#2
Hi tutor, I ve written down some parts from the text. It's considered pervasive if 1. Effectd are not confined to specific elements, accountd or items of financial statements (fs); or 2. If so confined could present or represent a substantial proportion of fs; or 3. Fundamental to users' understanding of fs in relation to disclosures. So when we see in no. 2, how do we determine that substantial proportion ? For materiality, we can determine using percentage calculation but im not sure how we determine that ' substantial proportion' I did understand no 1 and 3 but number 2 is quite ambiguous Thank you
KimKimTutor7y ago#3
You are not going to be asked to regurgitate explanations in a particular text. Simply understand that if you can say "except for this and except for that and except for the other. .. shows a T&F view" the FS as a WHOLE are still ok. Pervasive is extreme and related opinions exist more in theory than in practice.
Sign into reply to this topic.