Can I ask a silly question, when determining materiality. For example, year end is Sept 20x5. Audit date being July 20x5. Am I performing the materiality benchmark on 20x5 accounts or 20x4 accounts. I assumed 20x5 as the audit has already been done on the previous year, and the whole point is to have a balanced comparative. Why sometimes in answers materiality has been performed against 20x4.
Materiality Question
Welcome to my forum!
Could you please provide an example of a Q&A where you have seen this? So I can give a specific response?
In Q1 the default "today's" date is 1 July 20X5 - and, as this is a "planning" Q, the client will have a year endING at a future date - typically 30 September 20X5 (as in the last 4 published exams).
In other Qs, where dates are relevant, a client may have a year ENDED - i.e. it has past - e.g. in "completion and reporting" Qs.
A Q1 will usually give 20X5 "projected" with 20X4 "actual" and I would expect to see materiality using projected amounts.
However, as 1 July is only 9 months through the current year, if there are no reliable forecasts - say there are only interim results - and seasonal variations aren't reflected - using last year's actuals as a starting point would be reasonable. Remember that materiality is not fixed, but should be revised during the course of the audit as new information comes to light.

