Forums › ACCA Forums › ACCA AA Audit and Assurance Forums › F8 Results not convincing!!!
- This topic has 19 replies, 15 voices, and was last updated 8 years ago by nadine757.
- AuthorPosts
- January 20, 2016 at 12:15 am #296462
Hi Guys, Do you think that F8 results are fair?
Candidates who thought they would fail passed with high scores and other who nailed it failed!!, they should have rushed the marking to publish the results in one month???There must be something wrong!!
I was 100% sure that I would pass, but i failed F8 with 43% !!!
January 20, 2016 at 1:33 am #296464AnonymousInactive- Topics: 0
- Replies: 4
- ☆
I have the same feeling. I did very well (in my opinion). This is my second time. First time was 45%. And this time, I am totaly shocked with 35%.
January 20, 2016 at 8:16 am #296516I agree, I sat F7 which I had no confidence in whatsoever and missed half of the questions in section B but still scored 49% and i also sat F8 which I thought I nailed and i answered every question in full but also only got 49%. Something doesn’t seem right!
ACCA did mess up my F5 marking as they originally confirmed my results as 61% then a few weeks later emailed me to say they messed up and my score was actually 63% so I guess there’s hope that they will adjust their markings?
January 20, 2016 at 8:39 pm #296758I sat F7 F8 F9 with F7 being the worst of the three and F8 being the best.
Result? : Passed F7 but failed the others.I wrote so much for F8 that I was only 2 sides (1 page) away from finishing the answer booklet and requesting a new one.
I think we should stick to the point for F8 and only writing the number of points they want.
For example for a six point question (I think it was about the engagement letter) I should have only written 6 and not 8.I think what they do is only check the first points you’ve written and so if the first few are wrong and the last ones are correct, you’ll not gain any marks.
I don’t trust the marking scheme anymore but I am attempting to study to the point this time only.
January 20, 2016 at 9:02 pm #296764I agree with you all. I walked out the exam confident only to find out I failed
January 20, 2016 at 10:10 pm #296778Dont Give up
I passed this time with my 2nd attempt
Please watch more video lecturesJanuary 21, 2016 at 12:37 pm #296906Alright guys,
Do you think there is something we can do with ACCA to get them remark our papers again for december sitting? or adjust their marking??is there any possibility to sign a petition or something like that?
I feel like there is something wrong this time, you always know if you did well during the exam? don’t you? when you walk out you are either very confident that you will pass or just fail?
What do you think?
even the Admin review I think is useless??January 21, 2016 at 12:38 pm #296907we can write to the PQmagazine ??
January 21, 2016 at 1:39 pm #296925where did you sit your exam which got remarked ? did acca state why they marked it wrong? I got 48 in p7 advanced audit and would love the extra 2 marks although this probably will never happen!
January 21, 2016 at 2:28 pm #296945Guys I can understand your grief but the only thing I can suggest is to keep cool headed and just cut off the past – you cannot really do anything. They will not adjust their marking, they will not change their decision. Period.
They can only take into consideration external factors in the exam hall if you give complain and the ACCA team confirms unfavorable factors existed in this particular centre.
One thing I always told to myself is that you can never ever predict your final result.
I promise you I had 3 exams when I said after exam “Even I would fail myself” – yet the final result was pass. Is this fair I passed?They didn’t have to rush as in F levels 40 marks are automatically checked by computer right? MCQs 40 marks checked automatically.
If you scored 45-49 its not about lack of knowledge.
1. Exam technique – especially F8 requires a specific ‘technical’ way of writing. Do you know that F8 / P7 Audit exams are failed by experience auditors?
2. Time management – Did you really attempt full marks available?
3. Not answering the question set – you might have left the exam feeling I wrote such a good answer for that question when in reality you have been answering a different question (not understanding what is really being asked)
3a. Not applying/refering to scenario
4. Are you neat and tidy on exam? Decent handwriting, paragraphs, headings, conclusions, not crossing too often.January 22, 2016 at 1:30 am #297089@seagoat You are absolutely right, nothing will happen on ACCA side. Period.
But something is weird for sure: first time ever I walked out an exam and I was confident that it is a pass (managed time well, I had even 10 min to review, I used decent structure and formatting, I answered the questions, used specific precise answers, no guessing no bla-bla, checked the posted hybrid paper answers with mine, and no mistakes! etc.). First time ever I failed. With 48.
This is exactly what happened to many other candidate I personally know.
If it only happens to one candidate, that is lack of knowledge. If it happens to many of us, that there is a serious problem somewhere.
Did you guys use BPP revision kit and textbook?
Maybe the problem is there, maybe we study and practice in a wrong way.
Are Kaplan material users also in the same situation?January 22, 2016 at 7:46 am #297103@bloage, the problem most students find difficult with the paper F8 is they tend to believe they are writing the right answers where as they’re wrong, Take for example, a question requires you to point out certain audit risks that relate to a client, there’s every tendency for students to start picking up risks that are not necessarily relevant such as business risks, there’s also the possibility to have a good sight for the risk and end up writing so much.
such answers to me shouldn’t take more than two to three lines max. Your answers should hit the nail on the head, writing too much details would not be relevant, when a question that’s just one mark requires a short answer.
your question as regards bpp, i find bpp revision kit quite voluminous and bulky when describing model exam answers, when solving questions, try this approach; download the examiner’s own answers and compare your answers to that, this would help a great deal when solving questions. read up on the examiner’s comments about each exam diet, it would help you spot mistakes students make regularly when solving questions. an examiner’s comment i find reoccurring is that student’s state audit procedures with the word “CHECK” if you did this before, after reading this post i’m sure you wouldn’t anymore.
i hope you find this post useful.January 22, 2016 at 2:47 pm #297275Hi guys, my feeling is that the answer must be direct to the questions. 2-3 lines are good enough for each small point . Also, the answer format should be clear & easy to be understood by examiners. Too much writing and excellent grammar does not mean gain more marks if it is not relevant & understandable. Good reference is BPP test kit. It helped me passed F8 at 1st attempt .
January 24, 2016 at 12:30 am #297651Look i did all the things stated by DOA and zhou so did others these mistake you say are common so i was very careful about them and i know i only messed up one of my answer i know that for sure ,i checked sample answer and found i pointed out the correct ethical and control deficiencies and provided correct audit procedure. im convinced something must have happened
But in the end there’s nothing i could do but to prepare for march resit of f8.January 30, 2016 at 2:37 am #298502I feel the same way. This is my second time doing this exam and I failed again with the same pass 32%.How could I get the same exact mark? I was sure I was going to pass because the questions in my opinion was easy enough to understand. I did not finish the last question but that was one question, I did all the others the best of my ability, and I should have achieved at least 50% in each question. I am extremely frustrated right now as I have to redo this exam again. When I opened the results email and saw the fail my heart just sank into the earth. This is not fair I am extremely disappointed with ACCA and I am beginning to feel as though students are failed on purpose. I was studying since September hardcore and I did all the questions from BPP practice and revision kit. Does anyone else feel this way?
January 30, 2016 at 7:38 pm #298594Same for me, also Question 3 is not clear at all, please check our post “mispint for Question 3” by Vicki and myself.
I completely agree with all the others that ACCA is not correcting well since they have introduced 4 sittings in a year, I’ve the impression they have half the time for correction compared to what they had previously and consequently the quality of correction is impacted and worse the admin review is a complete waste as so many of us has complained. I wrote so many emails via myACCA and all they answered to me is that the admin review is just a re addition of numbers and nothing else. I have the chain emails I can send to anyone who wish to have a look. The main issue is they do NOT re correct anything they just go through the admin part ( addition and summing up) but what we want is a thorough remarking which is not being done and there is no existing process for this. Me too I was thinking to escalate this issue, but I don’t know where. Somebody mentioned about a petition, I’m ok for it but where to post it and to whom it should be addressed.@ D.O.A and SEAGOAT, true what you are saying is right: exam technique, time management, not to use CHECK etc, concretely I compared ALL my answers VS ACCA answers, except for MCQ which I don’t see at all and question 5 which is a September question ( I don’t know why they mixed up September and December in only one paper), I should have scored more than 50% in all areas, yet I got only 47. I’m really worried. Same thing for F7, I got 49 !!
Anyone can suggest to who shall we address this correction issue?
February 1, 2016 at 7:46 pm #298886@nzeadall I did consider paying for a review but that just seems like a waste of time now so I have decided to do over the exam in March. I do agree with you that it seems as though the quality standard has dropped with their correction process but like you said there really is no form of redress that students can take. I just hope that when I do the exam again the same person who corrected my December 2015 paper does not correct my March 2016 paper. There should be an online petition but ACCA has total autonomy and students would be afraid to be victimized if they sign this petition. I would like to see the chain of emails if you are still willing to share.
February 2, 2016 at 3:38 pm #298988@cloud9ali, indeed you are right, that’s the main issue “fear of being victimized” and this is worldwide. However, I’m confident that if we prepare a good case with concrete examples and taking good care to pass our message gracefully and objectively, they will take it positively. Our intention is not a blatant challenge against ACCA, we respect the institution as well as the markers, but what we want is a clear explanation or clarification on this uncomfortable situation we are all in. Come on ! We are paying for these exams and also the yearly subscription, the least we can expect is some explanations from them.
Send me your email ad and I’ll forward the chain mails to you.February 2, 2016 at 6:31 pm #299017Instead paying for review invest those money in taking a MOCK (or even few) with a tutor feedback. I think there must be something you are missing and only tutor may have an idea what it is.
December 2015 F8 global pass rate was quite nice 46%. Historically second highest, although it’s hard to compare different structures of exams.
March 24, 2016 at 5:49 am #308052Can we post our answers for pass exams papers and will someone help to correct and suggest ,where there are deficiancies
- AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.