Skip to content

Ask the Tutor ACCA SBR

Control

LLuna2y ago
Hi Sir, In BPP Q5 (d), why doesn’t the option to acquire 35% of the voting rights give Marley control over Cratchett? I don’t understand why the fixed price of the shares matters here. Thank you!
stephenwidbergstephenwidbergTutor2y ago#1
I don't have the Q. Please could you summarise and I'll get back to you. (Try not to copy and paste the whole Q. ) :)
LLuna2y ago#2
Thank you Stephen. Here’s a summary of the question: “Cratchett’s voting rights belong to Scrooge (70%) and Marley (30%). Marley has an option to buy 35% voting rights from Scrooge, exercisable for the next 2 years and at a fixed price that is deeply out of the money. The price is expected to remain so for that 2-year period. Explain if S or M should consolidate C under IFRS 10.”
stephenwidbergstephenwidbergTutor2y ago#3
Out the money = exercise price $10; current share price $20. Therefore unlikely to exercise option and obtain control. Therefore Marley would not treat C as a subsidiary. :)
LLuna2y ago#4
Sorry for asking. If Marley can use the option to buy shares at a cheaper price ($10), why is it unlikely to exercise the option?
stephenwidbergstephenwidbergTutor2y ago#5
My Fault :( Exercise price $30 Share price $20 Thank you for checking :)
Sign in to reply to this topic.