Foriegn subsidary and foreign loan

Hi there,

who can give me a summary of how to treat the exchange gain or loss in
1, retranslation of Foreign loan
2, translation of goodwill and net asset

As I know the exchange G/L for retranslate of foreign (loan cash, receivable payable )moneytary items is accounted into P/L

for consolidate accounts with foreign subsidary. exchange G/L from goodwill translation and Net asset translation should be accounted into OCI.

However, the question Jun 08 Ribby has accounted the exchange gain or loss in Retained earning.

While the question Jun 11 Rose foreign subsidary has accounted it in exchange reserves with an extra line in equity.

I thought the OCE stand for other than Retained earnings. therefore, OCI should be included in OCE. is it right?

Thanks
Katie