Hi Sir, Thank for your lecture. I have tried to consolidate the Financial Posotion statement of the 3 companies @31 Dec 20X5, but it is still unbalance. I think there is something wrong with my working on the NCI on the consolidated FS. I hop you can help. Asset: Non-current asset = 180 + 115 + 100 = 395 Goodwill = 10 + 23 = 33 (working previously from the lecture) Current asset = 80 + 90 + 60 = 150 Total asset = 395 + 33 + 150 = 578
Liability and equity: Non-current asset = 15 + 14 + 10 = 39 Current asset = 50 + 46 + 30 = 126 Share capital = 250 Retained earning = 110 (parent full retained earning) + 24 + 9 (subsidiary post retained earning) – 1 + 7 (effect of 31 Dec 2015 transaction) = 149 Non-controlling interest = 40 + 13 (NCI @ acquisition date) + 16 + 1 (NCI post acquisition RE) -14 + 28 (effect of 31 Dec 2015 transaction) = 84 Total Liability and equity = 39 + 126 + 250 +149 + 84 = 684
There are 70 mil unbalance, I can not spot the mistake.
Teacher, I think in Example 5, we should calculation ‘Carry value of 20% JONES’ shares disposal’ according to ‘Carry value of Net assets of JONES at 31/12/15 plus Goodwill of JONES at 1/1/15’ instead of use NCI (=14)*20/10. Check with ‘Example 5 technical articles acca IFRS 10’ and with ‘exmple 3 opentution note’
My opinion for JONES’ shares transactions is:
Carry amount of net assets of JONES at date of change equity (31/12/2015): = FV of net asset of JONES at acq-date (1/1/15) + Change JONES equity post acq-date (from 1/1/15-31/12/15) = (75+35) + (45-35) = 120 (Assumption that net book value of net assets at acq-date = FV of net asset at acq-date)
GW at acq-date (1/1/15) = 23 (for calculated above)
Therefore Carry amount of 20% share disposal = (120+23)*20% =28.6 So double entry: DR: Cash 35 CR: NCI 28.6 CR: RE 6.4
I think, In example 3 in the open tuition notes, the only way we could find the NCI is if we used the proportionate method. However, in this example 5, they require the Fair Value of the net assets
OCE include share premium, revaluation reserve, gains/losses on fair value through other comprehensive income investments.
Part 1 of the question involved a gain on disposal when cAlculate the goodwill, since part two is related to part 1, this might be the reason for debiting OCE instead of Retained earning?
I was wondering what exactly is the component in OCE thats reducing due to the transfer ? If its not the goodwill impairments and there are no revaluation gains or loss calculated then what is reducing within the OCE, what does that balancing figure of 1.1m represent ?
thanhvan0507 says
Hi Sir,
Thank for your lecture. I have tried to consolidate the Financial Posotion statement of the 3 companies @31 Dec 20X5, but it is still unbalance. I think there is something wrong with my working on the NCI on the consolidated FS. I hop you can help.
Asset:
Non-current asset = 180 + 115 + 100 = 395
Goodwill = 10 + 23 = 33 (working previously from the lecture)
Current asset = 80 + 90 + 60 = 150
Total asset = 395 + 33 + 150 = 578
Liability and equity:
Non-current asset = 15 + 14 + 10 = 39
Current asset = 50 + 46 + 30 = 126
Share capital = 250
Retained earning = 110 (parent full retained earning) + 24 + 9 (subsidiary post retained earning) – 1 + 7 (effect of 31 Dec 2015 transaction) = 149
Non-controlling interest = 40 + 13 (NCI @ acquisition date) + 16 + 1 (NCI post acquisition RE) -14 + 28 (effect of 31 Dec 2015 transaction) = 84
Total Liability and equity = 39 + 126 + 250 +149 + 84 = 684
There are 70 mil unbalance, I can not spot the mistake.
Paulo says
In example 6, is the date of disposal 2015 or 2012?
hieuht010198 says
Teacher,
I think in Example 5, we should calculation ‘Carry value of 20% JONES’ shares disposal’ according to ‘Carry value of Net assets of JONES at 31/12/15 plus Goodwill of JONES at 1/1/15’ instead of use NCI (=14)*20/10.
Check with ‘Example 5 technical articles acca IFRS 10’ and with ‘exmple 3 opentution note’
My opinion for JONES’ shares transactions is:
Carry amount of net assets of JONES at date of change equity (31/12/2015):
= FV of net asset of JONES at acq-date (1/1/15) + Change JONES equity post acq-date (from 1/1/15-31/12/15)
= (75+35) + (45-35) = 120
(Assumption that net book value of net assets at acq-date = FV of net asset at acq-date)
GW at acq-date (1/1/15) = 23 (for calculated above)
Therefore Carry amount of 20% share disposal = (120+23)*20% =28.6
So double entry:
DR: Cash 35
CR: NCI 28.6
CR: RE 6.4
faithnderitu says
I think, In example 3 in the open tuition notes, the only way we could find the NCI is if we used the proportionate method. However, in this example 5, they require the Fair Value of the net assets
lc5598 says
on the lecture notes it says debit RE not OCE? which one is the best option to debit?
qq419850428 says
OCE include share premium, revaluation reserve, gains/losses on fair value through other comprehensive income investments.
Part 1 of the question involved a gain on disposal when cAlculate the goodwill, since part two is related to part 1, this might be the reason for debiting OCE instead of Retained earning?
Zura says
As always, very useful and interesting lecture, thank’s tutor.
accajapass says
I have the same question as aditya7. Please explain why there is a reduction in OCE.
yashgupta04 says
Hello,
I also wanted to ask the same question as above.
Thanks
Yash
aditya7 says
Hi Chris,
thanks for the video lectures !
I was wondering what exactly is the component in OCE thats reducing due to the transfer ? If its not the goodwill impairments and there are no revaluation gains or loss calculated then what is reducing within the OCE, what does that balancing figure of 1.1m represent ?
Thanks.