Forums › Ask ACCA Tutor Forums › Ask the Tutor ACCA AAA Exams › Moritz & Co – Mar 2020 Question 3b
- This topic has 1 reply, 2 voices, and was last updated 4 years ago by Kim Smith.
- AuthorPosts
- November 6, 2020 at 7:51 am #594215
Dear tutor,
Below is the extract from ACCA answer. In the last sentence, is it recommending compilation engagement (to prepare share prospectus and to provide accountant report) as an action to be taken?
“Share prospectus
Moritz & Co has been asked to assist in the preparation of the share prospectus document and to provide an accountant’s report on financial data, business risks and a business plan which recommends the shares to investors. Performance of these services for Beaufort Co would create an advocacy threat for the auditor. The advocacy threat arises because the auditor is effectively being asked to promote and represent their client’s position to the point where the auditor’s objectivity is compromised. The Code prohibits an auditor from acting in this way for an audit client and Moritz & Co should politely decline to assist in the preparation of the document and to endorse the recommendation to investors to purchase the shares. It may be possible, however, for the auditor to provide an accountant’s report on some elements of the prospectus. Moritz & Co may be able to provide an opinion on the financial information if, for example, it limits the form of opinion to stating that it has been properly compiled on the basis stated within the document and that this basis is consistent with the accounting policies of the company.”November 6, 2020 at 12:10 pm #594253In the scenario “Margaret Shelley has asked if Mortiz & Co can also provide an accountant’s report which will be included in the prospectus and which will cover each of these elements.”
The requirement is to “comment”. The answer is commenting on rather than recommending the possibility of what would be a compilation engagement. It should seem commonsense that to provide any assurance on the compilation of financial information, Mortiz could not also compile it. Either:
– the client compiles it and the practitioner reports on it (assurance); or
– if the practitioner compiles it, there is no opinion/conclusion/assurance. - AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.