# December 2009 , Question 1 (a) : Help

Home Forums Ask ACCA Tutor Forums Ask the Tutor ACCA P5 Exams December 2009 , Question 1 (a) : Help

This topic contains 11 replies, has 7 voices, and was last updated by  mrfaizankhan 3 years ago. This post has been viewed 67 times

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
• Author
Posts

• hamid1
Member
• Topics: 2
• Replies: 0

Hi

In December 2009 exam , Question 1 (a) , the budget Tuition fee for 8000 students per annum is given as \$720,000.

Actual number of students for year ended 30 November 09 is: 6900. And in answers the figure for Tuition material is taken as \$92,000.

Can you please tell me how did they came out with \$92,000 tuition material cost ?

Thanks

John Moffat
Keymaster
• Topics: 3
• Replies: 3805

Two things….

Firstly you have read the wrong line – the tuition materials in the answer are 648,000 (92000 is the catering)

Secondly, to make comparing actual with budget useful for costs they have flexed the costs budget and calculated the budget cost for the actual number of students, which is 7200. So the calculation is 7200/8000 x 720,000 = 648000

princeacid
Participant
• Topics: 23
• Replies: 45

Thank you for your support John.

A good question by Hamid.

So by this you mean that what we call a ‘flex budget’ is actually flexed according to the ACTUAL DEMAND and than a new ‘budget’ is created to reflect the actual level of activity ?

neeru
Member
• Topics: 12
• Replies: 26

what i actually wanted to know is that how will we know that we have to use that actual demand for the calculation.
actually in Dec 2009 Q.1 the examiner has stated in the question that “Variable cost vary according to the number of students attending the courses at BEC”.
however nothing has been stated in the pilot paper question and still flex budgeting is used for both income n expenditure .
is it that for this type of question we should use the flex budgeting whether or not stated in the question…..???

princeacid
Participant
• Topics: 23
• Replies: 45

If the question mentions that the budgeted figures are for certain level of activity and the actual level of activity is also mentioned, than probably you have to flex the budget to draw a fairer comparison.

neeru
Member
• Topics: 12
• Replies: 26

ok…now i think that’s true….thank u very much princeacid…

princeacid
Participant
• Topics: 23
• Replies: 45

Pleasure @neeru.

all the best!

Anonymous
• Topics: 1
• Replies: 2

Dec 2009 1st question variable expenses have been flexed for 6900 students but revenues are not. Then how could it be the fair comparision. Please any one help me to clarify my doubt.

John Moffat
Keymaster
• Topics: 3
• Replies: 3805

It is a bit confusing, and the examiner did allow alternative answers. More obvious would be to flex both the revenue and the variable expenses (and this would have got full marks).
Certainly the costs have to be flexed since the question wanted the budgets to be comparable.
His logic in not flexing the revenue is that for revenue we are more interested in why it is different from the original budget.
However, what he has done is not a standard rule, and so do not worry too much about it.

asifrehman
Member
• Topics: 4
• Replies: 2

I was wandering here and there to ask the same question but was not satisfied. I am grateful to you all and especially OpenTuition Team and Honourable Tutor. Previously, I didnot get support from OpenTuition, but I will recommend it.

John Moffat
Keymaster
• Topics: 3
• Replies: 3805

You are welcome, and thank you

mrfaizankhan
Participant
• Topics: 11
• Replies: 29

Lolz about to post this question but found it…. solved my problem….Thanks everyone who helped in this post…..

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.