Investment Appraisal – Methods Accounting rate of return and Payback period

ACCA F9 lectures ACCA F9 notes


  1. avatar says

    Dear John,
    when we calculate the average investment of balance sheet for ARR calculation, why we simply divided by 2, why not by total numbers of years ?
    I am sorry if its a silly question to u!!!!!! but i really didnt get it. thank you.

  2. avatar says

    Hello, Sir!

    Could you please explain why we don’t take into account scrap value when calculating the average profit? When we sell the machine at the end of 4 year we will get the $10 000 for it. This is our income.

    • Profile photo of John Moffat says

      Scrap proceeds never appear in profit statements (they do not when we do financial accounts, and ARR is an accounting measure)!!!

      We take them into account when we calculate the deprecation, which does appear in the Statement of profit or loss.

      • avatar says

        Thank you very much, Mr Moffat.

        Also I have two more questions. Unfortunately, I cann’t find link to forum, that’s why I write them here.
        I’ve made practise question 6 Gold.

        1. In answers payback period is calculated as = 4 + 1/8 = 4.125. How you get 1/8? I calculated it as = 4 + 1000/23000 (cash flow for year 5) = 4.04.

        2. I don’t agree with the answer b, part ii.
        The question is “Is it worth equipping the new premises”.
        In answers you take the market value of the new premises into consideration.
        But for me – market value is not a cash flow and it doesn’t depend on the way of equipment. I think that market value is irrelevant information. And also it’s told that Bronze has recently expanded into new premises. This means Bronze has already bought it.

      • Profile photo of John Moffat says

        1. The cash flow in year 5 is 8,000 (the 15,000 will not come until the very end of the year).

        2. They have indeed already bought new premises. However, they are deciding whether or not to move into them. If they don’t move in then they sell them for 2.6M, so it is an opportunity cost of using them.

        In future, you must ask in the forums or questions other than on the lectures will not be answered. There is a tab at the top of the page that says on it ‘ACCA Forums’!!

  3. avatar says

    Dear John Sir,

    You have said that if he cast the depreciation, I am a little confused that how you took 80,000 did you just assumed it or the examiner would tell us what value to use , If you give some explanation on this it would be very nice of you .

    Thank You I am getting F9 lectures very easily and I can understand them all credit goes to you .

    Thanks :)

  4. avatar says

    Sir , today i was doing ARR questions in a class , and i have deducted the scrap value from the cost of machine but my lecturer told me its a wrong method , but i was doing this every time when i have scrap value in a question , i m confused , i don’t know what to do , help me sir please ..

    • Profile photo of John Moffat says

      For ARR you need the average investment in the Statement of financial position (balance sheet). This is (initial investment + scrap value) /2.

      Think about this. Suppose you bought a machine with a cost of 100,000 and a scrap value of zero. The value in the SOFP would fall each year (because of depreciation) and the average value would be 50,000.

      Now suppose you bought the same machine with the same cost, but with a scrap value of 20,000. The value in the SOFP would again fall each year, but only down to 20,000.

      Surely, the average value in the second case would be higher than in the first case?

      The average value in the second case would be (100,000 + 20,000) / 2 = 60,000.

      I hope that makes sense.
      You might find the free lectures on investment appraisal useful :-)

      (and I am surprised that your lecturer did not explain to you the reason for adding the scrap value!!)

      • avatar says

        No Sir , i m talking about deducting the scrap value from the cost of machine when you are working out total depreciation , like e.g total cashflows less total depreciation (cost – scrap value) and my lecturer didn’t deduct the scrap value from the cost of machine , the average investment part i already understood by your lectures thanks..

      • Profile photo of John Moffat says

        Sorry for misunderstanding your question.

        The total depreciation over the life of the machine will certainly be the initial cost less any scrap value.
        I cannot think of a situation that would result in your lecturer telling you different. It seems very strange!

        (He was definitely talking about ARR calculations, and not discounted cash flow calculations?)

      • avatar says

        Thanks a lot Sir , i owe you , i have been passing all the ACCA papers of which you taught us because the way you teach is more effective , I do really enjoy your lectures and thank you for your very interesting lectures , I appreciate everything and I’ve learned a lot’ ..

Leave a Reply